Roast Preliminary Final Umpiring Thread

[niko11]

Yeah what's done is done u win some u lose some!

The image of Branson and Gill together at the game last week is just a coincidence! *cough* bullshit *cough*

But it's time to move on because no matter what we say we won't be playing next Saturday so i'm going to try enjoy G.F week hoping that 2014-15 is another 94-95 with no 5 not far away..

 

[nelroo]

Brownlow interview with Spitta and misses..Noticed numerous scratches around Swallows neck..wonder how he got them? lol

 

[nelroo]

F*** some people on here are precious. Yes the umpiring was disgraceful. Would we have won if it wasn't so badly officiated Who knows?. Let's not forget that no holding the ball decision against cunners in the final against the tigers could have ended our season weeks ago. I just hope like hell a grand final isn't won or lost on a decision or non decision like Jacobs the other night. Good luck wing it I hope you pump the Hawks

Really?

Look, I think we can all accept 1 or 2 howlers per match maximum!!!

But when there are at least 5 or 6 howlers for one team..get stuffed that is INCOMPETENT or CHEATING I don't care what anyone says.

 

[ferball]

Time to let it go and move on.

Dude that conference was in perth!!!!!!

Perth!!!!!

 

[Roosurgence]

I'm sorry you feel that way. North had a great year, but so did we. See you next year

F*** some people on here are precious. Yes the umpiring was disgraceful. Would we have won if it wasn't so badly officiated Who knows?. Let's not forget that no holding the ball decision against cunners in the final against the tigers could have ended our season weeks ago. I just hope like hell a grand final isn't won or lost on a decision or non decision like Jacobs the other night. Good luck wing it I hope you pump the Hawks

Precious? Are you serious?

Not only was our team robbed of the chance to compete on a level playing field, but then we have to put up with flogs coming on to this board to try and tell us that we weren't screwed over.

I don't know about you but if you think that what took place on Saturday night was acceptable in a sport that claims to be professional, then you sound like you don't really mind if a small club like ours is bent over?

Believe me if the same treatment was dished out to a big club, then you bet it would be given due attention. But since it's North it hardly rates a mention.

 

[kool kangas]

The bloke is an ex Ninthmond squib of the highest order and anything that comes from his mouth is drivel.

Where is the:

"Yeah, ive done my own review, and personally im disgusted and honestly quite shocked on what went on over the weekend. Obviously, the "top 6" umpires that were picked werent up to finals pressure, so we will go back to the drawing board, pick another 3 field umpires and spend the week ingraining the kind of umpiring we wish to see the the GF into them. We want the umpires to not be noticed, if thats the case, then they have had a great day out"

Razor Ray won't like that...

 

[Twinkletoes]

The GF umpires are........

UmpireAFL (@UmpireAFL)
29/09/2015 10:36 am
The field umpires for the 2015 Toyota AFL Grand Final will be Brett Rosebury, Matt Stevic, Jeff Dalgleish and Ray Chamberlain (emergency)

 

[archereleven]

Margetts got the arse for cheating obviously and Razor is to be seen but not heard.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Stevic, the guy is a hawk cheerleader.

 

[La Flama Blanca]

Margetts got the arse for cheating obviously and Razor is to be seen but not heard.

They should be fired, not dropped. This is a multi-billion dollar industry and their efforts on the big stage were below what I would expect at an under 12s game.

 

[Horace]

The GF umpires are........

UmpireAFL (@UmpireAFL)
29/09/2015 10:36 am
The field umpires for the 2015 Toyota AFL Grand Final will be Brett Rosebury, Matt Stevic, Jeff Dalgleish and Ray Chamberlain (emergency)

Well thank goodness Margetts got the a***. Mind you it is all too late as he managed to get the Eagles into the GF at least. And as my sister said last night, Freo must be cursing that they never got him on Friday night, as his WA bias might have got a different result there.

Sadly though Ray will surely find a way to insert his a*** into proceedings at some stage.

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

Well, none of Saturday's umps are umpiring this Saturday.

 

[Shermanator]

Well, none of Saturday's umps are umpiring this Saturday.

If only they weren't umpiring last Saturday...

 

[Roosurgence]

Not one of the arse clowns that umpired our game gets an onfield gig, pretty much says it all.

Also like that the AFL came out and said that the GF umps were the best blokes all year, so our game was given the dregs.

Then we have Stevic defending that soft decision on Friday night.

AFL umpiring department is a shambles!

 

[royals1922]

Well, none of Saturday's umps are umpiring this Saturday.

That is genuinely surprising.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Well, none of Saturday's umps are umpiring this Saturday.

Colour me surprised.

 

[royals1922]

I'm sure the wce supporters will take any disputable free kicks given to hawthorn in good stride in the gf and will attribute to Hawthorn all their success if they lose by less than 5 goals.

 

[Twinkletoes]

Well thank goodness Margetts got the a***.

It was mutually agreed that umpiring the Grand Final AND assisting with holding the West Coast banner was too difficult to coordinate on the day.

 

[royals1922]

It would be quite churlish if nm supporters copied wce supporters posts on this thread and changed the pertinent details and then posted those slightly altered copied posts on the wce board if there were some disputable umpires calls in favour of hawthorn in the gf and they lost.


Churlish indeed.

 

[spurs]

After being at the game on Saturday night, I thought we were reemed by the umps. Now looking at the replay just now, it was worse than what I thought it was. It was a disgrace.
Thank goodness the same umps are not in the GF. Go Hawks

 

[DarkPhoenix]

 

[Shermanator]

After being at the game on Saturday night, I thought we were reemed by the umps. Now looking at the replay just now, it was worse than what I thought it was. It was a disgrace.
Thank goodness the same umps are not in the GF. Go Hawks

I just had a WCE fan tell me they flogged us and that the umpiring was fair and square. He reckons the only disputed non-decision was the Jacobs tripping incident but apparently Jacobs shouldn't have fallen over his legs.. I had to tell him that Nat Fyfe almost lost the Brownlow last night for doing the exact same thing...

Seriously WCE fans are as intelligent as a double ended dildo, surely you Vics feel for us WA Roos??...

 

[King Corey]

I just had a WCE fan tell me they flogged us and that the umpiring was fair and square. He reckons the only disputed non-decision was the Jacobs tripping incident but apparently Jacobs shouldn't have fallen over his legs.. I had to tell him that Nat Fyfe almost lost the Brownlow last night for doing the exact same thing...

Seriously WCE fans are as intelligent as a double ended dildo, surely you Vics feel for us WA Roos??...

I do and bonus points for the fact you turn out in numbers with a very poor win-game ratio in recent years.

 

[Elroo]

Yep article in the age on umpiring for the GF.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...vic-jeff-dalgleish-named-20150929-gjx6iz.html

All three of the umpires who officiated in last Saturday's second preliminary final - Ray Chamberlain, Dean Margetts and Simon Meredith - were overlooked, although Chamberlain was listed as the grand final emergency umpire.

North Melbourne were on the receiving end of several questionable decisions in the 25-point loss to West Coast.

 

[GoNorth]

Can't believe Chamberlain was even made an emergency. They must have a very shallow pool of umpires to select from!