Remove this Banner Ad

Is My Forward Line To Weak?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

magpies03

Club Legend
Mar 26, 2007
1,364
77
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Cavs
Pavlich
Bock
Brennan
Embly
Cornes
Okeefe
Kosi

RESERVES
Davey
Jetta

Is this to weak? Heard one guy say you should have 3 of Jonno,Lucas,Pavlich, Hall. SHould i change anything?
 
Pavlich
Bock
Brennan
Embly
Cornes
Okeefe
Kosi

RESERVES
Davey
Jetta

Is this to weak? Heard one guy say you should have 3 of Jonno,Lucas,Pavlich, Hall. SHould i change anything?
Nah, its a perfectly fine forward line.
In fact, I have 6 of your 8.
If you trade smartly, you will be able to upgrade Kosi, Brennan and Bock for elite players.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Nah, its a perfectly fine forward line.
In fact, I have 6 of your 8.
If you trade smartly, you will be able to upgrade Kosi, Brennan and Bock for elite players.

yeh i think id like to get one more of those elite guys at least! What are you ranked? Out of interest who do you have in your midfield?
 
yeh i think id like to get one more of those elite guys at least! What are you ranked? Out of interest who do you have in your midfield?
I am ranked 3530th- been carrying Ball and Lappin for two weeks with Browne providing an amazing 2 this week. Yourself?
My midfield is:
Hodge
Hasleby
Ball
Rischitelli
Gibbs
Lappin

Selwood
Browne.
Why do you ask?
 
I am ranked 3530th- been carrying Ball and Lappin for two weeks with Browne providing an amazing 2 this week. Yourself?
My midfield is:
Hodge
Hasleby
Ball
Rischitelli
Gibbs
Lappin

Selwood
Browne.
Why do you ask?

Just wanted to see the sorts of players you have in your midfield seeings your forward line is basically the same as mine.

Im ranked 14737

got goodes
black
kerr
priddis
foley
lappin

Gibbs and Sellwood

Trading goodes this week, has been a massive dissappointment. Thinking maybe bartel however i wanna get rid of solomon out of my back line hopefully for mcleod,kenelly or mcfee.
 
Pavlich
Bock
Brennan
Embly
Cornes
Okeefe
Kosi

RESERVES
Davey
Jetta

Is this to weak? Heard one guy say you should have 3 of Jonno,Lucas,Pavlich, Hall. SHould i change anything?


Am ranked 1040ish

My forward line is
G Ablett
Pavlich
Hall
Embley
J Brown
Patfull
Al Davey

EMG
Edwards
Tomahawk

Will trade patfull and Al Davey after stopped increasing

Good forward line but Brennan is a waste, more consistant player needed
 
Am ranked 1040ish

My forward line is
G Ablett
Pavlich
Hall
Embley
J Brown
Patfull
Al Davey

EMG
Edwards
Tomahawk

Will trade patfull and Al Davey after stopped increasing

Good forward line but Brennan is a waste, more consistant player needed

Yeh i agree with you about brennan. Ill probably give him a few more weeks tho coz he has been playing well. If his form drops off ill probably trade him for chapman or jonno or lucas
 
I am ranked 600th and would say most of you guys have a better forward line than me.

Mine is:
Pavlich
Hall
O'Keefe
Fevola
Flanklin
Bock
Betts

Al Davey
Edwards
 
I am ranked 600th and would say most of you guys have a better forward line than me.

Mine is:
Pavlich
Hall
O'Keefe
Fevola
Flanklin
Bock
Betts

Al Davey
Edwards

THats not to bad.SOme big fire power in there with pavlich, hall and fevola. Would say franklin and betts could be a bit inconsistant tho
 
This my current forwardline:

B Johnson
Pavlich
Fevola
Bock
Franklin
Hawkins
Al Davey

So yeah, I think you guys are in much better shape than me. I have 3 that definately need to be upgraded, possible 4.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

This my current forwardline:

B Johnson
Pavlich
Fevola
Bock
Franklin
Hawkins
Al Davey

So yeah, I think you guys are in much better shape than me. I have 3 that definately need to be upgraded, possible 4.

Whats wrong with that forward line??? Only possible problem could be franklin who you could easily upgrade for someone like hall but other than that dont think it looks to bad at all.:thumbsu:
 
Whats wrong with that forward line??? Only possible problem could be franklin who you could easily upgrade for someone like hall but other than that dont think it looks to bad at all.:thumbsu:

Compared to some of the other ones posted on here it looks a tad weak. Im starting two rookies (but have Matt Campbell and Aaron Edwards on the bench for cash), Bock isnt proven to be a consistent high-scorer. Same goes for Buddy.

