Humm, Roach and Rodan

[PLSC]

if these poor excuse for footballers are on the list next yr we are the biggest ****ing joke in the afl

knobel is ****

limbach is a pussy

mcguane and graham have MASSIVE potential, just need to learn how to play

our vfl side is a joke, if it wasnt for schulz kicking bags early on they would be almost last

 

[Brad-clare]

I imagine Humm and Rodan wont be there next year.

Not sure about Roach but has to be skating on thin ice.

 

[tugga]

Rodan is contracted for next year. Do your research before posting emotion-filled build-up.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Moore should be the first to go

 

[Bojangles17]

mcguane and graham have MASSIVE potential, just need to learn how to play

watched 1q of ressies game and McGuane looks a likely type as a forward...needs to bulk some, but presents, marks and moves well...Definately worth perevering with and looks better as a KF than down back

 

[PLSC]

who cares about contracts

put him up for a 7th round pick and pay half his wage

graham is ****ing massive!

how can a guy like him be with us when the rest of the team are twigs

 

[mini_me316]

if these poor excuse for footballers are on the list next yr we are the biggest ****ing joke in the afl

knobel is ****

limbach is a pussy

mcguane and graham have MASSIVE potential, just need to learn how to play

our vfl side is a joke, if it wasnt for schulz kicking bags early on they would be almost last

You don't know much.
Limbach will need to get a go in the seniors before deciding on anything, naturally for a young kid he is up and down with his form but I don't care, young forwards are like that.

Mcguane is effectivly one year behind all the other players in his draft because of his horrendus upper arm break which forced him to lose alot of weight and strength, havent seen Graham so dont know.

I think Tom Roach needs to be given more of a go in the seniors, he has only played 1 and a half games in 2 years and not because he was injured but because TW doesnt seem to want to pick him.

Moore should go but unfortunatly Rodan is still under contract, Humm should be given another chance in the seniors aswell.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

can anyone post a few picks of graham I can't find any. he's massive? why the hell hasn't he been given a go?

 

[PLSC]

You don't know much.
Limbach will need to get a go in the seniors before deciding on anything, naturally for a young kid he is up and down with his form but I don't care, young forwards are like that.

Mcguane is effectivly one year behind all the other players in his draft because of his horrendus upper arm break which forced him to lose alot of weight and strength, havent seen Graham so dont know.

I think Tom Roach needs to be given more of a go in the seniors, he has only played 1 and a half games in 2 years and not because he was injured but because TW doesnt seem to want to pick him.

Moore should go but unfortunatly Rodan is still under contract, Humm should be given another chance in the seniors aswell.

you know what? how about you and that other firend of yours Pettifers_ugly or whatever go back to msn, you have nfi

omg hughes is hot he should be in the team!!!!

leave the FOOTY talk to the big boys

 

[banzai]

You don't know much.
Limbach will need to get a go in the seniors before deciding on anything, naturally for a young kid he is up and down with his form but I don't care, young forwards are like that.

Mcguane is effectivly one year behind all the other players in his draft because of his horrendus upper arm break which forced him to lose alot of weight and strength, havent seen Graham so dont know.

I think Tom Roach needs to be given more of a go in the seniors, he has only played 1 and a half games in 2 years and not because he was injured but because TW doesnt seem to want to pick him.

Moore should go but unfortunatly Rodan is still under contract, Humm should be given another chance in the seniors aswell.

Roach, Moore, Gaspar, Chaffey, Stafford should go. Hopefully we can come to an agreement with Rodan and let him go as well. Humm is only on the rookie list and will certainly go. McGuane has a lot more potential than Limbach and Dean could be in trouble at seasons end.

Also with Polo and possibly krakouer now out we should debut Casserley next week.

 

[Weaver]

Also with Polo and possibly krakouer now out we should debut Casserley next week.

More value playing Casserley in Coburg's first final than in a meaningless round 22 match against the Eagles.

 

[Infamy]

What's wrong with Polo?

