Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Well it'll still be easier for Spencer to pass Meesen than for Jacobs to pass Hampson IMO.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Player Comparison Thread - Part 2
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
That's basically what it comes down to. Do we know how long Warnock and Jamar will be out for? I'm not really convinced Warnock is even good enough to be a #1 ruck just yet.
Well considering they have both been put on the LTI list then i presume 8+ weeks. I don't like the fact that Blues fans say Warnock is our number 1 ruckman. He is yet to prove much at AFL, i think he'd be in our 22 but to me he isn't our number 1 ruckman just yet either.
Didnt warnock get placed on LTI list other day?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Nov 24, 2007
- 13,156
- 950
- AFL Club
- Carlton
1. Ladson
2. Gram
3. Lockyer
4. Enright
2. Gram
3. Lockyer
4. Enright
i think malceski will score more points in the end of the year from playing more games and from being with mattner as the 2 main sydney backline possesion getters.
i have hentschel and ziebell in my team one will be on the bench and one will start. will decide later
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
Anyone keen to help?
Also does anyone think I'm crazy not going for Grimes or Hill as the 7th back or bench spot?? I've had them in my plans the whole pre-season, but have decided to stick with a player in the $200-250k price range who is best 18 at their club, has showed potential in previous years and still young. He is assured of a game each week. Only downside, then raines is the final backman with Suban/Petrenko warming the bench.
Although Drummond is a massive injury risk if you were going to go for one of them i'd suggest drummond as he will ave mid 80's to low 90's while i don't think malceski will be in that bracket.
I was on the Ziebell bandwagon for quite some time but i think laidley won't play him all that much. i havent heard much of him in his last 2 matches. Yarran will be an easy selection as his squad will be shown a bit earlier than the others. Hentschell could be good i reckon his average would be 50-60. Personally i'd go with yarran, but thats just my gut feeling.
Can u rate these guys from 1-4 and give info why if possible.
Hasleby
Grigg
Tuck
t.Selwood
Can u rate these guys from 1-4 and give info why if possible.
Hasleby
Grigg
Tuck
t.Selwood
i'd say
tuck, haselby, grigg, t.selwood...
but i think grigg pulled his hammy in the game against freo, not sure how bad...
i've been hearing alot about tuck and how he will be very good,
haselby was a very good player but is coming back from injury
and t.selwood just dont rate him IMO
Hasleby
Grigg
Tuck
t.Selwood
i'd say
tuck, haselby, grigg, t.selwood...
but i think grigg pulled his hammy in the game against freo, not sure how bad...
i've been hearing alot about tuck and how he will be very good,
haselby was a very good player but is coming back from injury
and t.selwood just dont rate him IMO
Come on GS....play nice, or dont play at all!
I'd go Pav/Dids/Bock/Ziebell. Pav, Dids and Bock are better than Richo, SJ and Enright IMO, and I think Ziebell will score aswell as Hentschel anyway.
If you think you've found a good player from $200-$250k who is certain to play, then I'd take him over Grimes/Hill.
My problem...
Fisher (90ppg) and Adcock (75-80ppg)
vs
Bock (85ppg) and McMahon (85ppg)
I think option 2 gives me 2 definite keepers and option 1 gives me 1, with another potential keeper. My predicted averages are in brackets and going by that, they are pretty even IMO so I'd like to know what others think. Cheers.
If they are the averages you think, go option two and bring in Fisher later in the year, that way its less trades, at 75 there is no way you could keep Adcock all year. Its always better to have 2 keepers than one for the same average.
I had the same issue with my mids,
Ablett Selwood Gibbs Knights + 20K
VS
Swan Kornes Selwood Gibbs
Ive chosen the second because it requires one less trade through the year.
I had the same issue with my mids,
Ablett Selwood Gibbs Knights + 20K
VS
Swan Kornes Selwood Gibbs
Ive chosen the second because it requires one less trade through the year.
Thanks for the help.
Went for a massive team change by doing these trades:
Hille to McIntosh
Thomas to Jack Riewoldt
Suban to Broughton (Bench Trade)
Meant i had the cash to do these:
Knights, S Johnson, Cloke to Joel Selwood, Franklin, Pavlich
I know exactly who youre talking about
Could be an excellent option but imo I cant really see him doing enough to be a keeper, especially when Houlihan at a slightly higher price has the potential to do so. If you are excited by his (your 200-250k pick) last NAB challenge score in the Freako email, dont be. He essentially played against Coburg.
But are you crazy for not having Grimes/Hill as your 7th back? Absolutely not. Dont get me wrong, I jumped right on Grimes after his massive NAB performance. But he didnt play last week and was left out this week because of "soreness". In my eyes this doesnt bode too well for his chances of playing consecutive games week in week out this season.
- Nov 23, 2008
- 12,452
- 293
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Lockyer v. P. Burgoyne
- Jul 12, 2003
- 6,998
- 14,596
- AFL Club
- Carlton
People's thoughts on Firrito? Moving into an onball role after initially playing there while at Box Hill. Lack of KP defenders has meant he's had to move down back, but now Laidley has indicated he will make a permanent move to the midfield. Ticks a lot of boxes...gets good tackle and mark numbers and has the size to win a lot of possession. Reports suggest he was impressive in the practice match up at Bendigo.
A couple of questions I'm having with my team at the moment.
Goodes vs Kerr vs Foley
Richo vs Delidio vs Franklin
K Cornes vs S.Thompson
Adcock vs Drummond
Fraser vs McIntosh
McPhee vs Fisher
Goodes vs Kerr vs Foley
Richo vs Delidio vs Franklin
K Cornes vs S.Thompson
Adcock vs Drummond
Fraser vs McIntosh
McPhee vs Fisher
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Yeh that is pretty much along the lines I was thinking. I think I will stick with Franklin, although he hurts you with free kicks against, I can see him playing further upfield this yr (eg against west coast on weekend, 4 goals and 26 possies) vs Delidio who I think may play more up foward this year.
I've gone Drummond as my risk player vs an Adcock or Malceski.
McIntosh I guess I hope Petrie plays back and Hale up foward thus McIntosh to get the hitouts and play ruck.
Another couple of questions I then have is.
Delidio vs Chapman vs Brown ( I have room for two in my team)
Gram vs Gilbee vs Milburn (I can have one)
Judd vs Kerr vs Goodes vs Foley (I can have two)
Fisher vs Goddard (I can have one)
FredNerk69
Senior List
What are people thoughts on Sam Butler. He averaged 80 before having injuries the past 2 years. He has been playing well pre-season and is only 218K
In a nutshesll he is 50K cheaper than Reilly, Has and Tuck
In a nutshesll he is 50K cheaper than Reilly, Has and Tuck
Pav + Rich + 40k (in bank) vs Stokes + McKay
Obviously the reason I'm throwing up those names is that I'm cash tied. At the moment I've got Judd/Foley although I could with a trade (Gilbee for Adcock) I could upgrade that to Judd/Burgoyne.
- Status
Similar threads
