Fyfe or Scully

[Pegasaur]

Fyfe has recently signed a deal with Freo and is now the 3rd highest paid Docker (behind Sandilands and Pav), while if Scully goes to GWS he will be the highest paid at the club (unless they somehow recruit Dale Thomas, which will cost them $100 000 000 per year ).

My question is if you had the option which one would you take and how much would you pay them?

 

[gaz15]

Fyfe by a little bit. Scully has all the attributes to be a champ, but Fyfe is nearly there already. Absolute gun!

 

[GordonBlue]

Fyfe... tbh I don't what all the fuss is about when it comes to Scully... yes he is good... but gee Fyfe is one special player... has everything you would love in a player

 

[Hodgepodge]

Scully is too injury prone, and apparently has a chronic knee condition that will need to be managed, ala Cooney.

Fyfe is just a freak of a player.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

At this point in time, Fyfe - I want to see if Scully's injuries are going to continue plagueing him

 

[Deledio_Judd]

Fyfe, has just showed more. Scully's knee problems scares me a bit as well, has shown a lot though

 

[Tulip]

Fyfe by a little bit. Scully has all the attributes to be a champ, but Fyfe is nearly there already. Absolute gun!

same for me.

 

[Mr Magic]

Fyfe... tbh I don't what all the fuss is about when it comes to Scully... yes he is good... but gee Fyfe is one special player... has everything you would love in a player

Interested to here Carlton supporters views on Fyfe because seems to me to be a contemporary bigger version of a Ken Hunter which isn't necessarily a bad thing!