Rate Brock McLean With a Draft Pick

[The Panther]

What would you feel would be the value of Brock McLean if he was up for a trade.

 

[OPETH]

List clogger

 

[mfc150]

I rated him at 20-25 before he was traded in a "rate your team's trade value" thread. He would have to be less than that now. I would say 3rd round at present.

His body has been leting him down for a long time now and his pace has waned significantly.

 

[Richo83]

dees won the trade, 3rd round.

 

[iGNITER]

Would struggle to get a game in our midfield.

Wouldnt play him before:

Swan
Pendlebury
Ball
Wellingham
Thomas

 

[ByeByeBrendan]

I thought he was only worth a second rounder last year and his value certainly wouldn't have increased this year.

 

[THE_GUN]

slow, injury prone , questionable disposal , hack

shane tuck is a brownlow medalist compared to this guy

luke ball pick 30 , brock mclean pick 11 .................. work that 1 out !!

 

[100action]

could not believe melb got pick 11 at the time. Its scary how big the market value of Franklin is if you use Brock for pick 11 as a benchmark.

 

[Kipz]

Pass

 

[Sin City]

You certainly have an unhealthy obsession with Carlton panther. Fear or jealousy?

 

[Donakebab]

After this season dropped from 2nd to 3rd round material. Depth only.

 

[harry45]

You certainly have an unhealthy obsession with Carlton panther. Fear or jealousy?

Who would be jealous, or fear Carlton

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Pre season draft at best

 

[}>-DEMON-<{]

about pick 40, unless you are Brett Ratten then clearly pick 11 is fair

still LOLing

 

[raymagoo]

rate the panthers iq with a number

 

[Bazzar]

Jordan McMahon for Brock McLean and 5th round selection would be a fair trade

 

[THE_GUN]

You certainly have an unhealthy obsession with Carlton panther. Fear or jealousy?

lol look who's talkong about obsession !

pot kettle black sin !

have a look at your obsession with richmond you cant live without a quote dangling from you .

 

[TigerTime88]

Well I would consider Luke Ball a better player than an up and coming McLean. However they are very similar and therefore pick 30. By no way would you want to give pick 11....definitley a failed trade.

 

[Demonheart]

Comments saying he is a hack is over the top, McLean has demonstrated this year that he can still play good footy but the biggest query over him is whether he can stay injury free and put several season together and get back to his best.

Clearly this is his biggest hurdle, and what makes it worse is that he broke down again with multiple injuries after having a great pre-season.
From a Melbourne perspective we did pretty well to get pick 11 considering he wanted to leave. With the benefit of hindsight it's pretty obvious that he'd struggle with our current style of play and would probably be spending a fair amount of time at Casey if he was injury free.

His value has obviously decreased but it's too early to write him off just yet, doesn't look great though.

2nd rounder right now (as absolute best) but still has potential to be a late first rounder if he can stay injury fee, big if though.

 

[THE_GUN]

Comments saying he is a hack is over the top, McLean has demonstrated this year that he can still play good footy but the biggest query over him is whether he can stay injury free and put several season together and get back to his best.

Clearly this is his biggest hurdle, and what makes it worse is that he broke down again with multiple injuries after having a great pre-season.
From a Melbourne perspective we did pretty well to get pick 11 considering he wanted to leave. With the benefit of hindsight it's pretty obvious that he'd struggle with our current style of play and would probably be spending a fair amount of time at Casey if he was injury free.

His value has obviously decreased but it's too early to write him off just yet, doesn't look great though.

2nd rounder right now (as absolute best) but still has potential to be a late first rounder if he can stay injury fee, big if though.

thats not his biggest problem at all deamon heart !

injury prone
extremely slow
terrible kick
plodder

definately a failed trade, hughes should be held responsible for giving up such a high draft pick for a plodder
in todays market mclean wouldnt attract anything more than a late 3rd draft pick & most teams would bypass him altogether

melbourne r*ped carlton on this trade.

 

[Demonheart]

thats not his biggest problem at all deamon heart !

injury prone
extremely slow
terrible kick
plodder

definately a failed trade, hughes should be held responsible for giving up such a high draft pick for a plodder
in todays market mclean wouldnt attract anything more than a late 3rd draft pick & most teams would bypass him altogether

melbourne r*ped carlton on this trade.

Well, it's hard to argue with you about his speed and his kicking isn't great either.

I guess my view is if he can get a couple of full seasons under his belt then it may assist with both of those issues.
I agree that the signs aren't great.

 

[jonesy86]

Based on Ball being pick 30... probably 40-50.

 

[Jade]

No thanks, list clogger.

Melbourne made out like bandits in that trade.

 

[davey_magik]

McLean >>>> Ball (If McLean actually gets out onto the park).

I would have said late first round, so I'm pretty happy with 11. Still think we forced him out a bit and he's the only reason I don't mind seeing Carlton go alright.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

We're done here.