MattDoggies
Rookie
- May 3, 2009
- 21
- 0
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Lockyer vs Goddard?
(New) Player Comparison Thread
- Thread starter chrisknights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Feb 28, 2009
- 37,123
- 34,299
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Atletico
Buddy with both, but personally, Id try elsewhere
Goddard. I think that he is more consistent. Lockyer is more likely to give you 120-130 1 week and then 65 the next.
Stokes v Davey?
kangaroos3
Team Captain
- Jul 15, 2008
- 366
- 227
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Stuck on who to upgrade to out of Embley or Mackie..
I will aim to eventually get both but for the first one I'm leaning towards Mackie because he has a low B/E and Embley has a high one so he will most likely drop next week.
Thoughts?
I will aim to eventually get both but for the first one I'm leaning towards Mackie because he has a low B/E and Embley has a high one so he will most likely drop next week.
Thoughts?
- Nov 23, 2008
- 12,452
- 293
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Pavlich V. J. Brown
- Nov 23, 2008
- 12,452
- 293
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Mackie (Harley returns)
I wouldn't get either, but if I had to then probably Davey; I still think Stokes' spot in that lineup is questionable- if they ever do falter a little he will come under question, and Davey looks to have stepped up this year.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 37,123
- 34,299
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Atletico
Id go with Pavlich + Cooney. Should average about 180-200 between the two of them for the rest of the year (Pav 90-100, Cooney 90-95).
I dont really like ROK this year, he doesnt seem to really want to play and i think he is more likely to play like his has Rnd1-6 and he did against the Cats and average ~75. They combination of ROK and one of those mids is more likely to averge 165-185 imo.
- Oct 18, 2008
- 1,293
- 1,996
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Aston Villa
just wanna know who is the best value and scoring premium from here on in besides cornes fisher and goddard. i think lockyer will be too inconsistent but will be decent whilst mackie i have never really rated and is just an average player. i think i might get waite thie week as he is having a good season and should be able to keep it up who likes waite and is he a good option compared to others at 383k?/?
there are plenty of options at about 380k but i do agree that waite is having a good year. He is currently in the top 5 backs of the comp and he would be a unique pick
- Banned
- #62
Roughead or Buddy?
Another choice I'm thinking hard on is Waite or Lockyer? Waite seems like a gun but Lockyer gets so many cheap marks, that he's displayed on the front page of the AFL site in leading markers. I'm leaning toward Waite atm but I might not even make a change to either.
Another choice I'm thinking hard on is Waite or Lockyer? Waite seems like a gun but Lockyer gets so many cheap marks, that he's displayed on the front page of the AFL site in leading markers. I'm leaning toward Waite atm but I might not even make a change to either.
I'd go Buddy and Waite
Buddy for absolute sure
and Waite just (i have a great dislike for lockyer so my bias side might be showing)
Personally though, Lockyer is a little inconsistent for my liking
kangaroos3
Team Captain
- Jul 15, 2008
- 366
- 227
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Stuck on who to upgrade out of;
Krak > Gia
or
Malceski > Embley
Both players who I'm trading out have BE's which IMO I dont think they will reach.
Thoughts?
Krak > Gia
or
Malceski > Embley
Both players who I'm trading out have BE's which IMO I dont think they will reach.
Thoughts?
Looks like your team doesnt have so much to worry about if their your intended trades this week
I personally dont think krak to gia is worth a trade purely because i think krak can still average ~80 and gia hasnt looked the goos this season
I would do the 2nd trade for sure
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Looking at downgrading either Skippy or Lucas to Sidebottom to free up some cash for upgrades and gain a playing player. Who should i downgrade and is Sidebottom likely to hold his spot for most of the season baring injury? Cheers guys
- Banned
- #67
Ok thanks for the help. Now I just have to think on Firrito vs Ryder but I'll probably just go with Ryder due to all the game time he'll get.
Waite's coming in next week, probably for Hodge if he breaks down, I'm on my last nerve with him anyway.
Waite's coming in next week, probably for Hodge if he breaks down, I'm on my last nerve with him anyway.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 37,123
- 34,299
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Atletico
Ive got one that is kinda different:
Who would be a better keeper as a 7th back: Houlihan or Hill?
Who would be a better keeper as a 7th back: Houlihan or Hill?
kangaroos3
Team Captain
- Jul 15, 2008
- 366
- 227
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Who would be a better forward line upgrade out of
O'Keefe, Johno Brown or Gia?
O'Keefe, Johno Brown or Gia?
Hoolidooli
I believe Brown for sure, only one proving himself this season thus far
kangaroos3
Team Captain
- Jul 15, 2008
- 366
- 227
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I believe Brown for sure, only one proving himself this season thus far
Thanks, I was leaning towards Browny.
I'm probably going to be forced to do the same this week, if Higgins, Goodwin and Brown don't all get up. I'm thinking Lucas at this point. Have waited so long for Skipworth already. Lucas could also get a recall in the next week or 2, so it's a pretty difficult decision. Skipworth is a chance to play for Bendigo this week. Skipworth might have a hard time getting into the team, but he's very determined, and a bad loss or 2 for the Bombers might change that landscape a bit. I'm really hoping I can get another week to decide!
I'd probably go Birchall (mr. consistent) but Scotland wouldnt be too bad in an up and coming team like carlton
Both pretty good, maybe whichever is cheaper
Similar threads
- Sticky
