James Aish

[Mr MysteryGuest]

i Haven't seen that much of Aish to be honest, and some here have said he has above average pace but not that quick. How would his leg speed compare with douglas?

 

[pjcrows]

i Haven't seen that much of Aish to be honest, and some here have said he has above average pace but not that quick. How would his leg speed compare with douglas?

He'd be slower than Douglas.

 

[irish]

hi guys , just dropping in with your approval ! with respect james is wanted by us no doubt ! but a lot of the talk is purely speculative
boy is being floated by his management on his familys reputation and his own potential !

not real sure noble will be fighting to sign him yet , he would want to show a shit load more this season i reckon

we see the potential and would prefer to keep the kid but we need to make a statement about kids sucking us dry and going where ever they nominate

think if he goes it will be to the highest bidder not to mum and dads !

thanks folks

 

[pjcrows]

hi guys , just dropping in with your approval ! with respect james is wanted by us no doubt ! but a lot of the talk is purely speculative
boy is being floated by his management on his familys reputation and his own potential !

not real sure noble will be fighting to sign him yet , he would want to show a shit load more this season i reckon

we see the potential and would prefer to keep the kid but we need to make a statement about kids sucking us dry and going where ever they nominate

think if he goes it will be to the highest bidder not to mum and dads !

thanks folks

cheers !

 

[RePete]

hi guys , just dropping in with your approval ! with respect james is wanted by us no doubt ! but a lot of the talk is purely speculative
boy is being floated by his management on his familys reputation and his own potential !

not real sure noble will be fighting to sign him yet , he would want to show a shit load more this season i reckon

we see the potential and would prefer to keep the kid but we need to make a statement about kids sucking us dry and going where ever they nominate

think if he goes it will be to the highest bidder not to mum and dads !

thanks folks

He won't leave for the sake of leaving, if he wants out he will nominate a state or club. If he nominates Adelaide you will probably have to accept our first round pick and do the trade.

 

[headache1]

hi guys , just dropping in with your approval ! with respect james is wanted by us no doubt ! but a lot of the talk is purely speculative
boy is being floated by his management on his familys reputation and his own potential !

not real sure noble will be fighting to sign him yet , he would want to show a shit load more this season i reckon

we see the potential and would prefer to keep the kid but we need to make a statement about kids sucking us dry and going where ever they nominate

think if he goes it will be to the highest bidder not to mum and dads !

thanks folks

If he agrees to go to the highest bidder, you shouldn't have any problems !

 

[Mismatched]

hi guys , just dropping in with your approval ! with respect james is wanted by us no doubt ! but a lot of the talk is purely speculative
boy is being floated by his management on his familys reputation and his own potential !

not real sure noble will be fighting to sign him yet , he would want to show a shit load more this season i reckon

we see the potential and would prefer to keep the kid but we need to make a statement about kids sucking us dry and going where ever they nominate

think if he goes it will be to the highest bidder not to mum and dads !

thanks folks

You can talk tough, just like we did with Tippett, but at the end of the day the player has to agree to any trade.

The only power you have is refusing to trade him and force him into the PSD and to potentially a club that he doesn't want to go to.

 

[mattymac]

Look, I love dougie, but Aish, if he came home to us and was surrounded by his mates and family...his potential is ridiculous. Dual footed gun waiting to receive and lace out our forwards. He's been in a shit place this year and its affected his footy, no doubt

 

[Crowbots are dead]

Well yeah. But if it was a matter of Douglas or Aish right now I don't know how you could pick Douglas. Aish has 10+ years left.

I agree. Just don't think that it's a forgone conclusion as Douglas is far better than most have given him credit for on here

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I'm not saying it would happen. Others are suggesting it.

How do we lose if we trade Douglas for Aish!!

Very similar to getting Matt crouch with the pick we got for Bernie .....a massive win for the long term

 

[Freddy Bassett]

Lyons and R2 Pick for Aish

Round 1 Draft Riley Bonner
Round 3 Draft Keiren Aguis.

BANG!!!!

I am sure Brisbane would be over the moon with that offer.... Great post

 

[LC40]

Very similar to getting Matt crouch with the pick we got for Bernie .....a massive win for the long term

Sad part about this, is we could have had both.
Thanks to our self imposed sanctions we gave away our Round 1 and 2 picks two years in a row. Feeling the effects now!
Why oh why did we jump at those shadows. The true legacy of Chapman and Trigg(Good luck Carlton).

 

[Sanders]

Plus Lowden had Hale , McEvoy and Ceglar to compete with in the first 22.

That's like saying Luke Jericho couldn't make it in the toughness stakes because noted hard man Josh Jenkins was in his way.

 

[Sanders]

Douglas is a much better player than aish and will be for at least a couple more years. Mainly because Douglas is actually a very good player.

If he wanted out you'd trade him for aish, but I wouldn't offer him

 

[Bonkers000]

Did anyone just see aish' kick out? Do we really still want him?

 

[Bacon8]

Did anyone just see aish' kick out? Do we really still want him? [emoji14]

I saw Joe Dahiner kick the ball into the man on the mark.

I assume that also means he's no good?

 

[Bosley]

Did anyone just see aish' kick out? Do we really still want him?

This is the first time I have actually watched him play with the intention to keep an eye on him.

I am embarrassed that we have a thread dedicated to his potential trade. He is a passenger out there ... at best.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Did anyone just see aish' kick out? Do we really still want him?

always buy low and back your environment & development .....look at Eddie ...heading for AA this year

 

[headache1]

This is the first time I have actually watched him play with the intention to keep an eye on him.

I am embarrassed that we have a thread dedicated to his potential trade. He is a passenger out there ... at best.

So you're making that second statement based on the fact that you've watched him play for 2 and a bit quarters?

 

[Bosley]

So you're making that second statement based on the fact that you've watched him play for 2 and a bit quarters?

I have watched him before and not been impressed ... now I am focusing on him and am embarrassed, yes.

I don't want to bag an Aish ... just saying what I see.

 

[King Elvis]

I have watched him before and not been impressed ... now I am focusing on him and am embarrassed, yes.

I don't want to bag an Aish ... just saying what I see.

Watch him much last year, or in the year he was drafted??

What did you think of Polec before Port got him; or Matt White?

 

[Bosley]

Another assist.

 

[spenze]

Jeebus, we have far greater needs if we are trading our first round pick than Aish. I've watched every game this year and he just isn't worth it...I mean if we had our KPPs all sorted out then maybe, maybe trade our first for him...and even then I wouldn't be happy.

As for talk of him being a better option than Dougie...FFS

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I have watched him before and not been impressed ... now I am focusing on him and am embarrassed, yes.

I don't want to bag an Aish ... just saying what I see.

Do people understand the concept of buying low and talent ......the kid is talented, not happy, so his footy is shit

Would you have wanted to keep CEY last season? ......what about now?

 

[King Elvis]

Do people understand the concept of buying low and talent ......the kid is talented, not happy, so his footy is shit

Would you have wanted to keep CEY last season? ......what about now?

I wonder if the deal has already been done, and he's already mentally checked out...