Club Focus Gold Coast 2021 - Chol, Andrew, Constable

[H00t]

Your overrating draft picks and underrating proven players.

I would not be giving up pick 5 for Balta or Lynch so he’s picked an group to put up for being worth that. Even Martin probably doesn’t fit GC window. Bolton is a pick 5 though.

Looking at Richmond list I can’t really see anyone else who I’d give up pick 5 for. If a couple of Richmond players where younger definitely.

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

unlikely we could make a single trade that would be suitable ie. pick 5 for x


we want key position players
Brisbane want to move up the order.

can we give gc 2021 1st (pick 5) and Carlton 3rd round (42)

Get back jack payne, BL 2021 1st (pick 16), Melbourne 2021 1st (pick 18)

Then give one of those 1sts for CCJ?

Giving up a valuable asset for unproven players..
but the players have more value for us.
The picks have more value for others.

Gc give: pick 5, pick 42
Gc get: Payne, CCJ, pick 16

BL give: Payne, 16, 18
BL get: pick 5, pick 42

ricmond give: CCJ
Richmond get: pick 18


makes suns immediately better on field
Allows bris to move up the order
Give Richmond a fair pick if CCJ wants to leave for opportunity.

 

[Turbocat]

No way near Pick 5, from Richmond only Dustin Martin, Tom Lynch & Noah Balta are worth pick 5

which player in the draft is worth those players...

 

[anotherletdown]

Would love to have their pick but no idea how we'd make it happen.... although.... Parker hasn't signed yet

 

[boncer34]

Call me crazy but

Pick five and a future 3rd for

Tom Mitchell and one of our early 2nds this year.

Fair?

Nobody is giving you a top 10 pick for Mitchell

 

[Pure_Ownage]

No one who is worth pick 5 will want to go there so i cant see them trading it.

 

[carnthedons]

unlikely we could make a single trade that would be suitable ie. pick 5 for x


we want key position players
Brisbane want to move up the order.

can we give gc 2021 1st (pick 5) and Carlton 3rd round (42)

Get back jack payne, BL 2021 1st (pick 16), Melbourne 2021 1st (pick 18)

Then give one of those 1sts for CCJ?

Giving up a valuable asset for unproven players..
but the players have more value for us.
The picks have more value for others.

Gc give: pick 5, pick 42
Gc get: Payne, CCJ, pick 16

BL give: Payne, 16, 18
BL get: pick 5, pick 42

ricmond give: CCJ
Richmond get: pick 18


makes suns immediately better on field
Allows bris to move up the order
Give Richmond a fair pick if CCJ wants to leave for opportunity.

CCJ gets to live closer to his fave kebab shop too, win for all

 

[carnthedons]

And that's exactly why it also involves a pick upgrade for GC. Values Mitchell at an end of first round pick. You can read, correct?

Based on the arbitrary pick points system yeah? It’s not really relevant unless a club needs points for a particular player. Would you rather have p5 and 40 something but have to give up 22 or 15-18 on it’s own? Yeah, thought so.

 

[eastfreo75]

Could only see something happening if it's with a side in the bottom 10 and they swap firsts like a Freo, Essendon, or Saints.

Send your pick back a few places only for a 5 year best 22 player. Not sure who. Walters on the outer at Freo isn't he? Or is that just another Sumich special?

How so Suma?

 

[M Malice]

What about Shai Bolton for pick 5?

I'd give up pick 5 in a heart beat for Shai Bolton if I were the Suns.

 

[M Malice]

BL give: Payne, 16, 18
BL get: pick 5, pick 42

Too much to give up and not enough in return for the Lions IMO, Payne is an extremely promising KPD and I wouldn't want to lose him.

Substitute Payne for Rhys Matheison and Archie Smith and we have a deal.

 

[Ants]

They should have traded up with North last year. Offered their pick #5 last year and this year's first to North for #2 and North's 2021 R2. Would have guaranteed them one of McDonald or Thillithorpe, and they really need a good tall to support King.

Given the quality of players who will be willing to go to GCS, their #19 or North's R2 would have been about the right value for most of them as well.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

And that's exactly why it also involves a pick upgrade for GC. Values Mitchell at an end of first round pick. You can read, correct?

On paper it probably values him that way. Not sure gcs would

 

[CatToTheFuture]

How so Suma?

Isn't he the irate former employee spreading bad information? Like Darcy and Tucker to Geelong etc?

