hodge > judd

[cussernaut]

the tide has turned

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

Yes one 3 goal game. What a legend. Best ever imo

 

[melbournemartin]

No. Judd even got more Dream Team points and that is all that counts

 

[Aussie Assault]

Here it is! I was waiting for this thread after hearing Hodge has kicked 3 goals..

Thanks for not disappointing me Cusser

 

[Embers]

Hodges best game of the year was only slightly better then Judds worst game of the year. Funny that

Even funnier was Hawks fans booing Judd when he got the ball. Talk about jealousy

 

[patsmith]

Bloody hell I'm annoyed that we got Judd instead of Hodge. The six brilliant seasons, B+Fs, Brownlow and Premiership all just went out the window with one game. Astute recruiting, Hawthorn. It may have taken a while, but it's paid off...

 

[Bretski]

He could very well be.

 

[Leafie]

No need to start this thread. Yes Hodge had a great game, he set us up in the third, However Judd is a superstar of the game. I wish everyone would just stop bringing up this Judd and Hodge crap! enough is enough, Im happy with Hodge is great for the hawks and all fans should be just greatfull they get to see both players playing afl. NOW GET OVER IT!!!!!

 

[stewpyd2]

Don't see Hodge's brownlow or premiership medallion as captain anywhere. Nuff.

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

Yep, tell Woosha the Judd-Franklin trade is off. Hodge had a good one so it's his turn now

 

[Hairy Cat Mooney]

No. Judd even got more Dream Team points and that is all that counts

Hodge got more supercoach points

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Deledio > Hodge > Judd
Richmond > Hawthorn > West Coast

Why not?

 

[CAS79]

While I'm not doubting Hodge is playing well and is in fact a good player, its time to accept that you got that draft wrong.

But whats done is done and now just be happy watching Hodge play good football with good teammates.

 

[Paul Kersey]

Great 3rd quarter. Don't compare him to the eye gouger.

 

[Hawkamania!]

I wouldn't go that far...yet.

But seriously, if any team had both Judd and Hodge, they would own the midfield. Not to mention both players ability to create opportunities forward and back.

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

Great 3rd quarter. Don't compare him to the eye gouger.

Cheap.

 

[Choota]

Even funnier was Hawks fans booing Judd when he got the ball. Talk about jealousy

Booing had more to do with Judd's Brownlow costing eye gouge.

 

[Upgrayedd]

dang hodge has some supurb foot skills, i dont know why hes left at the forward flank, can take a great mark as well

 

[Jono B]

Hodge is an absolute Gun no doubt. I would say his disposal is better than Judds' but Judd plays as a pure midfielder while Hodge plays a lot of the time on the backflank so it makes it harder to compare.

Arguably the best number 1 pick this decade.

 

[hawka_fan]

Hodges best game of the year was only slightly better then Judds worst game of the year. Funny that

Even funnier was Hawks fans booing Judd when he got the ball. Talk about jealousy

Thats cos he eye gouged Brown.

 

[sydney_hawka]

While I'm not doubting Hodge is playing well and is in fact a good player, its time to accept that you got that draft wrong.

But whats done is done and now just be happy watching Hodge play good football with good teammates.

Most Hawthorn supporters will argue that we didn't get the Draft wrong.
Chris Judd would not have won us a premiership in the last 5 years. Luke Hodge will be there when we do win one. That time is sooner rather than later.

 

[cussernaut]

Hodge is an absolute Gun no doubt. I would say his disposal is better than Judds' but Judd plays as a pure midfielder while Hodge plays a lot of the time on the backflank so it makes it harder to compare.

Arguably the best number 1 pick this decade.

finally a good reply

no sh.. all the sherlocks who posted, judd has the points on the board

Will be interesting to compare in 5 years after hodge has had time in a good side...

 

[Big Nasty]

Bartel, Ablett >>> Hodge, Mitchell

 

[JKCeagle]

I wouldn't go that far...yet.

But seriously, if any team had both Judd and Hodge, they would own the midfield. Not to mention both players ability to create opportunities forward and back.

What do you mean, midfield?

Clarkson clearly doesn't think Hodge is a midfielder...he's been a half-back flanker all year who today was switched up forward, much in the way the Eagles sometimes use Wirrpanda

 

[DannyJ]

Bartel, Ablett >>> Hodge, Mitchell

Hodge>Ablett>Bartel>Mitchell