Remove this Banner Ad

Our best after five rounds?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Jul 1, 2004
Posts
22,728
Reaction score
6,439
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Still early in the season but would like to see who we think has been our best performed player thus far this season. Seems no one could be arsed doing a Carlton Board Player of the Year this season (think I'll get it started now - better late than never).

Only players who have played all five games included.
 
For me, its a tie between Betts and Murphy, both have really stood up this season. I'm gonna vote for Murphy, by a hair.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Waite for mine, but Murph probably for everyone else. Wiggo deserves to be in the poll too - I'll lay money that he polls top 3 in the B&F if he keeps his form up.
 
Juddy's been pretty clear BOG a couple of times, so he gets my nod (which i know will make him happy when he reads this).

Waite would be second for mine at the minute, just in front of the Murphinator.
 
Hard to split Betts and Murph, but I thought Murph really only got going in the Tiges game after half time.......Betts has been very consistent throughout IMO.

Betts by a hair for consistency, and the fact that he co-leads the Coleman. Not bad for a bloke spending half his time in the midfield. :thumbsu:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I've been doing a 10-1 tally every week... here is my leaderboard after round 5

1. Chris Judd (33)
2. Marc Murphy (31)
3. Bryce Gibbs (30)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (25)
5. Eddie Betts (21)
6. Jarrad Waite (18)
7. Richard Hadley (17)
8. Simon Wiggins (15)
9. Kade Simpson (13)
10. Brett Thornton (12)
11. Brendon Fevola (10)
12. Paul Bower (8), Heath Scotland (8)
14. Sam Jacobs (7), Nick Stevens (7)
16. Mitch Robinson (6), Michael Jamison (6)
18. Ryan Houlihan (4)
19. Denis Armfield (2)
20. Andrew Carrazzo (1)
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Difference between most important and best player, though.

fair call
its really difficult to split for mine, i dont think theres much between 4-5 players but i went with judd because he deals with a hard tag every week, still puts up big numbers and leads from the front

could raffle it between judd, murph, gibbs, betts and chief tho (who i just realised is also not listed!)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom