Good Call / Bad Call

[RoosterLad]

Stupid call. I hate Port and even I know that the PAFC from the SANFL moved into the AFL with a new club called the PAMFC being created to fill the void.

 

[JunX]

Stupid call. I hate Port and even I know that the PAFC from the SANFL moved into the AFL with a new club called the PAMFC being created to fill the void.

Relax lad... Just stirring the pot...

 

[RoosterLad]

Yeah... stir the Port pot on the Adelaide board....

 

[sbenno]

restart the thread...

The Crows of 09, given the opportunity, are unable to thrash a side, resulting in our poor percentage

 

[Jilly]

restart the thread...

The Crows of 09, given the opportunity, are unable to thrash a side, resulting in our poor percentage

Terrific call. We have been given the opportunity to blow games wide open, yet we didn't.

Based on talk about the possibility of one of our legends retiring, my question is..
McLeod, Edwards and Goodwin will all play on next year.

 

[jackster83]

Terrific call. We have been given the opportunity to blow games wide open, yet we didn't.

Based on talk about the possibility of one of our legends retiring, my question is..
McLeod, Edwards and Goodwin will all play on next year.

Too early to call. Edwards looks certain to go on next year as he has been terrific this year (better than last year). Goodwin has been playing reasonably well, racking up good numbers but isn't quite getting the kicking penetration he used to. If he gets over this injury, then he is quite likely to play on next year. McLeod is the tough one: round 1 and the last 3 weeks he has been pretty good, but apart from that he hasn't really had the spring in his step that he used to. I don't think he enjoys the heavy tagging that he has been copping, although playing as an attacking wingman coming off the bench has helped free him up a little. With him, it's a matter of whether he wants to play on (he wont be delisted).

We should trade heavily to secure either Griffen or Burgoyne jr

 

[crowman86]

We should trade heavily to secure either Griffen or Burgoyne jr

Trying to get this thread going again.

Good call, with the lack of talent in the draft this year and us having possible trade bait (Griff and Radar) it is important that we look to securing a proven player to help bolster our midfield or a small crumbing forward role.

Crows should play more youngsters (Armstrong, Davis) before the finals this year for 2 games like Otten and Danger last year so they know what they are working towards over the pre season.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Trying to get this thread going again.

Good call, with the lack of talent in the draft this year and us having possible trade bait (Griff and Radar) it is important that we look to securing a proven player to help bolster our midfield or a small crumbing forward role.

Crows should play more youngsters (Armstrong, Davis) before the finals this year for 2 games like Otten and Danger last year so they know what they are working towards over the pre season.

Bad call - players should be picked on form not because they are young. Craig has already showed this year he will reward young players on performance, so this should continue. Having said that, don't be surprised if particularly the former gets picked as would have already played if not for room-mates flu.

Will Kurt Tippett & Taylor Walker kick more combined career goals than Tony Modra & Darren Jarman?

 

[jenny61_99]

Will Kurt Tippett & Taylor Walker kick more combined career goals than Tony Modra & Darren Jarman?

Way too early to call! Jarman was a legend of the game, and Mods was a freak of nature - not too often you get to see players of that quality.
While both Tippett and Walker show great promise, it really is too early to call.

The new game plan looks very promising and should deliver great things - probably earlier than most of us anticipated.

 

[King Elvis]

Part game plan, but also a hell of a lot to do with the quality of the players executing it.

Good Call / Bad call is lame.

 

[RoosterLad]

Good call.

 

[jenny61_99]

Good call.

Spoil sport call! Well that just put paid to that then didn't it? How to kill a thread!

You two are party poopers!

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Spoil sport call! Well that just put paid to that then didn't it? How to kill a thread!

You two are party poopers!

Good call if they don't like the thread then stay out, who do they think they are maccas_no1?

Bringing the Birdman back this week is too early.

 

[Mego Red]

Spoil sport call! Well that just put paid to that then didn't it? How to kill a thread!

You two are party poopers!

Bad call. They're actually d-bags, which I think is something worse.

There is a trade out there for Kurt Tippett that we should do this off season.

 

[King Elvis]

Good call if they don't like the thread then stay out, who do they think they are maccas_no1?

Bringing the Birdman back this week is too early.

Good Call.

Needs another week in the SANFL, not only that, Sellar/SMck need another week in the AFL. Although Tex could force one out anyway.

Bad call. They're actually d-bags, which I think is something worse.

There is a trade out there for Kurt Tippett that we should do this off season.

Bad Call - unless he desparately wants to go home and, like Johnson/Stenglein, is happy to go when we find the best trade for him.

What's a d-bag?

Least Jenny has a sense of humour

 

[razorsedge]

That phrase DEFENSIVE PRESSURE !
AFC website
Backs
Goodwin Tackles 19
Bock Tackles 10
Rutten 12

Forwards
Tippett 45
Danger 26
Walker 25
Porps 53
Knights 37
Who really is applying pressure when the ball is in dispute !

 

[RoosterLad]

Confused call.

 

[Witty Remark]

That phrase DEFENSIVE PRESSURE !
AFC website
Backs
Goodwin Tackles 19
Bock Tackles 10
Rutten 12

Forwards
Tippett 45
Danger 26
Walker 25
Porps 53
Knights 37
Who really is applying pressure when the ball is in dispute !

Bad Call . Wrong thread. Red Card?

18 is too many teams for the AFL competition.

 

[Smoooothy]

Bad Call . Wrong thread. Red Card?

18 is too many teams for the AFL competition.

good call, but i would just about bet lefty we'll be back to 16 pretty quick after both teams come back in..

AFC is the most awesomest fantastic wonderfully sexy football club eva!!!!

 

[cmndstab]

good call, but i would just about bet lefty we'll be back to 16 pretty quick after both teams come back in..

AFC is the most awesomest fantastic wonderfully sexy football club eva!!!!

Bad call, we were much sexier when we had Jericho's golden locks in our side


We will pick up no KPPs at all in the upcoming national draft.