Mystical Mac's Phantom Draft

[WCE2012]

Well ONE of them is Will Sullivan ; 202 cm but apparently skinny. He was picked up last year in the rookie draft.

Alexander Sneddon, a NSW scholarship holder
http://www.sportingpulse.com/assoc_...task=DETAIL&articleID=6276032&sectionID=55526

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

My only issue is that Dees take 2 ruckman with their top picks. I fail to see how Naitanui would 'save' the dees marketing wise though.

 

[richoatthedisco]

did you miss Schoenmakers in this or do you just not rate him top 34?

Yeah I'd much rather have Schoenmakers for the Tigs at pick 26, or Hanneberry come to that. We don't need a specialist small forward, certainly not more than a key forward or class mid. We have Brown, Morton and Edwards, with Collard getting fit and impressing on the rookie list. To have Rusty & Schoey would be a great result for us, and we'd have the two best names in the draft, if not the AFL.

 

[Mystical Mac]

this is the best phantom draft ive see and you didnt just copy what everybody else has done. i like naitanui at pick one and trengrove at 6. the only problem ive got is it was only 2 round and i was just starting to get in to it. could you please do a part 2. i would love to see how you think the rest of the draft pans out.

thanks mate

it took me ages to do 2 rounds so i might try the rest later but not now!

 

[Mystical Mac]

did you miss Schoenmakers in this or do you just not rate him top 34?

I thought about him but still have some doubts. Probably should have had him going to Geelong at 33

 

[Mystical Mac]

My only issue is that Dees take 2 ruckman with their top picks. I fail to see how Naitanui would 'save' the dees marketing wise though.

the marketing thing with Nic Nat would be a bonus for the dees. i really believe he is the best player in the draft and if he is a gun his looks and size and aggression will get a lot of attention for the team he plays for. And mckernan will only pinch hit in ruck when he gets into the afl. he will be a forward.

 

[true blue19]

Alexander Sneddon, a NSW scholarship holder
http://www.sportingpulse.com/assoc_...task=DETAIL&articleID=6276032&sectionID=55526

thank man thats some tall timber coming throw at the weagle

 

[whelan=legend]

I would just about neck myself if we got Naita instead of Watts