Prediction Pick 6

[Matt_352]

 

[NT.Thunder]

Who is your club GWS Giants picking?

Probably Fogarty or Bonar after Collingwood pass on both

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Probably Fogarty or Bonar after Collingwood pass on both

 

[Mukesh]

Found the going tough right from the start.
People put him on a pedestal.

yeah... a late starter...bit of a miracle worker in front of the big sticks, nailed quite a few in his time..

 

[Mongo Ming]

TBH I’d be over the moon with any of:
Fogarty
Cerra
Stephenson
Brayshaw

All those blokes were in top 3-4 calculations at some point, so a bargain is on the cards as at least 2 surely slide to our pick.

Glad we held onto 6 now, just got to use it bloody sensibly!

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

All Hine said was he thinks the first half dozen from our point of view will be "midfield/utility types".

Nothing about us drafting a utility, some may need a hearing check.

Isn’t Collingwood in the first half dozen?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Correct.

Said they'll be crossing off players down their list.
Also said they may not even use the four picks, depending on who might be left.

That would be logical. Take brown with the third pick, adding rookie promotion flexibility during the season. Also lower salary cap meaning you can use the savings to front load Mayne as much as possible.

And hope whoever you had in mind is still available for the rookie draft.

 

[Soups]

why wouldnt stephenson be mentioned....hes a far more complete footballer than any of these names mentioned....jmi

Like I said I’ve just heard we haven’t been keen. Now that could be us play our cards close to our chest, but he really has never been linked to us other than Twomey last minute. And I don’t really believe him.

He’s got just as many knocks as the kids listed above.

 

[Apex36]

as if you blokes need another midfielder! let us have Cerra!

Mate, it’s doubtful Cerra will even be available at 6 now.

 

[Matt_352]

Utility sounds to me like Fogarty Stephenson Bonar Coffee. Could maybe say Cerra or Brayshaw as well

 

[Matt_352]

Mate, it’s doubtful Cerra will even be available at 6 now.

According to mr know it all twomey cerra will be gone at pick 2

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Found It:

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2017-11-23/recruiter-outlines-draft-expectations

I think going off that I putting a Line Thru Naughton

Interesting interview.

“We have 4 picks but probably won’t use all of them”
“Early Pick will be a midfield/utility type, then we will pick on a needs basis”
“We have committed to Tyler Brown, provided he doesn’t get bid on before where we rate him”

Based on that, I think this is Collingwood’s plan:

Pick 6: Darcy Fogarty/Best Available Midfielder
Pick 38: Key Position Player
Pick 56: Tyler Brown
Pick 61: Pass (List spot kept open to promote Josh Thomas)

 

[left at home]

Interesting interview.

“We have 4 picks but probably won’t use all of them”
“Early Pick will be a midfield/utility type, then we will pick on a needs basis”
“We have committed to Tyler Brown, provided he doesn’t get bid on before where we rate him”

Based on that, I think this is Collingwood’s plan:

Pick 6: Darcy Fogarty/Best Available Midfielder
Pick 38: Key Position Player
Pick 56: Tyler Brown
Pick 61: Pass (List spot kept open to promote Josh Thomas)

Don’t need to promote Thomas, could be used in the rookie draft, or if someone falls that we like.

 

[Scodog10]

Interesting interview.

“We have 4 picks but probably won’t use all of them”
“Early Pick will be a midfield/utility type, then we will pick on a needs basis”
“We have committed to Tyler Brown, provided he doesn’t get bid on before where we rate him”

Based on that, I think this is Collingwood’s plan:

Pick 6: Darcy Fogarty/Best Available Midfielder
Pick 38: Key Position Player
Pick 56: Tyler Brown
Pick 61: Pass (List spot kept open to promote Josh Thomas)

Why exactly would we be doing that? Rookies are eligible to play in 2018 without being promoted. If we take three selections the more likely outcome would be a pick in the PSD, a DFA, an extra rookie or a reduced senior list.

 

[Apex36]

According to mr know it all twomey cerra will be gone at pick 2

I don’t really rate Twomey’s opinion at all or his rankings, but I’ll concede he probably gets the best mail this close to the draft. If he reckons that Cerra could be gone at 2 I reckon there’s a pretty good chance of it happening.

 

[Big Bryza]

Ok...I’ve finally settled on my pick...
It’s Fogarty...ah no it’s Cerra or Brayshaw, perhaps Stevenson or Naughton...what about Cofffield or Richards?
Yes, I’ve decided not to decide.
I’m going to let Hine decide instead.

Hang on, so what's your decision?

 

[Big Bryza]

Don't know who we'll get but we're due to nail a top 10 draft pick.

 

[Apex36]

Don’t need to promote Thomas, could be used in the rookie draft, or if someone falls that the like.

Why exactly would we be doing that? Rookies are eligible to play in 2018 without being promoted. If we take three selections the more likely outcome would be a pick in the PSD, a DFA, an extra rookie or a reduced senior list.

Regardless of all that, it’s already been confirmed that Thomas will be retained as a rookie, and rookie promotions aren’t even done on draft night anymore.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Interesting interview.

“We have 4 picks but probably won’t use all of them”
“Early Pick will be a midfield/utility type, then we will pick on a needs basis”
“We have committed to Tyler Brown, provided he doesn’t get bid on before where we rate him”

Based on that, I think this is Collingwood’s plan:

Pick 6: Darcy Fogarty/Best Available Midfielder
Pick 38: Key Position Player
Pick 56: Tyler Brown
Pick 61: Pass (List spot kept open to promote Josh Thomas)

My take is:

Pick 6: Darcy Fogarty/Best Available Midfielder
Pick 38: Key Position Player
Pick 56: Tyler Brown
Pick 61: Pass unless someone we really rate drops. Otherwise we go to the rookie draft, this may include picking up Ramsay. No need to promote JT with changes to the rookie list this year.

EDIT: Bolded has been pointed out.

 

[TradeDraft]

Daniel Cherny of the Fairfax press going with Fogarty at 6, from a Top 5 of Rayner, LDU, Dow, Cerra, Brayshaw...

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/tradin...selections-might-pan-out-20171123-gzros8.html

Everyone has us taking Fogerty now

 

[MagpieBat]

Sam Landsberger of News Corp...

6. COLLINGWOOD: DARCY FOGARTY (Glenelg)

192cm key forward

Big, powerful man with a beautiful kick should land at either the Kangas or Magpies. Mega talent was touted as No.1 at the start of the year before injuries hit. Collingwood needs goalkicking targets.

THE TWIST: If the Kangas plump for Fogarty, one of the premium midfielders will slip to Collingwood. That would almost certainly be the mature Brayshaw, who coach Nathan Buckley and captain Scott Pendlebury would equally love.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...k/news-story/6d354abf1290b7802b09a939e213b2f1

His Top 5 is Rayner, Cerra, Dow, LDU, Brayshaw.

 

[SideysBottom]

Just read Charlie Constable is touted as a 191cm cross between Sam Mitchell and Patrick Cripps... Jiminy! Why no hype on that? The kids ahead of him must be good!

His uncle is Mick Malthouse. Could go in the second round.

 

[left at home]

Regardless of all that, it’s already been confirmed that Thomas will be retained as a rookie, and rookie promotions aren’t even done on draft night anymore.

We know, but another poster did not.

 

[MagpieBat]

Everyone has us taking Fogerty now

I hope everyone is on the money...

 

[Saintly Viewed]

The media sheeple all start copying each other.

That way they all shine or drown together.