Good Call / Bad Call

[cmndstab]

Bad call. From the impression ive been given, hes as good as stuffed. Degenerative hip problems. Wont be back.

The Crows will keep atleast two of their current rookies next season

Good call. Difficult to see Schmidt or Donnelly upgraded or delisted.

If Henderson hadn't been tipped off to us last season Schmidt would have been our only rookie taken.

 

[jarmanagic]

Always? Mark Bickley ring any bells?

Bickley in top 7 both years (Rehn, Jarman, Mcleod, Hart, Smart, Roo then him, Modra in 97, Caven in 98 around the mark)

Crows 2009 B&F (no order after top 2)
Edwards, Thompson, Goodwin, Tippet, Danger, Mackay, Vince, Bock, Rutten, Doughty, Porps, Knights, Johncock, Otten and maybe Walker, Douglas would be ahead of VB. Probably

VB had a poor year in 09. Looks to have turned corner last week, hope he has

Back to good call/bad call

Porps in the most skilled player we've had since D Jarman

 

[Southerntakeover]

Crows 2009 B&F (no order after top 2)
Edwards, Thompson, Goodwin, Tippet, Danger, Mackay, Vince, Bock, Rutten, Doughty, Porps, Knights, Johncock, Otten and maybe Walker, Douglas would be ahead of VB. Probably

Honestly... this is a ridiculously bad call.

 

[jarmanagic]

Honestly... this is a ridiculously bad call.

tell me where he'd be right now in the B&F? and who he'd be ahead of in my list?

 

[Brenton Davy]

Bickley in top 7 both years (Rehn, Jarman, Mcleod, Hart, Smart, Roo then him, Modra in 97, Caven in 98 around the mark)

Crows 2009 B&F (no order after top 2)
Edwards, Thompson, Goodwin, Tippet, Danger, Mackay, Vince, Bock, Rutten, Doughty, Porps, Knights, Johncock, Otten and maybe Walker, Douglas would be ahead of VB. Probably

VB had a poor year in 09. Looks to have turned corner last week, hope he has

Back to good call/bad call

Porps in the most skilled player we've had since D Jarman

Good Call. Probably the best call of the thread. Sublime skills and less of a larrikin than Fud. Will be more useful.

SMACK should debut against Richmond, only because of their lack of quality ruckman.

 

[Southerntakeover]

tell me where he'd be right now in the B&F? and who he'd be ahead of in my list?

I dont think you really understand how a best and fairest works. You've confused profile with performance.

I there are maybe 5 or 6 of those players i think are justifiable.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Good Call. Probably the best call of the thread. Sublime skills and less of a larrikin than Fud. Will be more useful.

SMACK should debut against Richmond, only because of their lack of quality ruckman.

Good call, put him in against a team that doesn't have a massive ruckman that will smash him and lets see what he has got.

Can we ask non Crows related questions?

The worst decision at AFL house in the last ten years was not getting Brian Cunningham in there.

 

[Brenton Davy]

Good call, put him in against a team that doesn't have a massive ruckman that will smash him and lets see what he has got.

Can we ask non Crows related questions?

The worst decision at AFL house in the last ten years was not getting Brian Cunningham in there.

Good call. Far better administrator than Vlad ever would be and I think would have surrounded himself with far more competent people than the likes of Adrian Anderson.

The one to retire at the end of this year will be Goody, not Macca as most of us think, due to persistent injuries.

 

[whitey_1975]

The worst decision at AFL house in the last ten years was not getting Brian Cunningham in there.

Excellent call, the duffer we have in POWER now was a pro vic choice with pro vic results, ie cashing up poor vic clubs. Bucky is a very fair man in my opinion would have made a great league boss.

The one to retire at the end of this year will be Goody, not Macca as most of us think, due to persistent injuries.

Bad call, Goody is playing better and more consistant footy than Macca. Sadly. Macca is the next best to Roo no doubt in my opinion
Are the people calling for Kite to be delisted at years end complete morons?

 

[Witty Remark]

Are the people calling for Kite to be delisted at years end complete morons?

Sorry whitey that's a question, not a statement and so unfortunately i can't call it !

Steve Quarterbrain in the worst AFL commentator at the moment.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Sorry whitey that's a question, not a statement and so unfortunately i can't call it !

Steve Quarterbrain in the worst AFL commentator at the moment.

Impossible call cause there are so many that are so poor it isn't funny.

For all their hype and bluster Collingwood are the most over rated underachieving club in Australian and even possibly world sport.

