Draft Expert PMBangers' (and ‘friends’) 2022 Draft Board

[PocketRocket08]

I think it mostly validates what we've seen on field, but was a bit surprising he did that well

Does mcmullin get drafted or rookie. Has finished the season pretty well.

 

[bigwillday]

PM, how would you compare a Rueben Ginbey to Josh Goater from last year? Both former defenders with great athleticism who butcher the ball.

 

[PMBangers]

PM, how would you compare a Rueben Ginbey to Josh Goater from last year? Both former defenders with great athleticism who butcher the ball.

I think there's some similarities in that path from defence to midfield and their athletic traits, I feel like Ginbey is going to be more sort after though given that potential to be a contested ball beast with his play style where I think Goater is going to end up a more balanced midfielder, Ginbey has more of crash and bash approach where Goaters movement is a bit 'silkier'

 

[PMBangers]

Does mcmullin get drafted or rookie. Has finished the season pretty well.

I think he's got enough about him for a National selection personally

 

[LemmingMaster]

PM, how would you compare a Rueben Ginbey to Josh Goater from last year? Both former defenders with great athleticism who butcher the ball.

Ginbey butchers the ball, he's not completely terrible with ball in hand.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

PM, how would you compare a Rueben Ginbey to Josh Goater from last year? Both former defenders with great athleticism who butcher the ball.

Rueben Ginbey doesnt butcher the ball he actually a very good kick, jack Crisp comparison is apt.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Ginbey butchers the ball, he's not completely terrible with ball in hand.

I have watched his every game this season, and hardly ever turned it over especially late in the season
When he has space his kicking is elite, the fact at end of season he was using his pace to burst away from the pack then hit a teamate lace out
was a testament to how much he has improved.
This is a kid that will spend hours of time working on his weaknesses

 

[bzparkes]

Rueben Ginbey doesnt butcher the ball he actually a very good kick, jack Crisp comparison is apt.

Jamie*

 

[PMBangers]

None of this matters anyway, the main thing people will love about Ginbey is he prefers BBQ sauce to Tomato sauce on his egg and bacon rolls, that's the true testament to a prospects character

 

[Bastyy]

None of this matters anyway, the main thing people will love about Ginbey is he prefers BBQ sauce to Tomato sauce on his egg and bacon rolls, that's the true testament to a prospects character

All this has done is put Ginbey in the "undraftable" category for me

 

[PMBangers]

All this has done is put Ginbey in the "undraftable" category for me

I always knew there was a valid reason I hated you

 

[weltschmerz]

None of this matters anyway, the main thing people will love about Ginbey is he prefers BBQ sauce to Tomato sauce on his egg and bacon rolls, that's the true testament to a prospects character

knew there was a reason I wanted him at the Dogs

 

[Wild Bill]

PM, how would you compare a Rueben Ginbey to Josh Goater from last year? Both former defenders with great athleticism who butcher the ball.

Got the right player?

 

[Wild Bill]

PMBangers - with the mega trade looking likely would you then lock in your top 4?

1) Ashcroft
2) Cadmen GWS
3) Wardlaw Roos
4) Sheezel Roos

 

[PMBangers]

PMBangers - with the mega trade looking likely would you then lock in your top 4?

1) Ashcroft
2) Cadmen GWS
3) Wardlaw Roos
4) Sheezel Roos

I think North favour Tsatas to Wardlaw, but the usual 5 names are what I'm expecting for GWS/ North/ Dons to go for, with Bailey Humphrey the main one that might push in to that

 

[Wild Bill]

I think North favour Tsatas to Wardlaw, but the usual 5 names are what I'm expecting for GWS/ North/ Dons to go for, with Bailey Humphrey the main one that might push in to that

Why do you think that? We may have been turned off Wardlaw when he came out as an ess supporter.

 

[weltschmerz]

Why do you think that? We may have been turned off Wardlaw when he came out as an ess supporter.

Wardlaw's hammies seem to be made of tissue paper

 

[Wild Bill]

Wardlaw's hammies seem to be made of tissue paper

pinged it twice. We thought the same of Trelour - he played every game this year.

I have no doubt clubs will be well equiped to set Wardlaw up for success. Would be a lot more advanced than an under 18 club.

 

[PMBangers]

Why do you think that? We may have been turned off Wardlaw when he came out as an ess supporter.

Just an assumption I've come to, you don't lose with either so it's ultimately a decision of what you want for your side more, outside run or contested ball winning

There's already a decent contested crew with Simpkin, Cunnington, LDU all already at a good level, it'll be how the list management/ coached view the prospects of Powell and Phillips that'll determine who you ultimately go for imo

 

[logan wilson]

where do you guys think is the likely destination for jhye clark?

 

[Wild Bill]

Just an assumption I've come to, you don't lose with either so it's ultimately a decision of what you want for your side more, outside run or contested ball winning

There's already a decent contested crew with Simpkin, Cunnington, LDU all already at a good level, it'll be how the list management/ coached view the prospects of Powell and Phillips that'll determine who you ultimately go for imo

Fair enough. Will be a lot of debate over the next 6 weeks. Can’t see us passing on Sheezel so the 2nd pick will be interesting.

GWS have given up a fair bit to get Cadmen.

 

[Wild Bill]

where do you guys think is the likely destination for jhye clark?

Everything points to the Cats.

 

[eth-dog]

I think North favour Tsatas to Wardlaw, but the usual 5 names are what I'm expecting for GWS/ North/ Dons to go for, with Bailey Humphrey the main one that might push in to that

I'm hoping that this is the case.

Does the addition of Bedford make it less likely that GWS bid on Davey at pick 15 at all?

 

[PMBangers]

Fair enough. Will be a lot of debate over the next 6 weeks. Can’t see us passing on Sheezel so the 2nd pick will be interesting.

GWS have given up a fair bit to get Cadmen.

3 and 12 is pretty insignificant given our draft hand, and I expect we were happy to stump up the extra future second to facilitate the 4-way trade because it still ends up cheaper than what it have to do to get Pick 1 in a separate trade. Given the 'eveness' in the 10-20 range I'm not fussed at all

I'm hoping that this is the case.

Does the addition of Bedford make it less likely that GWS bid on Davey at pick 15 at all?

, they're almost completely different players so I doubt it'd influence too much, we still need additional small forward support but I reckon Konstanty and Clarke fit the mould of what we'd want more anyway

 

[PMBangers]

where do you guys think is the likely destination for jhye clark?

If the top 10 stays the same from here I'd be shocked if it wasn't one of the Suns, Hawks or Cats