Richmond vs Bullants

[CarltonFan]

if these two teams played against each other, who would win?

Here is Richmond's round 22 team:
Richmond
B: Moore, Silvester, Polo
HB: Rance, McGuane, McMahon
C: Edwards, Deledio, Thomson
HF: Brown, Riewoldt, Tambling
F: White, Morton, Cousins
Foll: Simmonds, Jackson, Tuck
I/C: Polak, Coughlan, Nahas, Graham

Here is the Bullants VFL Grand final team:
Bullants
B: Spiteri, Hartlett, Boundy
HB: Edwards, Saddington, Jo.Bannister
C: McCorkell, Iacobucci, Bentick
HF: Garlett, Cloke, Yarran
F: Gianfagna, Fisher, Ellard
Foll: Jacobs, Anderson, Morgan
I/C: Browne, Ja.Bannister, Bransgrove, Neaves

obviously both teams would be missing a few players from their best 22, but these teams give us a rough idea.

I dont think Richmond will be able to stop big Cloke and Fisher from kicking a bag, also Richmond dont have great small defenders so Yarran and Garlett would have a field day.

Jacobs is clearly the better Ruck, and there is about an even midfield with tigers just ahead there.

would be a good game to watch, who would win?

 

[Blueboys7]

Nice try

 

[CarltonFan]

mods please add a poll, this one could go to the wire.

 

[007Tigers]

if these two teams played against each other, who would win?

Here is Richmond's round 22 team:
Richmond
B: Moore, Silvester, Polo
HB: Rance, McGuane, McMahon
C: Edwards, Deledio, Thomson
HF: Brown, Riewoldt, Tambling
F: White, Morton, Cousins
Foll: Simmonds, Jackson, Tuck
I/C: Polak, Coughlan, Nahas, Graham

Here is the Bullants VFL Grand final team:
Bullants
B: Spiteri, Hartlett, Boundy
HB: Edwards, Saddington, Jo.Bannister
C: McCorkell, Iacobucci, Bentick
HF: Garlett, Cloke, Yarran
F: Gianfagna, Fisher, Ellard
Foll: Jacobs, Anderson, Morgan
I/C: Browne, Ja.Bannister, Bransgrove, Neaves

obviously both teams would be missing a few players from their best 22, but these teams give us a rough idea.

I dont think Richmond will be able to stop big Cloke and Fisher from kicking a bag, also Richmond dont have great small defenders so Yarran and Garlett would have a field day.

Jacobs is clearly the better Ruck, and there is about an even midfield with tigers just ahead there.

would be a good game to watch, who would win?

i got no problem with you listing this threat that the part i have in bold is a joke, round 1 cloke played and you beat us by 90 points and he didnt even score a goal, he was very lucky to get another shot on your list

brad fisher played against us in round 15 and kicked 1 goal, nothing special

yarren hasnt played against us yet, gartlett also played us in round 15 once again like cloke in round 1 no goals

yet you think he cant stop these players?

bag us all you like, but we still have a young list next year if richo does play we will prob only have 5-6 if that players in the team thats 23 or over

 

[GordonBlue]

bag us all you like, but we still have a young list next year if richo does play we will prob only have 5-6 if that players in the team thats 23 or over

What's your point?

Any team can have a team full of kids... that's not the aim... you need a good balance all over the board... a team full of kids at richmond only means that you have a new excuse to suck next year

 

[007Tigers]

What's your point?

Any team can have a team full of kids... that's not the aim... you need a good balance all over the board... a team full of kids at richmond only means that you have a new excuse to suck next year

thats not true, look at the cats the reason why they are so good is coz most of them have hit there peak which is usually around the age of 25 ect

they dont have many players in there starting 22 thats under 23 years old

 

[Go_Blues!]

thats not true, look at the cats the reason why they are so good is coz most of them have hit there peak which is usually around the age of 25 ect

they dont have many players in there starting 22 thats under 23 years old

Wrong dickwad. The reason why the cats are so good is because all of their players are really good. The reason why Richmond are so shit is because all of your players, regardless of age, are shit. Deledio, Cousins, Richo and Cotchin are possible exceptions but there is not a single other player on your list that would get a run with another club. What you have is a poorly run club that persisted in recruiting clowns for the best part of a decade. Richmond will be worse in 2010 than they were in 2009. You still have not seen the depths of your future misery. As a supporter of AFL, I find it embarrassing.