 

[Freoforever86]

If GCS do that, they should shut down the club.

Feel like Gil would need to step in on that one.

hey GC… no

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

unlikely we could make a single trade that would be suitable ie. pick 5 for x


we want key position players
Brisbane want to move up the order.

can we give gc 2021 1st (pick 5) and Carlton 3rd round (42)

Get back jack payne, BL 2021 1st (pick 16), Melbourne 2021 1st (pick 18)

Then give one of those 1sts for CCJ?

Giving up a valuable asset for unproven players..
but the players have more value for us.
The picks have more value for others.

Gc give: pick 5, pick 42
Gc get: Payne, CCJ, pick 16

BL give: Payne, 16, 18
BL get: pick 5, pick 42

ricmond give: CCJ
Richmond get: pick 18


makes suns immediately better on field
Allows bris to move up the order
Give Richmond a fair pick if CCJ wants to leave for opportunity.

unlikely we could make a single trade that would be suitable ie. pick 5 for x


we want key position players
Brisbane want to move up the order.

can we give gc 2021 1st (pick 5) and Carlton 3rd round (42)

Get back jack payne, BL 2021 1st (pick 16), Melbourne 2021 1st (pick 18)

Then give one of those 1sts for CCJ?

Giving up a valuable asset for unproven players..
but the players have more value for us.
The picks have more value for others.

Gc give: pick 5, pick 42
Gc get: Payne, CCJ, pick 16

BL give: Payne, 16, 18
BL get: pick 5, pick 42

ricmond give: CCJ
Richmond get: pick 18


makes suns immediately better on field
Allows bris to move up the order
Give Richmond a fair pick if CCJ wants to leave for opportunity.

I’d just be using your two second and third rounder to get those deals done and go for the top end talent in the draft at 5.

 

[Freoforever86]

Isn't he the irate former employee spreading bad information? Like Darcy and Tucker to Geelong etc?

he’s got a dart board at home with every non WA Freo player.

Throws a dart once a week and sees what he can come up with.

 

[boncer34]

And that's exactly why it also involves a pick upgrade for GC. Values Mitchell at an end of first round pick. You can read, correct?

You might want to do the maths on that before becoming condescending.

5 + 3rd for 2nd doesn't = late first.

 

[eastfreo75]

Isn't he the irate former employee spreading bad information? Like Darcy and Tucker to Geelong etc?

Same guy who says he has inside info but he got sacked and marched out of Fremantle in 2016 because he was leaking info to the media.

Told the world that Sean Darcy is leaving for Geelong and a month Darcy extends his contract by another 2 years. Sean tells he it was no brainer decision because he loves the club.

 

[GoldenMagpie16]

Pick 5 for Jordan De Goey

2

Jordan De Goey

Age

28

Ht

188cm

Wt

93kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.7

4star

K

10.0

4star

HB

6.7

4star

M

3.9

4star

T

3.1

5star

CL

2.3

4star

D

15.8

4star

K

9.7

4star

HB

6.2

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

1.7

3star

CL

2.3

4star

D

11.6

3star

K

6.2

3star

HB

5.4

4star

M

1.4

2star

T

4.8

5star

CL

2.6

5star

?

 

[Polo342]

What would Lobb and Walters get us from GC? Would be going backwards but so much outside noise!!

 

[The 747]

Pick 5 for Jordan De Goey?

Crazy to do that for GCS. Would not be a good influence.

 

[SnusCG]

Pick 5 for Jordan De Goey?

No club in their right mind would touch Jordan De Goey for a first round pick. The bloke is a negative asset for a club.

- Currently being charged with sexual assault
- Broke his hand assaulting people at a bar and lied to the club about how it happened
- Notably poor training standards and arriving to multiple pre-seasons overweight
- And expects ridiculously high wages for being either:
A) a mid that can't play out the game on ball.
or
B) a forward that has only kicked more than 2 goals in a game 4 time in the last 2 seasons.

 

[pupstar]

I would not be giving up pick 5 for Balta or Lynch so he’s picked an group to put up for being worth that. Even Martin probably doesn’t fit GC window. Bolton is a pick 5 though.

Looking at Richmond list I can’t really see anyone else who I’d give up pick 5 for. If a couple of Richmond players where younger definitely.

I am pretty confident the Tigers would not even dream about giving up Balta for pick 5 absolute gun

 

[Northernsoul74]

Pick 5 for Jordan De Goey?

De Goey living on the Gold Coast. What could go wrong?