Judd or Cyril?

[Hodgepodge]

Very interesting comparison, similar players in some ways, good at running through traffic, kicking goals. . .

 

[parrot]

Very interesting comparison, similar players in some ways, good at running through traffic, kicking goals. . .

lol. I love these Hawthorn supporter needy-talk-up-polls. Judd is about 60 talent-classes above "Cyril". You know it , and we all know it.

 

[one_twelve112]

Wagyu Beef or Spam?

 

[JSFish]

Are you kidding me? The best player in the league versus a 6 game player??

 

[Astro_]

Are you kidding me? The best player in the league versus a 6 game player??

That's Hawthorn supporters for you.

Someone layout a few bean bags- this will soften the fall for the million Hawk's supporters as they come crashing down once they realise their unrealistic fantasy dreams wont be met.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Apparently Cyril > Everyone, so by the transitive property, Cyril > Judd.

 

[Carnthe]

Wagyu Beef or Spam?

I've never understood what Wagyu Beef is.... then again I don't understand this thread either...

 

[Hawkas_01]

lol. I love these Hawthorn supporter needy-talk-up-polls. Judd is about 60 talent-classes above "Cyril". You know it , and we all know it.

Are you kidding me? The best player in the league versus a 6 game player??

That's Hawthorn supporters for you.

Someone layout a few bean bags- this will soften the fall for the million Hawk's supporters as they come crashing down once they realise their unrealistic fantasy dreams wont be met.

Apparently Cyril > Everyone, so by the transitive property, Cyril > Judd.

Can't recognise sarcasim?

******s.

 

[mattdwyer]

Can't recognise sarcasim?

******s.

your the ****** ..

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Can't recognise sarcasim?

******s.

Apparently you're the one that can't recognise sarcasm if you thought I was serious.

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

Rioli for me.

 

[Johnny_Segment]

Can't recognise sarcasim?

******s.

your the ****** ..

And it only took you 38 minutes to formulate this come back, bad spelling and all. Well done champ.

 

[Blue Dawn]

Rioli for me.

He'd fit right in to the Bombers recruiting 'strategy'.

 

[blues4flag]

And it only took you 38 minutes to formulate this come back, bad spelling and all. Well done champ.

Technically, it was the Hawthorn supporter with the bad spelling. Grammar =/= spelling

 

[Power King]

cyril easily

judd hasn't won a brownlow, norm smith, been all australian, captained a premiership side all before turning 23

oh, wait...

 

[davomavo]

Judd easy

 

[jiphoc]

Judd until Junior can prove himself over the long run

 

[Upgrayedd]

Cyril after only 6 rounds is playing better then Judd is this season, its scary to think when Cyril hits his peak

 

[Willie Stark]

Cyril after only 6 rounds is playing better then Judd is this season, its scary to think when Cyril hits his peak

Oh God

 

[Flamin Joe]

It's threads like this that make me cringe as a fellow Hawthorn supporter.

What's next? Thorp vs J Brown?

 

[Cat for Life]

Very similar players, both play football.

 

[parrot]

Cyril after only 6 rounds is playing better then Judd is this season, ...

Could you let us all know when you actually start watching footy games. lol.

 

[mannyj]

very much embarassing for whoever created this...


you cannot be serious??

maybe try, Judd Vs any other played in competition.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Could you let us all know when you actually start watching footy games. lol.

We all know you have started tuning in to watch for the first time in 5 years since carlton have strung some wins together typical bandwagon carlton supporters

Judd is a broken shell of he once was, i have doubt that he'll last another 4 years, he cant kick over 35 meters

Cyril on the otherhand has a huge upside and plenty of raw talent, has twice the natural skill that judd as possessed in his first 6 games as an 18 year old hes already the talk of the town. Its a wonderful feeling that hes only preforming to 25% of what hes capable of

Cyril by a loong way

 

[parrot]

..
Judd is a broken shell of he once was, i have doubt .....

lol. Yep, you don't watch any footy. Confirmed. I have noted that Hawthorn supporters anti-Carlton talent envy has escalated markedly over the past few weeks. Interesting. No Franklin, no Hawthorn? Certainly was at the end of last season, and I suspect that is still the case, and this could be the reason for your anti-Carlton talent envy.