Prediction Pick 6

[grayza2018]

Or do we hope an interstate team strikes for Richards then a bit of good home factor kicks in in 24 months?!

 

[Apex36]

Or do we hope an interstate team strikes for Richards then a bit of good home factor kicks in in 24 months?!

Fingers crossed for Brisbane or GC

 

[TradeDraft]

Or do we hope an interstate team strikes for Richards then a bit of good home factor kicks in in 24 months?!

That be more Chance then us Picking him at 6 or he falls to our Next Pick in 3rd Round

 

[DWil6]

If he’s a first round talent I think we can safely write him off.

 

[ChubbyGallon]

We could of tried to turn 6 and 30-whatever it is into Richmonds Picks - They will have to use it for Naish anyway..

We could of had the chance to go bang bang with Balta and Richards and kept everyone happy

 

[Chrispiesssss]

We could of tried to turn 6 and 30-whatever it is into Richmonds Picks - They will have to use it for Naish anyway..

We could of had the chance to go bang bang with Balta and Richards and kept everyone happy

But no Fog Machine then.

 

[Soups]

But no Fog Machine then.

I not sure we’d take him even if he was available.

 

[Tazzaye]

Draft set up is lame, so we have players already back for Preseason and we still haven't even drafted any players, just doesn't make sense how it's scheduled

 

[Apex36]

I not sure we’d take him even if he was available.

I really hope we do. He makes so much sense from both a needs and best available perspective imo.

 

[Darkyprotector]

I've changed my mind 100 times, but I'd be really happy with Fogarty. At 192 - 193cm (and how knows maybe still growing), he is that perfect height now for a modern forward. He also has relentless attack on the footy and scope to also play midfield. He also has good footskills and strength.

He obviously struggled through this year with injury, and I understand the concerns that he had a quiet year. Clearly the injuries would have had a significant impact.

I'd really like Coffield too. Would love to be in St.Kilda's position with picks 7 and 8.

I reckon though we've invested in Murray as the speedy half back, so our biggest need is a forward. Fogarty might not be exactly the KPP we desire, but we already have Moore at 200cm, and I don't see many teams going in with 2 200cm guys these days.

I like the Adelaide setup with Jenkins at 200cm, then Walker at 193ish. West Coast also structure nicely with Kennedy (195cm) and Darling (192cm).

I'd then go tall at our next 2 picks as well with key defenders.

Jenkins what a dud
200cm and specialist in joe he goose
When was he ever seen taking a strong pack mark or splitting a pack
McGovern twice the player IMO

 

[adammania9]

Jenkins what a dud
200cm and specialist in joe he goose
When was he ever seen taking a strong pack mark or splitting a pack
McGovern twice the player IMO

If Joe the gooses are so easy, why doesn’t every forward kick 40-60 goals a year? He’s no superstar but he’s certainly no dud.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[adammania9]

Naughton is my guy now, the kid is a machine and there isn’t a go home risk. He lived in Vic until he was 9 and has close connections here.

Give the young mids a year to kick themselves into gear without dumping another 18/19 year old gun into the mix. We might find out Daicos or Sier is a gun and that we didn’t really need Coffield/Cerra meanwhile our KPP stocks are still aching.

It sounds underwhelming taking a KPP after the build-up but make no mistake he will play senior footy in 2018 at any club and he’ll be terrific.

6: Aaron Naughton
38: Toby Wooller
56: Ben Paton
This is a draft I’d love to see. I’m interested in Spargo as a defensive small forward at 38/56 as well and also Sam Taylor at 38 would be a great key defender (would take both Naughton and Taylor if I had the chance - KPD’s sorted for many years)

Jake Patmore has displayed a lot as a small defender, might be an option at 56 or rookie draft, Flynn Appleby is a good shut down defender and should go in the rookie draft. I’d love to add one of these two. Sam Collins is also a very good mature key defensive option to provide immediate depth.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[adammania9]

I wouldn’t yet write off Noah Balta sliding his way to 38 either but he’s not all there behaviourally so I’m not sure Buckley will be huge on him. At the moment I can’t see a club in the first round taking him.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[grayza2018]

Naughton is my guy now, the kid is a machine and there isn’t a go home risk. He lived in Vic until he was 9 and has close connections here.

