EDFL Premier Discussion 2025

[Pick it up]

Not sure whose in more trouble, Wallan or Abers!

 

[Nepotism]

Aberfeldie are in the biggest trouble.

 

[pokka10]

I can’t believe I had to do this, but you’re selecting pieces out what I posted

I said at clubs like strathmore keilor riddle etc and refered to the responsibility that comes with it. It’s well known clubs such as this need to have what I stated below referring to juniors Etc

if saying something is not a strength is an attack or a bad word on someone then that’s not right. Nobody is perfect and flawless ? Stop being ridiculous. He like me and you and everyone In The world has flaws.
You have just gone through what I said and picked out words, picked them up together and formed a sentence to try and strengthen your views against someone else who won’t support you.

Saying someone isn’t good enough at coaching is not a bad word it’s an opinion.
End of.

From what I have heard and seen of you mate you’re not good at much but somehow are going to be president I don’t know ash but sounds like he dodged a bullet getting away from your club.

 

[Gremlin77]

Aberfeldie are in the biggest trouble.

Comparing Tudor to Christofi is something

 

[MortlockWatcher]

He has NFI.

 

[Turbos mail]

He has NFI.

Who?

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Nepotist

 

[ONTHEPROWL]

Hearing from several people that West Preston have signed Pascoe Vale’s captain

 

[danger_wood]

Hearing from several people that West Preston have signed Pascoe Vale’s captain

Interesting. Is this the same captain that was a key figure in knifing Tudor?

 

[late inclusion]

Strathmore fans v Ash's fluffer. Boring.

That's consecutive coaches that have been moved on from Strathmore under questionable circumstances & in turn had it play out on social media.
For a well run club, they seem to mishandle coaching changes.

2022 - Flag
2023 - lost GF to Keilor
2024 - lost prelim
2025 - Flag
Don’t think they have suffered much from the “mishandling”

 

[Town centre oval]

Lerka has been appointed as the new coach of AbersLatest One that lives a drop punt away from ground

I thought he moved interstate? Or is he flying in to coach!!!

As i mentioned lives a drop punt away from all reports commutes interstate occasionally for work

 

[BC04]

2022 - Flag
2023 - lost GF to Keilor
2024 - lost prelim
2025 - Flag
Don’t think they have suffered much from the “mishandling”

Can do things with transparency. Do you know how you know the club knows they’re in the wrong….

When you post a coaching announcement and turn off anyone’s ability to make comments hahaha.

At least we confirm the Strathmore officials are the bigfooty pair… imagine mentioning bigfooty in a coach interview… bahahaha.

 

[Localsport]

When will abers announce their new coach

Good to see that Strathmore didn’t let Abers have all the limelight tonight….

They posted Horne appointment 30mins ago

 

[BlueJet]

2022 - Flag
2023 - lost GF to Keilor
2024 - lost prelim
2025 - Flag
Don’t think they have suffered much from the “mishandling”

Given the latest dismissal occurred post-2025 flag, none of us would have any idea whether they have suffered for it yet..

 

[Turbos mail]

Comparing Tudor to Christofi is something

Both had questionable coaching history from previous roles.

Tudor is an interesting one as if he was given the boot by Pacco you might think clubs would be cautious. Don’t know the full story but from the outside I’m amazed Abers went there.

 

[PortVic]

Good to see that Strathmore didn’t let Abers have all the limelight tonight….

They posted Horne appointment 30mins ago

No mention of Nick! And comments turned off.

 

[fair crack]

Both had questionable coaching history from previous roles.

Tudor is an interesting one as if he was given the boot by Pacco you might think clubs would be cautious. Don’t know the full story but from the outside I’m amazed Abers went there.

Given the boot by Essendon VFL too. Gotta wonder.

 

[Town centre oval]

No mention of Nick! And comments turned off.

Luke Jarrod to ocean grove

 

[benny89]

I’m new to the Edfl scene, what’s the positives if any about Pat. Only heard negatives throughout both this and the rdfnl forums. Given I live in wallan and watch their games, forgive the ignorance

 

[PortVic]

I’m new to the Edfl scene, what’s the positives if any about Pat. Only heard negatives throughout both this and the rdfnl forums. Given I live in wallan and watch their games, forgive the ignorance

Probably a question for Bashen

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Both had questionable coaching history from previous roles.

Tudor is an interesting one as if he was given the boot by Pacco you might think clubs would be cautious. Don’t know the full story but from the outside I’m amazed Abers went there.

At least Tudor has a credible coaching CV
PC on the other hand...

 

[Stax on the mill]

I’m new to the Edfl scene, what’s the positives if any about Pat. Only heard negatives throughout both this and the rdfnl forums. Given I live in wallan and watch their games, forgive the ignorance

He’s got deep pockets, and not afraid to spend it.

 

[fair crack]

At least Tudor has a credible coaching CV
PC on the other hand...

Does he ? In the last 5yrs?
Wouldn’t think ESS VFL and Pascoe would agree.

 

[Gremlin77]

Both had questionable coaching history from previous roles.

Tudor is an interesting one as if he was given the boot by Pacco you might think clubs would be cautious. Don’t know the full story but from the outside I’m amazed Abers went there.

Does he ? In the last 5yrs?
Wouldn’t think ESS VFL and Pascoe would agree.

What’s your beef with Tudor Fair Crack ? A lot of your posts revolve around potting him since he arrived at Pacco ?

His football resume speaks for itself, the only man to ever get Pacco to a GF and is a VFL premiership coach. To be even mentioned in the same sentence as Pat is moronic.

Some serious coaches in this comp McGuane, Rock, Tudor, Prendegast, Holland …. You might want to concentrate on your own backyard and be sure Harris is up to standard.

Can’t stand Abers but this is their best chance to be successful with all the young talent and resources. Will be no excuses for Tudor, let’s see how he goes

 

[fair crack]

What’s your beef with Tudor Fair Crack ? A lot of your posts revolve around potting him since he arrived at Pacco ?

His football resume speaks for itself, the only man to ever get Pacco to a GF and is a VFL premiership coach. To be even mentioned in the same sentence as Pat is moronic.

Some serious coaches in this comp McGuane, Rock, Tudor, Prendegast, Holland …. You might want to concentrate on your own backyard and be sure Harris is up to standard.

Can’t stand Abers but this is their best chance to be successful with all the young talent and resources. Will be no excuses for Tudor, let’s see how he goes

No beef, just going by all the posts that have been done questioning his coaching.
Wonder why he has been sacked from last 2 positions, more so VFL that Pascoe vale.
I feel that GF team was built by Diggby over the past few years ? Correct me if I’m wrong.
Don’t know him personally as a bloke.
Hope all teams are competitive in the next season.