 

[macca23]

For all their hype and bluster Collingwood are the most over rated underachieving club in Australian and even possibly world sport.

Good Call.

One flag in 50 years, yet they walk around like gorillas thumping their chest espousing that they are the greatest. Pffft!!

Tony Shaw is actually the worst, most illiterate, most biased commentator (loose use of the word) on TV, radio or even pedal wireless.

 

[cmndstab]

Good Call.

One flag in 50 years, yet they walk around like gorillas thumping their chest espousing that they are the greatest. Pffft!!

Tony Shaw is actually the worst, most illiterate, most biased commentator (loose use of the word) on TV, radio or even pedal wireless.

Bad call, those jokers on 6PR are the worst. I don't remember their names but they are just shocking in every sense of the work.


The Crows will not miss the finals for the next four years.

 

[Lets Beyblade]

Good Call.

One flag in 50 years, yet they walk around like gorillas thumping their chest espousing that they are the greatest. Pffft!!

Tony Shaw is actually the worst, most illiterate, most biased commentator (loose use of the word) on TV, radio or even pedal wireless.

Bad Call

As long as Jakovich is still commentating he will always take the pedestal of shame. To back up my claim here is a quote: 'Cream to the top rises'

The Crows will not miss the finals for the next four years.

Good Call

We are consistant finals attendees and our list indicates that this is not about to change.

Armstrong will play an AFL game this season.

 

[Deaneus!]

Bad Call

As long as Jakovich is still commentating he will always take the pedestal of shame. To back up my claim here is a quote: 'Cream to the top rises'

Who does he think he is, Yoda?


Good Call

We are consistant finals attendees and our list indicates that this is not about to change.

Armstrong will play an AFL game this season.

Good call. Named an emergency a number of times, and we're thin on depth.

Walker will be dropped to the SANFL before the end of the season.

 

[beartoo]

Walker will be dropped to the SANFL before the end of the season.[/B]

Good call. Looked like he'd hit the wall last week. He'll be back and will be a force for us for a lot of years.

Thommo, Porps, Bock & Otten will all poll more than once in the Brownlow this year.

 

[cmndstab]

Good call. Looked like he'd hit the wall last week. He'll be back and will be a force for us for a lot of years.

Thommo, Porps, Bock & Otten will all poll more than once in the Brownlow this year.

Bad call, I can't see Otten polling more than once (even though he probably deserves to!), though the other three will all poll more than once.

Will Young's development or not into a full back will be instrumental to the club's success in the next decade.

 

[Smoooothy]

Bad call, I can't see Otten polling more than once (even though he probably deserves to!), though the other three will all poll more than once.

Will Young's development or not into a full back will be instrumental to the club's success in the next decade.

not sure call - very hard to tell at this stage, but there are good signs

Taylor Walker is the next Buddy

 

[Alex99]

not sure call - very hard to tell at this stage, but there are good signs

Taylor Walker is the next Buddy

Bad call – Tex won’t need any injunction to remove any speculation.

Dangerfield will end up being our best ever player.

 

[Smoooothy]

Bad call – Tex won’t need any injunction to remove any speculation.

Dangerfield will end up being our best ever player.

bad call - still a very long time to go in the book of danger, way too early to tell if he'll be anywhere near as good as roo, macca, fud or zooma

of the 4 players mentioned, to complete the top 5 of the best crows player, should someone like rehn be included?

 

[Jars458]

Good Call / Bad Call - This Thread is lame?

 

[Alex99]

bad call - still a very long time to go in the book of danger, way too early to tell if he'll be anywhere near as good as roo, macca, fud or zooma

of the 4 players mentioned, to complete the top 5 of the best crows player, should someone like rehn be included?

Good call – very good player.

Was David Pittman underrated as a player?

 

[Macjoe]

... David Pittman underrated as a player...

Good call. My hero until Bickley became Captain.

Our forward group will be more important to future success than our backs.

 

[Smoooothy]

Good call. My hero until Bickley became Captain.

Our forward group will be more important to future success than our backs.

obvious call - without a forward line, how the **** do you win???

The crows will play an AFL game at Adelaide Oval in the next 3 years

 

[marvin]

obvious call - without a forward line, how the **** do you win???

The crows will play an AFL game at Adelaide Oval in the next 3 years

Bad call. Too many contracts and the ground isn't AFL ready.

Scott Stevens plays best when allowed to settle in one position rather than being a sometimes forward, sometimes back utility