Matthew Scharenberg

[CFC2010]

I must have missed that press conference.

It was today....he said the Pies have forgotten how to win.

Can't make finals if you don't know how to win.......its not rocket science Bucks

 

[TW Sherrin]

I don't quite get the line that Sharenberg wants to play a well in the ones to bump his value. Sure the club know what he's worth and a couple of senior games wont add 100k's to it.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

He makes decisions like Pendlebury, has time with the ball like Pendlebury, but doesn't have his evasiveness, he's more of a straight line mover.

I didnt compare him with Pendles....just with Pendles vision and time. After one game its impossible to know what he will evolve into but I like the look of him because he is already showing confidence beyond his years.

 

[jackcass]

my first impressions: smart, calm

would be more excited about him but don't think he will be at the club next year.

usually when a kid gets supported through multiple injuries they repay the faith and resign.

is he a restricted free agent and therefore can only go if we don't match the crows offer?

No. But as an uncontracted player he can opt for the draft. That's unlikely to help him get to the Crows or the Power though.

 

[jackcass]

Also it wasn't a choice between Gault & Stewart. it was either pick 20 (Broomhead) or 38 Ramnsay

Yep, it's been done to death but a few can't seem to grasp that boat has sailed and for varied reasons we opted not to commit to Stewart. Who knows, we may well have taken him instead of Ramsay if he'd still been available.

 

[MattyMand]

I don't quite get the line that Sharenberg wants to play a well in the ones to bump his value. Sure the club know what he's worth and a couple of senior games wont add 100k's to it.

Yeah it will bump up his value if he wants to go somewhere else

 

[jackcass]

It was today....he said the Pies have forgotten how to win.

Can't make finals if you don't know how to win.......its not rocket science Bucks

Right... a general statement that the side has forgotten how to win = Buckley has lost interest in finals... Of course, how silly of me!

 

[ThePhantom777]

Right... a general statement that the side has forgotten how to win = Buckley has lost interest in finals... Of course, how silly of me!

Isn't this the Scharenberg thread?

 

[jackcass]

I don't quite get the line that Sharenberg wants to play a well in the ones to bump his value. Sure the club know what he's worth and a couple of senior games wont add 100k's to it.

Nobody actually knows why he's yet to sign, it's all guesswork.

Maybe he just needs to convince himself that he's still got senior footy in him before committing.

Maybe he is trying to bump his value, and maybe he won't squeeze an extra $100K but would you say no to an additional $30K or $40K or $50K a year in your salary?

Maybe he is going home.

I don't understand why we need to be so consumed by it when there is absolutely SFA we can do about it.

 

[jackcass]

Isn't this the Scharenberg thread?

And maybe if you read the thread you'll have context

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I didnt compare him with Pendles....just with Pendles vision and time.

Well I not only compared but also contrasted, so ha!

Stick that in your pipe and smoke it!

 

[Baltimore Jack]

It was today....he said the Pies have forgotten how to win.

Can't make finals if you don't know how to win.......its not rocket science Bucks

Or unsubstantiated speculation and ill-informed opinion based on things that were never said

 

[rand corp]

One thing I did take from his first game is a real desire to watch this kid play a lot more football.

 

[CFC2010]

Or unsubstantiated speculation and ill-informed opinion based on things that were never said

Enjoy B J

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...how-to-win-again/story-fni5f6hd-1227470633788

 

[jackcass]

Enjoy B J

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/nathan-buckley-says-collingwood-must-learn-how-to-win-again/story-fni5f6hd-1227470633788

Yeah, this bit was really telling....

“We’re still a shot at finals, and I think we can get our season back on track on Saturday,” he said.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Enjoy B J

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...how-to-win-again/story-fni5f6hd-1227470633788

Still looking for the bit about "can't make the finals"...oh wait, you made that bit up, didn't you?

 

[CFC2010]

Yeah, this bit was really telling....

“We’re still a shot at finals, and I think we can get our season back on track on Saturday,” he said.

Um maybe have another read smarty pants......I am pretty sure Scott Pendlebury is not Nathan Buckley.


"Magpies skipper Scott Pendlebury conceded it’s been a tough six weeks, but is holding out hope of seeing September action.

“We’re still a shot at finals, and I think we can get our season back on track on Saturday,” he said.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Um maybe have another read smarty pants......I am pretty sure Scott Pendlebury is not Nathan Buckley.


"Magpies skipper Scott Pendlebury conceded it’s been a tough six weeks, but is holding out hope of seeing September action.

“We’re still a shot at finals, and I think we can get our season back on track on Saturday,” he said.

Look, you said it right here ----> "Can't make finals if you don't know how to win.......its not rocket science Bucks"

 

[CFC2010]

Still looking for the bit about "can't make the finals"...oh wait, you made that bit up, didn't you?

That would have been the "part" last week in regards to not trying to make the finals.

When you drop a forward and let his replacement sit on the bench for three quarters hereby giving an average team a sniff.....then that in my eyes is tanking!

Before you highlight that is only my opinion.......Do you honestly think Bucks would admit to tanking????


P.S Back on topic please play Shaz for the rest of year Bucks the kid is the future!

 

[PieBeast]

The only fault I really found in his first game was a tendency to handball straight away when surrounded (in the manner of Frost), with no idea of the circumstances of the receiver. In a player's first game, with the whole team under the hammer, I am not ready to extrapolate this very far. Let's just wait and see.

That's pretty much all I took from this ridiculously short sample of his game at senior level.
Interestingly enough others are talking about Pendles' like vision...
To be fair there was one kick under no pressure whatsoever that hit the target and the sidestep that will be spoken about for generations to come.

Being slightly more serious for a second he clearly wasn't ready for the step up in pace but didn't disgrace himself either.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

That would have been the "part" last week in regards to not trying to make the finals.

When you drop a forward and let his replacement sit on the bench for three quarters hereby giving an average team a sniff.....then that in my eyes is tanking!

Before you highlight that is only my opinion.......Do you honestly think Bucks would admit to tanking????


P.S Back on topic please play Shaz for the rest of year Bucks the kid is the future!

I tried, no I really tried

 

[Bucksboys]

Dangerfield is the only other decent player with 11 letters in his last name

I think it's a sign

 

[CFC2010]

I tried, no I really tried

Thanks for your effort it was greatly appreciated.

 

[PieBeast]

Thanks for your effort it was greatly appreciated.

Harsh










should have offered some sort of a participation award

 

[jackcass]

Um maybe have another read smarty pants......I am pretty sure Scott Pendlebury is not Nathan Buckley.


"Magpies skipper Scott Pendlebury conceded it’s been a tough six weeks, but is holding out hope of seeing September action.

“We’re still a shot at finals, and I think we can get our season back on track on Saturday,” he said.

Right, and where exactly did I say Buckley said it or announce that Pendles was Bucks? Smarty pants indeed. Maybe you should just concentrate on being right instead of over-reaching aiming for clever.