Murphy or Gibbs?

[Heisenberg_]

Yep stay true to form and avoid the issue at hand which is the dire position that the Carlton Football Club is in, the past is irrelevent, so forget about it, our future is looking good on and off the field, our young players are improving a lot, our players actually want to play for us- hello Brett Thornton, we are posting profit of $1 million dollars.
Now lets look at Carlton, granted they have some talented young players, but its the players after that that are of a great worry, not much chop at all. And did i mention the total shambles off the field they are, can't you remember how embaressing it was with the whole Pagan situation and the board at seasons end, and the debt which will take at least 10 years to clear minimum sinse its going to get even bigger next year.

 

[gandaal]

Yep stay true to form and avoid the issue at hand which is the dire position that the Carlton Football Club is in, the past is irrelevent, so forget about it, our future is looking good on and off the field, our young players are improving a lot, our players actually want to play for us- hello Brett Thornton, we are posting profit of $1 million dollars.
Now lets look at Carlton, granted they have some talented young players, but its the players after that that are of a great worry, not much chop at all. And did i mention the total shambles off the field they are, can't you remember how embaressing it was with the whole Pagan situation and the board at seasons end, and the debt which will take at least 10 years to clear minimum sinse its going to get even bigger next year.

Fitzroy Football Club
"Well we've still played in more final series over the last 23 years than Richmond"

 

[Heisenberg_]

Fitzroy Football Club
"Well we've still played in more final series over the last 23 years than Richmond"

typical wind out the past because you know that everything i said is corect, it is sad and i am fully serious when i say that because you were a great club, now you can't even guarantee you will still be open for business next year.
Kind of ironic that your paying out my club with Fitzroy when there is a very good chance Carlton will be going down that path

 

[gandaal]

typical wind out the past because you know that everything i said is corect, it is sad and i am fully serious when i say that because you were a great club, now you can't even guarantee you will still be open for business next year.
Kind of ironic that your paying out my club with Fitzroy when there is a very good chance Carlton will be going down that path

I realise that you're a bit bitter about Brett "Chris Judd" Deledio turning out not to be as good as two player drafted soon after him but you've got to let it go. Carlton have done very well with Murphy and you're going to have to live with that fact.

Fitzroy Football Club
"Well we've still played in more final series over the last 23 years than Richmond"

 

[parrot]

Haha pwned.

1 flag in 45 years. Success?

 

[Smell The Glove]

1 flag in 45 years. Success?

Haha pwned.

 

[Fletchers Girl]

I can't believe this poll is so close! I don't understand how you can vote for Gibbs when he has proven jack s h i t! Murphy is a bloody gun!! and a proven one at that!

 

[Silvagnis]

I can't believe this poll is so close! I don't understand how you can vote for Gibbs when he has proven jack s h i t! Murphy is a bloody gun!! and a proven one at that!

I can't believe you expected people on Bigfooty to be intelligent and to vote for Murphy.

 

[Fletchers Girl]

I can't believe you expected people on Bigfooty to be intelligent and to vote for Murphy.

I know silly me!!! *slaps self across the head*

 

[Sockit151]

Which of thesè young super star`s would you take if given the choice? Would it be the Murphy the one who has proven he has what it takes to be a superstar at AFL level or would it be Gibbs, possibily the most highly rated player in draft history who has unnlimited potential but is yet to play an AFL game?

Who cares, we have both!!

 

[borgy]

Who cares, we have both!!

its going to be great to watch them both develop into stars in the future, good midfield the blues are building!

 

[Jeremias]

How the hell is Murphy losing this poll?

 

[gandaal]

How the hell is Murphy losing this poll?

You gotta feel sorry for Gibbs when that's the kind of expectation placed on him

 

[Jeremias]

You gotta feel sorry for Gibbs when that's the kind of expectation placed on him

Sure do-there is always huge expectations on the number 1 pick, but this is unparalleled.

 

[parrot]

You gotta feel sorry for Gibbs when that's the kind of expectation placed on him

I think Murph and Walker will provide massive support in that regard. From all reports, Bryce has a great temperament, and we have a lot of SA players, plus Bradley and Sticks around the Club. Murph, Gibbs in the midfield in 2007. Wow. From all reports Russell is looking to make a serious midfield impact in 2007. Throw in Walker, Simmo and Blackwell, and you have some very serious midfield talent. Just can't wait untill 2007.

 

[Heisenberg_]

I think Murph and Walker will provide massive support in that regard. From all reports, Bryce has a great temperament, and we have a lot of SA players, plus Bradley and Sticks around the Club. Murph, Gibbs in the midfield in 2007. Wow. From all reports Russell is looking to make a serious midfield impact in 2007. Throw in Walker, Simmo and Blackwell, and you have some very serious midfield talent. Just can't wait untill 2007.

Russell, talent, what are you on about.
But Murphy and Gibbs should give you a good platform to build on

 

[parrot]

Russell, talent, what are you on about.
But Murphy and Gibbs should give you a good platform to build on

Russell like Walker, Murph, and Gibbs are elite midfield talent. Period. Russell has taken a while to develop, but has blistering pace, stands about 188-190cm, and has excellent skills. Bradley and Ratten are working closely with Jordon to help him take the next step. You'll be in for a little surprise in 2007. Jordon will be very very good. The Blues are amassing some amazing talent now. How do you feel about the Tiges giving up a top-10 pick in this years super-draft? Hopefully your recycled Freo player will do OK. Kent Kingsley looks like being the Tiges main KP forward as well. Interesting.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Russell like Walker, Murph, and Gibbs are elite midfield talent. Period. Russell has taken a while to develop, but has blistering pace, stands about 188-190cm, and has excellent skills. Bradley and Ratten are working closely with Jordon to help him take the next step. You'll be in for a little surprise in 2007. Jordon will be very very good. The Blues are amassing some amazing talent now. How do you feel about the Tiges giving up a top-10 pick in this years super-draft? Hopefully your recycled Freo player will do OK. Kent Kingsley looks like being the Tiges main KP forward as well. Interesting.

We didnt take Kingsley
And i did compliment your young team then parrot, Murphy and Gibbs are a good base to work on. Walker will be good if his skills improve, but i just dont like what i see with Russell, not trying to troll, just my opinion.
And on another note, Daniel Conners pick 58- top 10 quality a lotof clubs will be left red faced

 

[parrot]

We didnt take Kingsley
And i did compliment your young team then parrot, Murphy and Gibbs are a good base to work on. Walker will be good if his skills improve, but i just dont like what i see with Russell, not trying to troll, just my opinion...

No problem. I guess I know a little more about Russell. You'll see in 2007. Anyone involved with the Blues, knows that there is a hell of a lot of excitement down there now. Denis and the other coaches, know they finally have the talent to build a very very impressive team. Ratten and Bradley have been sensational additions, and are providing invaluable guidance to our young midfielders. The Blues looks set to regain their traditional superpower Club status over the next few years.