Possibe trades for Tyson Stenglien?

[Blue Red and Gold]

As an Adelaide supporter and with Tyson Stenglien more than likely wanting to head West at the end of the year I was wondering what trade you would be willing to accept for him?

I was thinking along the lines of Stenglien + a 2nd rounder or player such as Burton/Perrie/Biglands for Polak

Interested to see what everyone else thinks...

 

[Docker_Brat]

Heh.

 

[Brickie]

Originally posted by tatts00
As an Adelaide supporter and with Tyson Stenglien more than likely wanting to head West at the end of the year I was wondering what trade you would be willing to accept for him?

I was thinking along the lines of Stenglien + a 2nd rounder or player such as Burton/Perrie/Biglands for Polak

Interested to see what everyone else thinks...

Bit late mate Polak just re-signed today for 2 years so hes going nowhere.

Troy Longmuir Clive and a 2nd rounder for Steinglein

 

[Portia]

Re: Re: Possibe trades for Tyson Stenglien?

Originally posted by Brickie
Bit late mate Polak just re-signed today for 2 years so hes going nowhere.

Troy Longmuir Clive and a 2nd rounder for Steinglein

Is that a better or worse offer than just a 2nd rounder for Stenglein?

 

[Brickie]

Re: Re: Re: Possibe trades for Tyson Stenglien?

Originally posted by Porthos
Is that a better or worse offer than just a 2nd rounder for Stenglein?

Much better with just TLO and 2nd rounder but Clive will end up at adelaide anyway.2 years he reckons he can get out of himself and adelaide could put him on a basic contract while the kids develop.

 

[error404]

Cliive for Carr, straight swap

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Re: Re: Possibe trades for Tyson Stenglien?

Originally posted by Brickie
Bit late mate Polak just re-signed today for 2 years so hes going nowhere.

Troy Longmuir Clive and a 2nd rounder for Steinglein

what about schammer? is he contracted?

We would take Longmuir i would of thought but you will have to do better than Clive. We have already tried our luck with one washed up forward...it didnt work haha

 

[ImperialPurple]

Re: Re: Re: Possibe trades for Tyson Stenglien?

Originally posted by tatts00
what about schammer? is he contracted?

Signed up about the same time as Pav did (about 6 weeks back I guess), until 2007.

Next try...

Seriously I love Clive, but to mention him in the same sentence as the other washed up forward is a bit of an insult to the afore mentioned other washed up forward I would think...

Can't see Clive getting much of a run anywhere for next year - except maybe the Port Magpies.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Well there goes plan B haha

Be interesting what is going to happen, personally i think a deal will be struck with the Eagles.
Stenglien is a quality player and so is Carr and both clubs will be wanting the max. for him so im not sure if Freo will be able or willing to trade evenly for em, and I cant blame em.

Another question who would you prefer if it came down to only having one?

 

[Moo]

Josh has age and a touch more class IMHO.

Stenglien is no where near a Polak, MC Schammer or the like.

It may be worth taking Biglands just so we can teach him to keep his elbows down.

 

[crowie]

Josh has age and a touch more class IMHO.

Stenglien is no where near a Polak, MC Schammer or the like.

It may be worth taking Biglands just so we can teach him to keep his elbows down.

Mate! you got no right talking about Biglands like that after what f*****g Farmer did to Doughty! That was a disgrace how he got off.

Anyway the moral to the story is...

Don't throw stones from glass houses.

 

[Farrand]

T-Lo, Haines and Droswell for Stinger

 

[BulldogMike]

Could the Dockers use Dion Woods as part of the deal?

 

[voodoo_86]

I wouldn't be surprised to see Woods traded but it was only last year that he played like a star and showed he could have a ton of talent.

He's probably one of the more likely players to be traded however.

 

[dockertor]

Mate! you got no right talking about Biglands like that after what f*****g Farmer did to Doughty! That was a disgrace how he got off.

Anyway the moral to the story is...

Don't throw stones from glass houses.

Are you really so blinded by your bigottry that you can't accept the truth? It was accidental, Get over it fool

 

[Boomhauer]

We're not going to get Stinger by simply offering up 3 stiffs. Is this age, you need to offer quality for quality.