Give the young mids a year to kick themselves into gear without dumping another 18/19 year old gun into the mix. We might find out Daicos or Sier is a gun and that we didn’t really need Coffield/Cerra meanwhile our KPP stocks are still aching.

It sounds underwhelming taking a KPP after the build-up but make no mistake he will play senior footy in 2018 at any club and he’ll be terrific.

6: Aaron Naughton
38: Toby Wooller
56: Ben Paton
This is a draft I’d love to see. I’m interested in Spargo as a defensive small forward at 38/56 as well and also Sam Taylor at 38 would be a great key defender (would take both Naughton and Taylor if I had the chance - KPD’s sorted for many years)

Jake Patmore has displayed a lot as a small defender, might be an option at 56 or rookie draft, Flynn Appleby is a good shut down defender and should go in the rookie draft. I’d love to add one of these two. Sam Collins is also a very good mature key defensive option to provide immediate depth.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I don't mind the argument there regarding locking our KPDs down for many years, just curious where you see McLarty? I really liked some of his stuff in the VFL this year, I think he'll be a very handy player in time

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Draft set up is lame, so we have players already back for Preseason and we still haven't even drafted any players, just doesn't make sense how it's scheduled

Allows 18 year olds to concentrate on year 12 exams without distraction

 

[adammania9]

I don't mind the argument there regarding locking our KPDs down for many years, just curious where you see McLarty? I really liked some of his stuff in the VFL this year, I think he'll be a very handy player in time

No problem with depth. I don’t expect the club to recruit two young KPD’s in the national draft, I just rate them high enough that I would take them both if given the opportunity. McLarty is looking good and I think he’ll play some footy next year.

Best 22: Lynden Dunn, Darcy Moore
Depth: Sam Collins
Alternatives: Ben Reid (forward), Tyson Goldsack (utility)
Future: Aaron Naughton, Sam McLarty
This is a badass key defensive lineup that I’d love to run into 2018 with.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[grayza2018]

Are links to Collins real? Or just a preference? I haven't seen much by way of news

 

[adammania9]

Are links to Collins real? Or just a preference? I haven't seen much by way of news

Nothing at the moment, I just really want him in the rookie draft.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[grayza2018]

I'd like to see that too, looked more than handy option at Freo until Hamling came along

 

[Soups]

I really hope we do. He makes so much sense from both a needs and best available perspective imo.

I would be more than happy to draft Fog, he was my guy early in the year. I just think A) he’s going to before our pick. I think Carlton, North and Freo all can select him. And B) He just doesn’t have the runs on the board this year and I think that comes under big consideration with Hine, so I can see him passing on him.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

No problem with depth. I don’t expect the club to recruit two young KPD’s in the national draft, I just rate them high enough that I would take them both if given the opportunity. McLarty is looking good and I think he’ll play some footy next year.

Best 22: Lynden Dunn, Darcy Moore
Depth: Sam Collins
Alternatives: Ben Reid (forward), Tyson Goldsack (utility)
Future: Aaron Naughton, Sam McLarty
This is a badass key defensive lineup that I’d love to run into 2018 with.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Three quarters of our premiership kpps came from the same draft. The other was s father son!

 

[Stifler's mom]

My guess is Cerra will be available with pick 6.

Not sure why the knock on Brander. Seems like a logical pick imo.

 

[adammania9]

My guess is Cerra will be available with pick 6.

Not sure why the knock on Brander. Seems like a logical pick imo.

Cerra will very likely be gone. The dockers are very big on him so there’s a bit of lip he might end up going pick two. Otherwise, Carlton, North or Freo again will collect him. I won’t shut the door yet but it’s highly unlikely he’s still on the board at our pick.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[cityslick1]

My guess is Cerra will be available with pick 6.

Not sure why the knock on Brander. Seems like a logical pick imo.

b/c from his highlights he looks more Corey Gault than Nick Riewoldt...

imo

 

[Matt_352]

1-LDU
2-Cerra
3-Rayner
4-Stephenson
5-Hayes

Could Dow make it to 6 and do we take him