Lol, hilarious watching a bunch of VIP's not disagreeing with what I actually posted. Just having hissy fits about what they would like me to have posted instead. 
-
LIVE: Carlton v Hawthorn - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Hawks at 69% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 2
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 1 Winner: dreamkillers
Kornes, Maclure and their 30 A Graders
- Thread starter Fadge
- Start date
- Tagged users None
The very bad news for you is Fadge loves this post.
The good news is there still may be hope for you if I explain one small fact to you...
McKay changed hands as a free agent, so the actual pick North got is reflective of how shyte North were that season, rather than how good McKay was.
Fadge might have been able to explain that to you in the interests of keeping people on this thread informed. As usual, it falls to ol muggins here.
- Thread starter
- #128
No. No disagreements from anyone...Lol, hilarious watching a bunch of VIP's not disagreeing with what I actually posted. Just having hissy fits about what they would like me to have posted instead.
- Apr 12, 2015
- 3,592
- 5,913
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Just when you think Cornes can’t be any more of a dead set half wit, he does an ‘A’ grade list with no Harris Andrew’s. Sicily- has to be stiff, bloke is a gun.
Ludicrously nebulous terms like A grader are just an excuse for people to push agendas without being held to account.
Drongos like Cornes & Fadge think they can watch a few games of footy, sniff the wind a bit and figure out better than the coaches and list managers(who devote their whole working lives, inside knowledge and far greater expertise to it)which players are of most value. It is hilarious when you really think about it.
Fadge championing the cause of people being able to form opinions without being ridiculed now.Something is not quite adding up here.
- Thread starter
- #133
Merely pointing out your hypocrisy.
Something is not quite adding up here.
I'd like to know what 'agenda' I'm trying to push by starting this thread and sharing my own personal opinion.
Is this yet another Anti-Richmond conspiracy to go with Stephen Hocking, the stand rule and the ARC?
- Thread starter
- #134
Hang on Meow....
Are you really telling me Lynch hasn't been awarded an All-Australian since he's been at Richmond?
The AA Selectors really do not like the Tigers, do they?
Rankine
Dawson
Neale
Cameron
Ashcroft
Dunkley
Daicos
Daicos
De Goey
Cripps
Curnow
Mckay
Weitering
Walsh
Merrett
Serong
Brayshaw
Young
Bolton
Ryan
Cameron
Stewart
Stengle
Dangerfield
Rowell
Anderson
King
Hogan
Greene
Green
Taylor
Barrass
Sicily
Newcombe
Day
Sheezel
Larkey
LDU
Petracca
Oliver
Gawn
Butters
Rozee
JHF
Lynch
Steele
King
Sinclair
Heeney
Gulden
Warner
Rampe
Kelly
Mcgovern
Bont
English
Liberatore
Dawson
Neale
Cameron
Ashcroft
Dunkley
Daicos
Daicos
De Goey
Cripps
Curnow
Mckay
Weitering
Walsh
Merrett
Serong
Brayshaw
Young
Bolton
Ryan
Cameron
Stewart
Stengle
Dangerfield
Rowell
Anderson
King
Hogan
Greene
Green
Taylor
Barrass
Sicily
Newcombe
Day
Sheezel
Larkey
LDU
Petracca
Oliver
Gawn
Butters
Rozee
JHF
Lynch
Steele
King
Sinclair
Heeney
Gulden
Warner
Rampe
Kelly
Mcgovern
Bont
English
Liberatore
I think Rampe is one of the most consistent and best defenders of the last 10 years is slowly declining but still above the others.
Ryan has put together about 5 very good years now and plays above and below his height great versatility.
I am not a big fan of Houston I don’t see what others see.
Treacy could be in a years time just don’t see him to have the runs on the board yet. He is B +.
Waterman had an A grade year but wasn’t far off being delisted in recent year.
Holmes B+ on the verge of being A for sure could include him though.
Miller was an A grade player but isn’t atm.
Moore the same.
This was just me going off the top of my head opinion based of who I think is an A grade player. I would say 50 is a good number for A grade players makes them about the top 7 percent of players in total.
A + would be another story.
- Jun 9, 2008
- 12,444
- 12,592
- AFL Club
- Carlton
KissKiss
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 26, 2012
- 8,769
- 11,200
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Gotta fit it to a proper bell curve
In this instance, it can be defined by what it is not. 'A' is the highest grade (we can assume given the best players in the league are included - Daicos, Cripps etc, that there is no 'A+' grader) therefore any player not included on these lists better than the other players included, we can define them as A grade.
Exactly
- Thread starter
- #144
Sam McClure interviewed a week after his list was published, and he regrets omitting one player from his list - Pendlebury.
The one he regrets including - Sam Taylor, given he's only played two full seasons in seven.
Interesting calls.
The one he regrets including - Sam Taylor, given he's only played two full seasons in seven.
Interesting calls.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 15,834
- 32,006
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Sam McClure is like the football equivalent of the Victorian Liberal Party. Just when you think they couldn't possibly get any dumber, they go and say something as dumb as this and make you realise there is no limit to their stupidity.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 15,834
- 32,006
- AFL Club
- Carlton
About as far from a Labor or Dan fan as you'll ever get, please never attach that title to me.
The point still remains, Taylor is close to the best key defender in the league. Pendles wouldn't be in the top 50 mids these days.
McClure is an idiot.
- Feb 11, 2025
- 155
- 122
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
average Collingwood hater Pendles is easily still a top 50 mid on leadership alone and did you even see that crows game mate? two goals and 30 disposals at 36 years old is taking the piss shockingly bad take.
- Thread starter
- #149
If it's about 'putting an A Grade season together', it is not an unreasonable call, if one player can't consistently get on the park.
But I forgot... apparently Pendlebury wouldn't get a game at Carlton....
LOLOL
- Feb 11, 2025
- 155
- 122
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Cripps isn't even that good anymore lol will be cooked by 32 due to carrying Cartoon for 10 years
Similar threads