Funnily enough I traded Hall out of my side the week he goes nuts. Not too fussed, cause I got BJ for him. But yeah definately looking to upgrade Buddy - probably to O'Keefe or someone around that price range.

But cheers for the positive assesment. :thumbsu:
 
Compared to some of the other ones posted on here it looks a tad weak. Im starting two rookies (but have Matt Campbell and Aaron Edwards on the bench for cash), Bock isnt proven to be a consistent high-scorer. Same goes for Buddy.

Funnily enough I traded Hall out of my side the week he goes nuts. Not too fussed, cause I got BJ for him. But yeah definately looking to upgrade Buddy - probably to O'Keefe or someone around that price range.

But cheers for the positive assesment. :thumbsu:
Okeefe is good because you can basically garantee he will score above 80. Dont write off Bock either. Just remember rounds one and two he posted scores of 100+. Playing sydney this week which will be another tough one but id expect him to bounce back after that:)
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Thanks mate...

Have kept Embley in the whole time as he will only get better and generally gets some possessions...

My backline is actually doing the majority of the scoring...!!
 
cant seem to get into the website at the moment but think it has Mcphee, Carrazzo, Milburn, Hargrave, Brennan, Jones and Birchall....

I think....Definately the first 6 ....


Midfield of Black, Ling, West, Murphy, Gibbs and Judd
 
cant seem to get into the website at the moment but think it has Mcphee, Carrazzo, Milburn, Hargrave, Brennan, Jones and Birchall....

I think....Definately the first 6 ....


Midfield of Black, Ling, West, Murphy, Gibbs and Judd

I would trade Jones out (if talking about corey), has had a shocker and is now playing forward. roos midfield can't get the ball in quick or direct enough, would trade maybe for adcock to free up some $$$. he will only increase in weeks and has a poor roos forward line to contend with this week:thumbsu:
 
Any thoughts and tips? My forward line is very weak (far weaker than my midfield, and even further behind my defence).


16. FEVOLA, Brendan (CAR) $508,400 $8,700 ($+8,700)
17. PAVLICH, Matthew (FRE) $536,600 $-20,300 ($-20,300)
18. FRANKLIN, Lance (HAW) $350,100 $25,500 ($+25,500)
19. KOSCHITZKE, Justin (STK) $220,000 $55,100 ($+55,100)
20. MONFRIES, Angus (ESS) $335,000 $-6,300 ($-6,300)
21. MURPHY, Robert (WBD) $350,100 $-36,300 ($-36,300)
22. DAVEY, Alwyn (ESS) $129,400 $39,200 ($+39,200)

29. BROWN, Nathan G. (RIC) $338,000 $0 ($+0)
30. EDWARDS, Aaron (KAN) $90,200 $0 ($+0)

I know Brown was a massive mistake in retrospect. Get rid of him now? Or is it not worth the trade?

Any other tips too please. Cheers.
 
Any thoughts and tips? My forward line is very weak (far weaker than my midfield, and even further behind my defence).


16. FEVOLA, Brendan (CAR) $508,400 $8,700 ($+8,700)
17. PAVLICH, Matthew (FRE) $536,600 $-20,300 ($-20,300)
18. FRANKLIN, Lance (HAW) $350,100 $25,500 ($+25,500)
19. KOSCHITZKE, Justin (STK) $220,000 $55,100 ($+55,100)
20. MONFRIES, Angus (ESS) $335,000 $-6,300 ($-6,300)
21. MURPHY, Robert (WBD) $350,100 $-36,300 ($-36,300)
22. DAVEY, Alwyn (ESS) $129,400 $39,200 ($+39,200)

29. BROWN, Nathan G. (RIC) $338,000 $0 ($+0)
30. EDWARDS, Aaron (KAN) $90,200 $0 ($+0)

I know Brown was a massive mistake in retrospect. Get rid of him now? Or is it not worth the trade?

Any other tips too please. Cheers.

Murphy and brown, wat were u thinking. come back after a knee reco and leg op., silly choices; were only ever going to perform poor. Would look at grabbing a star forward, (eg hall, ablett, chapman, lucas etc) and would look at a cash cow, eg hawkins, campbell etc
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Is My Forward Line To Weak?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top