phantom draft trial run - the summary

[macca69]

bargain picks from this mock draft -
leaunburger - 7
selwood - 10
westhoff - 34
edwards- 89
gray - 112

This was last years trial run, was much more laid back and there were a few auto picks and that sorta thing.

This is last years proper phantom draft and was much more professionally done.

 

[ImaBeliever!]

bargain picks from this mock draft -
leaunburger - 7
selwood - 10
westhoff - 34
edwards- 89
gray - 112

What about Boak at pick 39?

 

[sinepari]

Reid at whenever I got him.

Who cares, this is old news..

 

[ImaBeliever!]

Reid at whenever I got him.

Who cares, this is old news..

Well don't bother posting then.

 

[sinepari]

What good does it do? How many times can we possibly analyse the choices we made last year. It's been done so many times.

 

[ImaBeliever!]

What good does it do? How many times can we possibly analyse the choices we made last year. It's been done so many times.

And what harm does it do? It can be interesting to go over some of the old mock selections, and can help to 'fine-tune' our perception of the qualities that lead us to think a player will or won't be AFL quality.

Surely people can revisit things without being put down by others. If you don't like it, then ignore it.

 

[sinepari]

I'm just saying it's been done about 15 times. Search it.

 

[ImaBeliever!]

I'm just saying it's been done about 15 times. Search it.

So? I'm saying that there is no harm to it, and that if people want to provide comment on it, then they should be able to, without being put down for doing so. Fair enough if it is the same people saying the same things over and over, but this isn't the case here. If you have analysed the mock drafts several times, then that's your call, but i haven't, and should be free to do so.