gumbleton or kennedy

[toommy]

who is going to turn out to be the better footballer they look very similar

 

[Nightwolf]

Gumby by so much it isnt funny... Kennedy sucks..

 

[Melbdave81]

Haven't seen Gumbleton play so far, but I am very happy with Kennedy.

BTW - Kennedy >>>>>> Roughead

 

[Superster]

Gumby by so much it isnt funny... Kennedy sucks..

LOl you got no idea mate. Tell me when you have seen gumbleton play a afl game. Never your a tool.By the way kennedy has played about 4 afl homeandaway games.

 

[Nightwolf]

LOl you got no idea mate. Tell me when you have seen gumbleton play a afl game. Never your a tool.By the way kennedy has played about 4 afl homeandaway games.

Ive seen Gumby a few times as a junior and i can tell you he doesnt drop chest marks on a regular basis (hi Kennedy)..

 

[Merv]

I think they will both be very good footballers.

Gumby looks more athletic and is a better mark, but only time will tell

 

[burto]

lol kennedy is a goof.

 

[Silvagnis]

I think Gumbleton is a classier version of Kennedy and I like the look of Scott, but both players will be guns and better footballers than Ellis, Dowler, Roughead and Birchall. But I still wouldn't swap Josh for Gumbleton because that trade would be a nil all draw.

 

[Silvagnis]

Gumby by so much it isnt funny... Kennedy sucks..

Ive seen Gumby a few times as a junior and i can tell you he doesnt drop chest marks on a regular basis (hi Kennedy)..

A bit harsh mate!

I'm sure your Josh Kennedy will turn out OK and it's far too early to be writing him off as a player.

 

[blues4flag]

Hawthorn's version might struggle, but our Kennedy has a big future

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Ive seen Gumby a few times as a junior and i can tell you he doesnt drop chest marks on a regular basis (hi Kennedy)..

Hows Roughead going ? still looking for a position he can play ?

Does nothing as a forward - gets a bag kicked on him as a defender.

I guess you should have taken the Griff

 

[KING-JAMES]

Gumbleton, The KPP were stronger in last draft than the 05 draft with Gumbleton being the 1st one taken. Gumbleton was playing CHF for W.A over Josh Kennedy despite being a year younger. He is a beautiful kick, and has the best hands along with Hansen for someone his age i have seen in a long time. He is very skinny at this stage, and probably wont do so much at senious level, as where Kennedy is huge so i expect a bit from him, so if it was based on 2007 Kennedy, but from a career point of view Gumbleton for sure.
His an Absolute gem, so happy we picked him, i wanted him all along.

 

[Willy_37]

Hawthorn's version might struggle, but our Kennedy has a big future

Mate i'm pretty sure gumbleton plays for Essendon if ya don't know that you can't comment on the issue so just take a back seat to this issue mate

 

[Aussie Joe]

who is going to turn out to be the better footballer they look very similar

Which Kennedy numb nuts

 

[KING-JAMES]

Mate i'm pretty sure gumbleton plays for Essendon if ya don't know that you can't comment on the issue so just take a back seat to this issue mate

Pretty sure he was talking about the other Josh Kennedy

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Assuming Gumby can mark, he's already streets ahead of Kennedy. I cringe when I see Josh dump uncontested marks, he seems like a good kid.

 

[Jeremias]

Mate i'm pretty sure gumbleton plays for Essendon if ya don't know that you can't comment on the issue so just take a back seat to this issue mate

Self pwnage. Not much funnier than that.

 

[Nightwolf]

Why is Roughead being brought into this? All i said was the truth. Kennedy really does suck

 

[Jeremias]

Why is Roughead being brought into this? All i said was the truth. Kennedy really does suck

Writing off a player in your own team before he even plays a game?

Disgraceful...

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

Haven't seen Gumbleton play so far, but I am very happy with Kennedy.

BTW - Kennedy >>>>>> Roughead

Not to sure about that but this season we would tell ho is better out out of those two

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Hawthorn's version might struggle, but our Kennedy has a big future

As in, Josh P. Kennedy vs. Josh J. Kennedy.

No reference to Gumbleton. No "self-ownage".

 

[KING-JAMES]

This should be a poll probably...

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Kennedy is the new Travis Gaspar, big and athletic and hits packs hard but never marks it and is a poor kick.


Gumby is going to be awesome

 

[Hu$$ey]

Great thread!

Comparing one player who has played a grand total of 9 games against one who has played zip. Not to forget the 9-gamer had a broken shoulder before the season and hardly participated in the pre-season.

But even better is the fact that people already writing the "9-gamer" off as being a spud. Lol but that's bigfooty for ya, bunch of lost-cases running around.

 

[Bluebear]

Ive seen Gumby a few times as a junior and i can tell you he doesnt drop chest marks on a regular basis (hi Kennedy)..

JK didn't drop many against "Juniors" either - lets wait and see how Gumby goes against men.
I reckon Roughy will make it as a star on the field one day......................they'll need a longer Hawk suit though.