Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[Great8]

Wonder how many players on 2 strikes have been palmed off to unsuspected clubs. Some things from clubs and managers need to be transparent.

 

[foj1]

yeh it stinks doesnt it

for all the argy bargy that goes in trade week, i would have thought there are some things you just have to be open and honest about

Clubs need to make McConville accountable
He happily takes his commission yet burns st Kilda footy club
He burnt Essendon by refusing to allow Carlisle to get to hawthorn because he gets less commission
Player managers are becoming way too powerful without a strong moral compass

 

[Brenno]

If I found out that the club knew about this but kept it to themselves I would be pretty disappointed.

Seriously it has to be a joke he can't be that ****ing obtuse surely

 

[Defacto]

Wonder how many players on 2 strikes have been palmed off to unsuspected clubs. Some things from clubs and managers need to be transparent.

i attended a Q&A session with a club president, and he raised this exact point. clubs are very concerned about it. only the doctor knows and he is bound by strict confidentiality. he said the club president should know along with the doctor as he has to sign off on all contract agreements anyway (within a certain criteria)

if there is something like this occurring one club president should be able to pick up the phone to the other and disclose the confidential information. like wise manager to president.

i seriously hope there is some pressure put on the manager from the AFL, given the accreditation is approved by the AFL

 

[Defacto]

Clubs need to make McConville accountable
He happily takes his commission yet burns st Kilda footy club
He burnt Essendon by refusing to allow Carlisle to get to hawthorn because he gets less commission
Player managers are becoming way too powerful without a strong moral compass

I completely agree and i am sure these exact conversations are going on right now between the AFL and St Kilda

 

[foj1]

Mcconville is dodgy as they come
I know of a couple of terrible incidents
He should have his accreditation stripped for this permanently just like Ricky NixonNixon

 

[DERO]

Connors is the worst.

 

[DapperDon]

apparently the saints are in with the lawyers now

i'd imagine they'd be wanting hair samples etc ASAP

You taking hair samples of your entire playing list?

Might not field a team next year if so.

 

[Great8]

You taking hair samples of your entire playing list?

Might not field a team next year if so.

Yep, if there was hair samples from every player in the AFL taken at this time of year the results would be staggering.

 

[foj1]

Zero tolerance needs to be implemented ASAP
It is a gift to play afl footy but one of the rules is no drugs
If you can't cop it bad luck
Do st Kilda delist Carlisle if it is proven he has taken drugs just like they got rid of Lovett quickly?
I wonder if there is a behaviour clause in what is a very lucrative contract?
Hardly what you need for a young list.
I do believe st Kilda should go hard at the manager McConville
He should be deregistered

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

I have heard on good authority that Jakey has been up to a little no good, maybe in Vegas... buyer beware!

A young bloke having a good time whilst in vegas.... who would of thunk it.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Mcconville is dodgy as they come
I know of a couple of terrible incidents
He should have his accreditation stripped for this permanently just like Ricky NixonNixon

What do you know.. Mcconville is a cracking bloke, one of the most genuine blokes in AFL footy that i have had beers with and only has the best interest of his clients at heart.

 

[doona]

yeh it stinks doesnt it

Probably not for Carlisle, the insides of his nose are probably shot

 

[Pinpoint Pass]

How does he prove it was wizz fizz if it was? No way to but the worst case scenario is he gets a strike against him. As long as he is not on 2, outside of the embarrassment, its a non issue re his ability to play for Saints.

No way they can prove it was a drug if he just sticks to the story that it was a prank and it was harmless icing powder or whatever. He was the only one there, i think, so unless there was some text saying it was coke and he sticks to his story i doubt they could hit him with a strike, even though everyone will know what he was up to.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

**** this thread has been a rollercoaster. In the end we ended up with basically a straight swap for JC, just swapping pick 23 and 24.

I'd like to thank 2planks for his contribution.
I'd like to thank red bull for the endless PSD or watson talk
I'd like to thank saints for pick 5

I'd like to thank dodoro most of all- I doubted you oh great one, never again.

#haildodoro #disco #requiredplayer

 

[foj1]

What do you know.. Mcconville is a cracking bloke, one of the most genuine blokes in AFL footy that i have had beers with and only has the best interest of his clients at heart.

Anyone can be a cracking bloke when they are on the beers pal.
Very ordinary

 

[doona]

Regardless of what he was taking, if it is true his manager knew about it before the trade, this is dodgey.

Even if it is fake or a joke or something, this should have been disclosed to St. Kilda. If it was Wizz fizz, why wasn't it disclosed by Carlisle and his Manger to the Saints before the trades?

If they knew about it, and it was nothing it should have been aired.

Something weird about the timing as well.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Regardless of what he was taking, if it is true his manager knew about it before the trade, this is dodgey.

Even if it is fake or a joke or something, this should have been disclosed to St. Kilda. If it was Wizz fizz, why wasn't it disclosed by Carlisle and his Manger to the Saints before the trades?

If they knew about it, and it was nothing it should have been aired.

Something weird about the timing as well.

Do you honestly think Stkilda were not made aware of this before today? ACA woukd have gone straight to stkilda for comment as soon they got hold of the footage. Who ever sold it would also have contacted other media looking for $..

 

[foj1]

Regardless of what he was taking, if it is true his manager knew about it before the trade, this is dodgey.

Even if it is fake or a joke or something, this should have been disclosed to St. Kilda. If it was Wizz fizz, why wasn't it disclosed by Carlisle and his Manger to the Saints before the trades?

If they knew about it, and it was nothing it should have been aired.

Something weird about the timing as well.

This thread is long.
However I mentioned that I was worried what the press would do if jake did the dirty on Essendon. I knew nothing about this Instagram but there are a few Carlisle stories that have been buzzing around for a while.
I agree though the timing is off and very fishy

 

[doona]

Do you honestly think Stkilda were not made aware of this before today? ACA woukd have gone straight to stkilda for comment as soon they got hold of the footage.

If they were, and they let it air on ACA, the people at St. Kilda should be sacked that knew. You don't throw a landmine in your club.

If they were aware, and happy with Carlisle, they should have broken it

 

[foj1]

Do you honestly think Stkilda were not made aware of this before today? ACA woukd have gone straight to stkilda for comment as soon they got hold of the footage.

Do you believe st Kilda would have done the trade if they knew about this? No way!
I believe McConville kept it quiet. I am more than happy to be proven wrong but if the saints are meeting with their lawyers it is bye bye McConville.
What happens to Carlisle?

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

This thread is long.
However I mentioned that I was worried what the press would do if jake did the dirty on Essendon. I knew nothing about this Instagram but there are a few Carlisle stories that have been buzzing around for a while.
I agree though the timing is off and very fishy

The only thing that makes sense is that the snapchat friend is a former team mate happy to throw Carlisle under the bus now he is gone.

 

[foj1]

The only thing that makes sense is that the snapchat friend is a former team mate happy to throw Carlisle under the bus now he is gone.

Come on it could be anyone from jakes social circle.
More likely someone from crazy burn who made some quick dollars selling him out.

 

[TheEnsign]

The Age and the Oz not running the story. Given it originated from ACA it's hard to know what to think in terms of genuineness.

 

[Tedeski]

First we laugh at saints fans saying no pick 5 lol
Then we laugh at Syd and saints for
making this trade week the best ever lol
Then we laugh at jakey boy ...

But at the end of the day, you are still the Bombers & we all sit back & laugh that you still have many of Jake's mates running around at your club.