munro and adkins

[underthebridge]

those who think munro is to thin to play, or needs to bulk up, what do u think about adkins?

Adkins:
Height 181cm
Weight: 73kg

Munro
Height 182cm
Weight: 75kg

i have never seen adkins pull of a tackle, he always get pushed off.

 

[Deegle]

theyre both soft, outside players in my opinion

You could also chuck in Callum Chambers into that list.

 

[underthebridge]

i reckon callum has a lot of strengh, he is light, but has muscle. he can lay a good tackle from what ive seen, but not often enough.

 

[underthebridge]

adkins attempt to tackle (i think in the 2nd)someone, and he bounced right off him. he is a talented player, but seriously needs to bulk up.

 

[jod23]

Both will be delisted at years end.

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by jod23
Both will be delisted at years end.

Do you really think so?

Munro yes, but the club has given Adkins plenty of opportunities this year, and that would be unusual for someone who was to be delisted.

 

[The_Ruffneck]

next years should be adkins' last chance , they never give him enough time on the field in yesterdays game he only had 38 minutes on the pitch out of 122 total minutes.As for delistings there are alot of people in the mix , i don't think adkins is at the top of the list to be delisted so he might scrape through....my thought on who will be delisted...
Humm (been there 4 years just not good enough)
Munro (ditto)
Collica (just never gets a game)
Jakovich (speaks for itself)
so those 4 should get delisted , Worsfold wouldent make more than 4 delistings in a year id think because to me he seems conservative

 

[jod23]

Originally posted by larrikin
Do you really think so?

Munro yes, but the club has given Adkins plenty of opportunities this year, and that would be unusual for someone who was to be delisted.

Yeah I really think so. He might get saved for the simple fact that others might be slightly ahead of him on the chopping block. Jako is one delisting (retirement) and Munro will be another.

That leaves two more spots. Humm could go and might be ahead of Adkins in the chopping order and then there is Collica who seems to be behind Brett Jones, Carroll and Hunter as a third tall in defence.

So IMO Adkins may be saved just because we have a few that might be ahead of him.

 

[The Passenger]

i think there may be a few more delistings than some think. B. Jones has to get promoted. And i'd say one of Graham or Rudeforth will as well.

We have 38 on our main list plus Jako (now gone).

Meaning we will have to delist or trade for picks a further 5 to get down to the minimum of 35 on draft day.

 

[Monocle]

Originally posted by underthebridge
those who think munro is to thin to play, or needs to bulk up, what do u think about adkins?

Adkins:
Height 181cm
Weight: 73kg

Munro
Height 182cm
Weight: 75kg

i have never seen adkins pull of a tackle, he always get pushed off.

Difficult to see both of them staying. The development of Butler ahead of schedule and the real prospect of Morton being drafted would in my opinion lead to at least one of Adkins and Munro moving on.

At this stage if we were to keep one I would believe it would be Adkins who keeps his spot. However I suspect that they may both get their marching orders.

 

[noodle]

Originally posted by underthebridge
adkins attempt to tackle (i think in the 2nd)someone, and he bounced right off him. he is a talented player, but seriously needs to bulk up.

that someone was ben grayham. hard guy to tackle for the best of them.

 

[Hit And Rum]

Money Man!!! Money Man!!! Money Man!!!

 

[noodle]

ah. selection night tomorrow night.

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by Hit And Rum
Money Man!!! Money Man!!! Money Man!!!

Sorry Kane, it aint happening.

 

[noogie_da_sheep]

yeah Munro is gone at seasons end...as is Humm, Jako (obviously), Collica and possibly Paul Johnson.

 

[Hit And Rum]

Sorry John Lennon but:

"All I am saying is, give Munners a chance"