Rank the best 22 of each side, who has the best list?

[PerthBoy86]

There's talk about this or that team having a top a 4 list, like they'd be way better if only they had a great coach. Some think Carltons list has that potential while others think they're average or even bottom 4, especially considering depth. Thought it'd be interesting to try to rank each side purely on their best 22, if we take coaching/ladder/recent success out of it.

Also if you'd like, rank:

Best to worst top 6
Best to worst bottom 6

I dont feel I'm knowledgeable enough so will without doing my own, but be interesting to see what everyone thinks.

 

[TheUnicorn]

Top 6 in no particular order.

Adelaide
Brisbane
Fremantle
Western Bulldogs
Gold Coast
Geelong

Bottom 6 in no particular order.

West Coast
Richmond
Essendon
North Melbourne
Port Adelaide
Carlton

 

[DanA]

I don't think there is a standout this season but I am confident Carlton don't have a top 4 list. They have a really strong top end, but the core group of role players is really weak.

Top 6 in no particular order.

Adelaide
Brisbane
Fremantle
Western Bulldogs
Gold Coast
Geelong

Bottom 6 in no particular order.

West Coast
Richmond
Essendon
North Melbourne
Port Adelaide
Carlton

I'd probably swap Port with St Kilda in the bottom 6 but otherwise agree.

 

[PerthBoy86]

Full strength probably still Brisbane, then Adelaide, GWS, Geelong, Bulldogs, Gold Coast, Collingwood.

Coaching, Geelong, Collingwood, Gold Coast, GWS, Brisbane, Adelaide