 

[1980GFVideo]

I cant wait for these guys to be out of the door just to stop the threads about them being out the door.

It will happen. the line is already through the names of Roach and Humm. Rodan is contracted.

 

[tiger4life]

What's wrong with Polo?

Apparently he has stress fractures...but im not sure if thats true or not

 

[Goldust]

You don't know much.
Limbach will need to get a go in the seniors before deciding on anything, naturally for a young kid he is up and down with his form but I don't care, young forwards are like that.

Mcguane is effectivly one year behind all the other players in his draft because of his horrendus upper arm break which forced him to lose alot of weight and strength, havent seen Graham so dont know.

I think Tom Roach needs to be given more of a go in the seniors, he has only played 1 and a half games in 2 years and not because he was injured but because TW doesnt seem to want to pick him.

Moore should go but unfortunatly Rodan is still under contract, Humm should be given another chance in the seniors aswell.

AND who do you suggest we drop to accommodate Roach and Humm being selected???
Ever think that the reason we are winning games late in the season - besides playing crap like Essendon - is that the team is settled. Their form needs to warrant slecetion, but as much as some people want to see what they can do, others' form is far better than that of Roach and Humm.

 

[mini_me316]

AND who do you suggest we drop to accommodate Roach and Humm being selected???
Ever think that the reason we are winning games late in the season - besides playing crap like Essendon - is that the team is settled. Their form needs to warrant slecetion, but as much as some people want to see what they can do, others' form is far better than that of Roach and Humm.

Well for one Ray Hall is out with suspension, Krakour is unlikley to play, Polo is possibly injured.
Why not just give them a go, we did it for Rory Hilton last year and he showed us he wasn't up to it.

 

[Lynch drops a mark]

I thought that Roach looked like a gun against WC in R3

Broke his jaw I think and I've never heared of him since

 

[Truetiger]

limbach is a pussy

If he is a pussy i would hate to think what you are. As he is the one out there trying to make the grade. As you sit on ur ass and comment on players etc. i know were i would rather be

I imagine Humm and Rodan wont be there next year.

Not sure about Roach but has to be skating on thin ice.

Humm now what a waste of a Rookie pick. What the hell were they thinking. whats he done in the 2 games that he has played?

Rodan is finished. Richmond should put his name up for trade in a hope we can get something for him. Otherwise will be delisted.

Roach Another one that has been lucky to be on the list for a few years now. Regardless of the Injury he had he should be delisted or traded at seasons end. As i feel if we keep him it will be another wasted season. He is only with us due to his name and like David Bourke has been a big bloody let down

 

[Goldust]

Well for one Ray Hall is out with suspension, Krakour is unlikley to play, Polo is possibly injured.
Why not just give them a go, we did it for Rory Hilton last year and he showed us he wasn't up to it.

NONE of Roach, Humm or Rodan is capable of replacing Ray Hall. If fit, Kellaway will get the gig given we already lack talls down back. I can see huge problems if the Eagle sdecide to plonk big Cox down forward and why wouldn't they?
Krakouer and Polo both likely to play as I understand it, so doubt we'll see too many changes again. No need to change a winning formula and our best chance of winning does not include Rodan, Roach or Humm! We have better players of their size and style currently in the line-up.
Me, I would rather win Saturday than go down fighting by 11 points all just to discover again, again, again that Rodan and Humm aren't up to scratch!
As I say, their presence at Coburg and inability to break in to the line-up, especially with so many others sidelined with injury, is no coincidence. Just underlines how the powers to be at Tigerland rate them.
We have Brown, Newman, Thursfield, Coughlan, Gaspar, Meyer and Kellaway missing from our best 22, as well as Oakley-Nicholls and Hartigan (debatable whether they are in the best 22) and Jackson all sidelined. If a player can't crack it for a game with us in such a depleted state, there is simply no future for them!!!
And let me put it another way, more of the same mediocrity from Rodan, Roach and Humm in recent weekswould not have allowed us to uncover what a potential gem we have in Cameron Howat, or further develop a player such as Matthew White!