ins and outs

[toenail11]

ill try keep it as short as i can

OUT:
brock
murphy
macca
ma. johnson

IN:
head
hinkley
mayne (if hes fit)
and i hate to say it but possibley kepler

 

[freo1]

ill try keep it as short as i can

OUT:
brock
murphy
macca
ma. johnson

IN:
head
hinkley
mayne (if hes fit)
and i hate to say it but possibley kepler

farmer will be out for striking id think

ins will be black, headland, grover and hayden hopefully

 

[Lach72]

Out:
McManus - for the love of god, someone, pleeaaasssseeee....
Schammer
Murphy
Thornton

In
Hayden
Grover
Mayne
Dessie

 

[palmer2farmer]

Out
Thornton (Delist Now)
Brock (WAFL)
Macca (Retire)
Foster (WAFL)

In
Headland
Hayden
Black
Kepler

 

[Lach72]

I see no reason to drop Brock after 1 game.
The season is stuffed...give all the new kids an extended run with the predicted nucleus of the side for next year

 

[ImperialPurple]

I see no reason to drop Brock after 1 game.
The season is stuffed...give all the new kids an extended run with the predicted nucleus of the side for next year

I agree. FFS Brock and Foster had played 5 games between them before today and neither were our worst.

Geez people want to see some development but they want to arse a couple of young blokes who had no pre-season after a game where the ____ing leaders and senior players out there went to water when they should have been leading FFS (Pav & Solly excepted).

Neither of these guys had a pre-season, and if they are "omitted" it should be to increase their match fitness, not because they are "dropped". Macca, MaJ, Thornton, Murphy and Schammer should all get the arse before these two IMO.

 

[pistol17]

I see no reason to drop Brock after 1 game.
The season is stuffed...give all the new kids an extended run with the predicted nucleus of the side for next year

Brock didnt give a yelp today... I hope all you brock cult members took not of his lacklustre performance. He was one of the worst today, if not the worst. Severely over-rated by too many people on this board.

Im all for playing kids but not after a performance he gave today.

Outs: McManus, Brock, Mark Johnson, Thornton, Murphy, Gilmore

Ins: Hayden, Grover, Head, Bradley, Headland, Campbell/Dunn(elevate him)/Hinkley

Season over.... this is getting laughable now these types of performance.

Ridiculous

 

[sumavich]

Brock didnt give a yelp today... I hope all you brock cult members took not of his lacklustre performance. He was one of the worst today, if not the worst. Severely over-rated by too many people on this board.

Im all for playing kids but not after a performance he gave today.

Outs: McManus, Brock, Mark Johnson, Thornton, Murphy, Gilmore

Ins: Hayden, Grover, Head, Bradley, Headland, Campbell/Dunn(elevate him)/Hinkley

Season over.... this is getting laughable now these types of performance.

Ridiculous

OUT : Thornton, Murphy, Mundy, Schammer
IN : Hayden, Headland, Warnock, Mayne

 

[Scham]

OUT:
Macca
Thornton
Murphy
Gilmore

IN:
Headland
Hayden
Grover
Bradley

 

[E Shed]

I'm afraid to say I don't really care. I would have thought however that Grover & Hayden would be walk up starts if they are fit. Same Headland & probably Mayne. As for outs, where do start? Macca, Murph, Brock, Ma Johnson? Be easier to start with those that deserve a game. Pav, Ibbo, Ogre, Palmer, Crowls, Solo... maybe there's more.

 

[Freo Big Fella]

Out: Thornton, Schammer, Murphy, Gilmore, Mark Johnson, McManus
In: Grover, Hayden, Head, Mayne, Warnock, Kepler

Des a walkup if fit as well.

 

[Bradesmaen]

OUT : Thornton, Murphy, Mundy, Schammer
IN : Hayden, Headland, Warnock, Mayne

Mundy? Because he played an ok game? Well, lets drop over half the team then because they were far worse than him.

 

[spitlizard]

Brock didnt give a yelp today... I hope all you brock cult members took not of his lacklustre performance. He was one of the worst today, if not the worst. Severely over-rated by too many people on this board.Ridiculous

Thats crap Pistol.

We need to get some runs on the board for these young guys. Yes they will make mistakes and have bad days but thats the only way to build them up to AFL level and see just how good they can be. Yes we will probably lose games because of it but it will make the future brighter.

Everyone is yapping only about wholesale changes so playing these guys is essential.

 

[Avid_Avenger]

I'll pitch in, the only positive I can find from that game is that surely Harvs cannot find another reason for playing Macca and Schammer...

OUT:

Macca
Schammer
Thornton
Murphy
Farmer (suspended for striking)
Mark Johnson
?

IN:

Head
Des
Warnock - Sandi needs help.
Mayne
Grover
Hayden
Keplar

Brock gets a reprieve and given a chance to play on the ball after given a rocket for not running hard enough.

 

[Plugga]

I though Brock was okay...poor match up by coaching staff playing him on woonamanameri or whatever his name is.

Other kids...

Foster - didn't show anything
Drum - was okay but lacked discipline
Palmer - BOG in 1st half
Ibbo - Pretty good throughout


For mine...I think the season starts again;

OUT:
McManus (hopefully his 2nd last game EVER at the club. Great servant, but time was up Prelim Final 2006)
Murphy (Perth Media lovechild. Pathetic on the field.)
Thornton (Enough already. Looked disinterested)
Gilmore (Warnock must play 2nd ruck)
Foster (Poor game)
Mark Johnson (Was okay, but Mayne must play out season in #1's)

IN:
Hayden
Grover
Headland
Mayne
Bradley
Warnock

Give Brock a chance at Subi!
Give Bradley a chance to see if he's worth keeping.

I think Mayne, Palmer, Ibbo, Brock must be played every game until end of year.

 

[ImperialPurple]

I think Mayne, Palmer, Ibbo, Brock must be played every game until end of year.

And Foster and Drum too.

Warnock must play about 10 games and Hinkley must play 5-6.

Elevate Dunn - tell him they're rolling the dice with him and giving him 5 games to convince them to keep him next year. If he breaks down or has no impact, then get rid of him at the end of the year.

Give Big Kep a run for 3-4 games and see what he's made of.

 

[pistol17]

Thats crap Pistol.

We need to get some runs on the board for these young guys. Yes they will make mistakes and have bad days but thats the only way to build them up to AFL level and see just how good they can be. Yes we will probably lose games because of it but it will make the future brighter.

Everyone is yapping only about wholesale changes so playing these guys is essential.

Crap is what brocks performance was... he only got a game because 2 defenders were injured, in fact that is the only reason he has played his 2 games so far. From injuries and suspensions...

Something needs to give, its bull shirt we can go year to year like this, a clean out must start now. Build the team around Pavlich, Mayne, Palmer, Ibbotson and Sandilands... the rest can do whatever, they all tradeable in my opinion. Only way we will go forward...