Well Who's on first then?I thought Zach was replacing Scotty?
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Mega Thread Random recruiting hypotheticals etc 2011 - II
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Dramoth
Premium Platinum
Lucas => Scotland
Collins => Houlihan
Buckley => Simpson
pretty simple really *tch*
Collins => Houlihan
Buckley => Simpson
pretty simple really *tch*
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
How about:
Port
Lose: Pick 28, Pick 51
Gain: J Griffin, Pick 44, Pick 56
Freo
Lose: J.Griffin, Pick 56
Gain: P.Bower, Pick 51
Carlton
Lose: P Bower, Pick 44
Gain: Pick 28
Thoughts?
Port
Lose: Pick 28, Pick 51
Gain: J Griffin, Pick 44, Pick 56
Freo
Lose: J.Griffin, Pick 56
Gain: P.Bower, Pick 51
Carlton
Lose: P Bower, Pick 44
Gain: Pick 28
Thoughts?
get it done B&S
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
I think it is a pretty good deal for all.
Freo keeps it's second and offloads surplus (Griffin) for value (Bower)
Port gets promising ruck (Griffin) and stays in the second
Carlton free up list space and get a good pick
Third round pick swap is more or less an equalisation measure. Freo gets a little more, and Port won't be too flustered about a 5 pick downgrade when they get the second rounder as well
Freo keeps it's second and offloads surplus (Griffin) for value (Bower)
Port gets promising ruck (Griffin) and stays in the second
Carlton free up list space and get a good pick
Third round pick swap is more or less an equalisation measure. Freo gets a little more, and Port won't be too flustered about a 5 pick downgrade when they get the second rounder as well
It sounds like Port are more likely to just hand over a pick for Renouf.
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
I agree with you, but the press is reporting Lyon is keen to hang on to Griffen, perhpas worried about Sandilands breaking down as he gets on?
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
Clarke is a handy back-up I would have thought and Bradley is fine as a second ruck. Griffen could certainly claim top spot, but it might end up in a Warnock/Kreuzer/Hampson situation, except Kreuzer is better than the Freo second stringers by some margin.
clay smith
heard from a mate from gippsland that we are looking at this kid in the draft but dont quote me on that i know nothing of this draft or the kid? but my mate knows a few carlton people down there in gippsland so who knows
heard from a mate from gippsland that we are looking at this kid in the draft but dont quote me on that i know nothing of this draft or the kid? but my mate knows a few carlton people down there in gippsland so who knows
Re: clay smith
sounds like another mitch robinson
sounds like another mitch robinson
If we can get a pick in the 30's through Bower or OHailpin we might be able to get Clay.
Have to get Zyrus Manson with our first pick though for his name alone.
Have to get Zyrus Manson with our first pick though for his name alone.
Waylon/Zyrus/Charles
Yeah what is his name man.
When I first heard someone mention Waylon Manson I thought he sounds risky but possibly awesome, then all of a sudden they are talking about Zyrus Manson.
I say Zyrus becuase it sounds cooler.
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
Assuming my trade on last page pans out I'd want:
22: Paine/Waldhuter/Grigg/Tomlinson
28: Dobosz/Smith/Curran
1 Inside Mid, 1 KPF (although Tomlinson/Curran may be better suited at the other end)
22: Paine/Waldhuter/Grigg/Tomlinson
28: Dobosz/Smith/Curran
1 Inside Mid, 1 KPF (although Tomlinson/Curran may be better suited at the other end)
So I take it you cannot be persuaded solely by cool names then, I hope our recruiters are more like you than me.
Fair call, we are spoilt for choice.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Sep 5, 2011
- 8,488
- 16,734
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Dallas Cowboys, STL Blues
Where is bower off too?
Read western bulldogs - but they dont have anything we need. Hoping its not lake
Read western bulldogs - but they dont have anything we need. Hoping its not lake
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
Hypothetically carlton get in on the Brisbane/Freo trade:
Brisbane:
Lose: Mitch Clark, 34, 52
Gainick 16, 20, O'halpin
Freo:
Lose: Pick 16, 20,
Gain: Bower, Clark,
Carlton:
Lose: Paul Bower, Setanta O'halpin, Gain: 34, 52
Brisbane get a make-shift Clark replacement in O'halpin (no where near the quality, but depth coverage while you develop a replacement) and two first rounders.
Freo lose the first two but get their man Clark, and quality in Bower.
Carlton get picks for players and free up list space
Brisbane:
Lose: Mitch Clark, 34, 52
Gain
ick 16, 20, O'halpin Freo:
Lose: Pick 16, 20,
Gain: Bower, Clark,
Carlton:
Lose: Paul Bower, Setanta O'halpin, Gain: 34, 52
Brisbane get a make-shift Clark replacement in O'halpin (no where near the quality, but depth coverage while you develop a replacement) and two first rounders.
Freo lose the first two but get their man Clark, and quality in Bower.
Carlton get picks for players and free up list space
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
Too much for too little you think?
If Bower is getting interest from multiple parties you could probably worm Freo's second rounder in for ours. Or maybe a pick upgrade from Brisbane (34>> 29/30)
If Bower is getting interest from multiple parties you could probably worm Freo's second rounder in for ours. Or maybe a pick upgrade from Brisbane (34>> 29/30)
Carlton don't really need extra picks unless we offload higher picks for a player.
Carlton may only require one live pick in this draft.
Pick 1: Live
Pick 2: Touhy
Pick 3: Buckley
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
If Austin is gone, and we move O'halpin and Bower, plus Houlihan's retirement we have 4 selections.
22 Live
34 Live
52 Tuohy
63 Buckley
22 Live
34 Live
52 Tuohy
63 Buckley
