Phantom Draft - Trial Run #1

[sinepari]

Certainly more guaranteed than Sellar who you rate highly though LH.

 

[LukeHodge15]

Certainly more guaranteed than Sellar who you rate highly though LH.

Since when did i say i rate Seller , I just said he wouldnt slide

 

[JavaBlue]

LMAO of Snoop, I probably wouldnt pass him up but im just saying Gumby has flaws. He isn't the Guarentee Superstar everyone is making him out to be.

I've been stirring the pot around the Carlton traps by pushing Gumby - mainly because I'm sick of reading about Gibbs. But having watched the WA Metro game the other day, I have to say I wasn't overly impressed with Gumby. While Leuey at least showed glimpses of what he could do, there wasn't much about Gumby that jumped out and said class. Jumpin Jack's boy and Dawes were much more impressive.

Still that's only one game and I don't think WA put a lot of thought into how they entered the forward line. Maybe they're used to just bombing it up to Gumby and he just wasn't there that day. He does have a fairly impressive CV.

 

[LukeHodge15]

I've been stirring the pot around the Carlton traps by pushing Gumby - mainly because I'm sick of reading about Gibbs. But having watched the WA Metro game the other day, I have to say I wasn't overly impressed with Gumby. While Leuey at least showed glimpses of what he could do, there wasn't much about Gumby that jumped out and said class. Jumpin Jack's boy and Dawes were much more impressive.

Still that's only one game and I don't think WA put a lot of thought into how they entered the forward line. Maybe they're used to just bombing it up to Gumby and he just wasn't there that day. He does have a fairly impressive CV.

Dont get me wrong, im not saying he is a cat, just has some weaknesses thats all

 

[JavaBlue]

Dont get me wrong, im not saying he is a cat, just has some weaknesses thats all

I don't think I mention he was a cat. Doesn't lack in courage, he did show that. Like I said ,maybe I caught him on a bad day and my expectations were too high.

 

[krisholio14]

I've been stirring the pot around the Carlton traps by pushing Gumby - mainly because I'm sick of reading about Gibbs. But having watched the WA Metro game the other day, I have to say I wasn't overly impressed with Gumby. While Leuey at least showed glimpses of what he could do, there wasn't much about Gumby that jumped out and said class. Jumpin Jack's boy and Dawes were much more impressive.

Still that's only one game and I don't think WA put a lot of thought into how they entered the forward line. Maybe they're used to just bombing it up to Gumby and he just wasn't there that day. He does have a fairly impressive CV.

ive seen under 11's coaches with better game plans than the WA under 18's coach did.

 

[HBF]

ive seen under 11's coaches with better game plans than the WA under 18's coach did.

Haha

 

[mad-saint-guy]

Lingsface, please don't make the same stupid mistake so many people are making by picking Riewoldt/Renouf. Saints need midfielders. Unless Brown slips to pick 27 (or one of Hansen/Thorp slips to 9) I can't see them picking anything other than midfielders with our first three picks.

 

[LukeHodge15]

ive seen under 11's coaches with better game plans than the WA under 18's coach did.

Classic

 

[HBF]

With the Nov 1 start LH15, is there any certain time you want to tick this bad boy off. I can start whenever you like.

 

[Snoop Dog]

Why dont we kick off in the evening LH?????

Around 7pm would suit me. Can get the pizza, grab a can and sit back draft....top night!

 

[sinepari]

WCE haven't made final delistings yet...not that it really matters for the early selections I guess.

 

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

WCE haven't made final delistings yet...not that it really matters for the early selections I guess.

It'll be 4 picks though, they've already said that, as I'm sure you know.

Make us proud Sinepari.

 

[macca69]

With the Nov 1 start LH15, is there any certain time you want to tick this bad boy off. I can start whenever you like.

I don't mind if u start 3 hours early, I don't think there's any problems with getting this underway if your interested...

 

[Lingsface]

so wat time is it scheduled to start?

 

[macca69]

so wat time is it scheduled to start?

I think we just ended up setting a date (Nov 1st), but no set time.

 

[HBF]

so wat time is it scheduled to start?

I'll kick it off first thing Wednesday morning - say 9:00am Melbourne time.

 

[sinepari]

Wednesday is a great day, as it's my only day off until Sunday.

Looking foward to this exercise. Let's hope all coaches go with a combination of who they rate and who they think we'll be taken with each pick to ensure we get a rough idea of what MIGHT happen come draft day.

 

[macca69]

I'll kick it off first thing Wednesday morning - say 9:00am Melbourne time.

need more time to think about your pick

 

[Snoop Dog]

I wont be back until around 2pm on Wednesday so will need to wait until around then for my pick.

 

[HBF]

need more time to think about your pick

Ummmmm, NO
Now how do you spell Leu..............?

 

[Snoop Dog]

Ummmmm, NO
Now how do you spell Leu..............?

Go on!

I am most interested in whether peoples views have altered

 

[HBF]

Go on!

I am most interested in whether peoples views have altered

You'll just to wait Snoop.
This could be very interesting.

One thing though, do we/should we post profiles?

 

[Salaryman]

i don't think i am going to write profiles, at least not to begin with. You can find profiles elsewhere. I will give a brief description of my reasoning, then i will come back later and add a profile.

 

[sinepari]

I say no profiles, but reasons for the selection are a must.