Most Underated and overated player in the AFL

[F-U]

Overrated : Mark Ricciuto - Unlike a true great of the game the guys as dumb as a post, when he goes forward unlike the true greats in Buckley Hird and Voss who do well he provides his team with nothing. Instead of going forward he spends 25% off the game on the bench and comes on when the opposition has there tagger on the bench to pick up his 20 odd stats bashin about kids half his size

Underrated : Luke McPharlin - The guy does it all, defence forward, the guys got the biggest leap you would ever see. A absolute star in any other team me thinks.

 

[Ported]

Hah, these all sound like grudge lists. Chad is pretty close to our best player really. I'm surpised not to have seen Francou on an overrated list yet.

 

[outback jack]

overrated on current output- cousins, did bugger all in the finals Judd is a couple classes above him. Kane cornes, Macca, Tredrea, josh carr

Underrated- R James (won the preimiership for port last yr), Perrie, Roo, pavlich (both absolute champions)


and theres probably an hundred others that could easily be put on both lists.

 

[JonHay2]

Most overated player without a shadow of doubt is Nick Riewoltd. He is a good mark and kick of the footy, which are key elements of any centre half forward - but he SERIOULSY lacks the strength. Not that he isn't a great player, it is just that he isn't as good as most make him out to be (i.e. top 10 players in the league) hence the phrasing "most overated".

There are many underated players. Generally the hard at it midfielders. Off the top of my head - Kane Cornes, Daniel Harris and Adam McPhee are all players who don't get the credit that they deserve.

 

[mark73]

Overrated : Mark Ricciuto - Unlike a true great of the game the guys as dumb as a post, when he goes forward unlike the true greats in Buckley Hird and Voss who do well he provides his team with nothing. Instead of going forward he spends 25% off the game on the bench and comes on when the opposition has there tagger on the bench to pick up his 20 odd stats bashin about kids half his size

Underrated : Luke McPharlin - The guy does it all, defence forward, the guys got the biggest leap you would ever see. A absolute star in any other team me thinks.

You seriously don't like Mark Ricciuto do you?

 

[Jimthegreat]

Hah, these all sound like grudge lists. Chad is pretty close to our best player really. I'm surpised not to have seen Francou on an overrated list yet.

Ok then.overrated=Josh Francou, only for the reason you're surprised. I'm working towards a 1000 posts so I need an excuse for a few crappy one's to get over the line.

Seriously though, I've never really thought or cared. The 'overrated" opinions should be put on a "biased" board, if they had one as many could never think of a real reason otherwise.