Koschitzke or Didak?

[jonesy86]

Taken at numbers 2 and 3 in the 2000 National Draft who would you prefer now?

Bias aside i'd take Didak, not injury prone, does the incredible and is an out and out match winner

Thoughts?

 

[Saint Corin]

While Kosi has had is fair share of injury, Kosi's best is better is better than Didak's I beleive... Those 5 games where Kosi poled 12 Brownlow votes I think it was, showed what he can do, A fantastic Contested mark which is a rare comoditity and when fit gives the ruck a fair shake. Won his rising star at CHB, can play up forward we all know, and when fit was really good in the ruck with like 20+ touches around the ground and he pushed forward.

Didak is a fantastic player though, awsome in goal assists and getting out of trouble...

So i guess it's a matter of opinion, i just think that big contested marking power forwards are far more valuable... Not taking away anything from Didak who should be AA and has has a sensational season, I'd be happy with either... But Kosi for me...

 

[Oh When the Saints]

Good poll

Didak has had a superb 2006, but there is no doubt that Koschitzke at his best is greater than Didak at his best.

Didak has only played 20 more games than Kosi, so the injury thing isn't as big as it seems.

Wait until the end of their careers before making a final judgement though.

 

[jonesy86]

Fair points, Kosi could turn out to be a dominant ruckman who can play KP forward or back if thats the case Kosi would be better but if he just plays KP i think Didak would have him covered in single handedly winning games

 

[parrot]

Silly poll. Kosi by miles. I wouldn't want Didak in my side - period.

 

[Jabso]

Coulda woulda shoulda.

 

[lihei]

Silly poll. Kosi by miles. I wouldn't want Didak in my side - period.

Stupid response - how about having some b*lls and justifying this insipid reply?

 

[KING-JAMES]

Kosi, i was thinking about this today and just say he went to the pies and didnt have these injuries he could very well be the best player from that draft. I think Koschitzke when fit is easily the better player.

 

[Smell The Glove]

Tough call. As much as I hate Didak for being a dirty little s h i t that id like to punch fifteen shades of sh it out of, he certainly is a sensational player that can really make the difference between an ordinary forward line (ie. the Pies) and a good forward line (ie. the Pies). Kosi can be more dominant though, as he showed in that purple patch last year, and versatile dominant big men are so hard to find and develop. Is very soft though, one thing Didak definitely has over him. Kosi just, even with his injuries.

 

[FIGJAM]

Kosi, i was thinking about this today and just say he went to the pies and didnt have these injuries he could very well be the best player from that draft. I think Koschitzke when fit is easily the better player.

I don't think anyone would disagree with this. Unfortunately he's rarely fully fit.

If I were offered one or the other as coach of another team, I'd take Didak, but only on the trend line of lesser injuries. Even when coming back from injury, Didak's form has got back to near pre-injury quicker, which you'd exect for small compared to talls.

 

[mini_me316]

Kosi if he is injury free.
Kosi by a mile because he has an amazing work rate can play forward, back or midfield and isn't a smart arse.

 

[Patty#32]

Didak