Judd Or Westy

[Kerrby]

Who Would you go for?

They're about even in disposals, handballs, marks e.t.c.

P.s Don't bite my head off if this has already been done.

 

[borgy]

Brad Johnson V Shannon Grant board.

 

[DapperDon]

yeah we get it already, Judd is good and will never lose a poll.

get over it, we have

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Who the hell voted for Scott West?

 

[greenlight]

I voted judd due to the fact he,s younger but no doubting west has been fantastic but hes at the end of his career

 

[bellzy]

I voted judd due to the fact he,s younger but no doubting west has been fantastic but hes at the end of his career

The fact that he happens to be the better player means nothing though?

 

[lifelike_]

Umm, yeah.....

 

[JKCeagle]

West has been a fantastic player, but it'd be hard for even the most one-eyed Bulldogs supporter to vote him over Chris Judd...

 

[mudgeathon]

An example of why 'newbies' shouldn't be allowed to create threads

 

[Quinz]

What a silly poll.

 

[Kerrby]

An example of why 'newbies' shouldn't be allowed to create threads

What newbie created this thread? I see no newbies that created his thread? Are you seeing things or are you just crazy? I expected better from a West Coast supporter....

 

[Kochie 16]

this poll is rigged

 

[Kerrby]

Yes it's rigged. I made 28 votes to Judd, i don't know how it's possible.

 

[Souup]

Voted for West because an Eagles supporter created the poll

 

[Kerrby]

Voted for West because an Eagles supporter created the poll

Whoa! arn't you great? You would choose Scott West over Chris Judd, because a West Coast supporter created a thread. Arn't you that great, that you won't worry about players, just what someone else is asking.

 

[Beloved]

haha what a loser, u dont vote 4 west just coz the maker is an eagles supporter, its about whose better, duuuur.

 

[Souup]

haha what a loser, u dont vote 4 west just coz the maker is an eagles supporter, its about whose better, duuuur.

You're both tools

Its quite obvious he's created this poll to brag about Judd

 

[micky_ashman]

both gun players but west is better

 

[Kerrby]

You're both tools

Its quite obvious he's created this poll to brag about Judd

Why thankyou, no i didn't want to brag about Judd, i wanted to know what Bigfooty thinks.

Btw, who can you brag about from the Kangas?

 

[wally funk]

i'd easily go west if they were the same age, but the fact that judd is NINE years younger, i'd pick him.

 

[dales.girl38]

i'd easily go west if they were the same age, but the fact that judd is NINE years younger, i'd pick him.

Same. Who would pick a 31 year old over a...is he 23? Anyway, it's a stupid poll- we all know Judd is amazing, no need to compare him to veterans.

 

[mudgeathon]

i'd easily go west if they were the same age, but the fact that judd is NINE years younger, i'd pick him.

Why would you though?

Judd vs West at their respective peaks [Judd hasn't hit his yet]

Judd gets more clearences
More contested Posessions
Kicks more goals
Is more damaging with his possesions
Is a match winner
More inspiring [does the things like James Hird does]

Judd is the best Inside and outside midfielder of the last 25 years [this doesn't meen best...yet anyway]

Just curious to know why you would choose West, when Judd has him covered in every area with ease

 

[dales.girl38]

Why would you though?

Judd vs West at their respective peaks [Judd hasn't hit his yet]

Judd gets more clearences
More contested Posessions
Kicks more goals
Is more damaging with his possesions
Is a match winner
More inspiring [does the things like James Hird does]

Judd is the best Inside and outside midfielder of the last 25 years [this doesn't meen best...yet anyway]

Just curious to know why you would choose West, when Judd has him covered in every area with ease

Does it even matter...?

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Does it even matter...?

No, it doesn't...

But for the sake of the question, yourself and Wally Funk both suggested that age was the only reason you would go with Judd...

You're actually saying that if you had two 17 year olds in front of you - One was definitely going to be the next Chris Judd, and the other was definitely going to be the next Scott West, and you would take the Scott West clone?

That's quite simply ridiculous. The best year of Scott West's career doesn't come close to Chris Judd's 2004 or 2006.

Judd is comfortably a much better player than Scott West, and quite frankly, it's silly that anyone has voted for West. This poll is the equivalent of Wayne Carey vs. Stewart Loewe, and people actually voting for Loewe.

 

[Kochie 16]

Why would you though?

Judd vs West at their respective peaks [Judd hasn't hit his yet]

Judd gets more clearences
More contested Posessions
Kicks more goals
Is more damaging with his possesions
Is a match winner
More inspiring [does the things like James Hird does]

Judd is the best Inside and outside midfielder of the last 25 years [this doesn't meen best...yet anyway]

Just curious to know why you would choose West, when Judd has him covered in every area with ease

Hahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahahhahah.......... (*Wipes tears from eye*) That was the best laugh I've had in years (Days actually but years makes it more hilarious)!