 

[The Toad]

Wrong dickwad. The reason why the cats are so good is because all of their players are really good. The reason why Richmond are so shit is because all of your players, regardless of age, are shit. Deledio, Cousins, Richo and Cotchin are possible exceptions but there is not a single other player on your list that would get a run with another club. What you have is a poorly run club that persisted in recruiting clowns for the best part of a decade. Richmond will be worse in 2010 than they were in 2009. You still have not seen the depths of your future misery. As a supporter of AFL, I find it embarrassing.

Ha Ha Ha what a craker. God I love BF.

 

[Bentick's My Man.]

Ha Ha Ha what a craker. God I love BF.

Nah this is why I don't like it.

No point to this thread. Why try and irritate the Richmond supporters then when they retaliate cry to the mods.

 

[blues4flag]

Crap thread is crap.

 

[Silvagnis]

Can we move this to the bay?

Or lock it down...

This sort of thread belongs on the bay.

Or the Richmond board.

 

[celtic_pride]

This is the worst thread ever, the Bullants got pantsed by a North Ballarat side that is mostly a team of 'battlers', I hardly think they are in a position to say they can match it with an AFL side ...

Richmond will improve next year make no mistake, I even think the rnd 1 game next year irght now is a 50/50 contest, especially with no Judd.

These is no excuse for unfounded arrogance in my book.
If we lost, the Tigers fans will come back and troll this board and bump up threads like this, make no mistake.

 

[Gozz]

I agree with CP, this thread is setting us up for embarrassment.

On the other hand, if you take Deledio and Benny Cuz from that team, then it would be an interesting match.

 

[lvt06]

Crap Thread guys.

We i could reply with my true feelings, but thats not aloud.

 

[celtic_pride]

Crap Thread guys.

We i could reply with my true feelings, but thats not aloud.

ROFL your appalling grammar speaks volumes in the way insults never could

 

[Cotchin2010]

Wrong dickwad. The reason why the cats are so good is because all of their players are really good. The reason why Richmond are so shit is because all of your players, regardless of age, are shit. Deledio, Cousins, Richo and Cotchin are possible exceptions but there is not a single other player on your list that would get a run with another club. What you have is a poorly run club that persisted in recruiting clowns for the best part of a decade. Richmond will be worse in 2010 than they were in 2009. You still have not seen the depths of your future misery. As a supporter of AFL, I find it embarrassing.

OMG I cannot actually believe the arrogance of Carlton supporters to put this thread up. To think a VFL side could compete with an AFL team is a joke and shows your stupidity!

I bolded this comment because I love the fact that a BROWNLOW medalist a guy who was runner up and has kicked 800 goals and two young guns are 'possible' exceptions. You have got to be kidding yourself.

I don't mind the blues and was good mates with Murph at school, but I think a few Carlton supporters need to take a look and see that they have had 1 good year for the last 7. Plus you got bundled out in the first final, lost your captain for the first 3 games and now have no forward line.

Im not at all suggesting that Richmond are going to come through and dominate by any means. However I love the fact that you put in every crap Richmond player possible and don't include guys like Cotchin in your team.

I think you need to realise that rnd 1 this year will have no where near as much build up, but will probably be much closer. Carlton have no forward line now and a terrible back line. Your midfield is very good but come rnd 1 no Judd will make a big difference.

While Richmond have alot of work to do our midfield of: Cousins, Deledio, Cotchin, Foley, Tambling, Collins and Jackson is decent. Add to this Martin who will we pick up in the draft and Carlton really don't have much over us.

Seriously take a rain check...cannot see Carlton making the 8 next year purely for the fact that they will not be able to replace 90 goals.

 

[celtic_pride]

FFS how many people on this forum are friends or 'went to school' with Marc Murphy??

 

[thylacine60]

FFS how many people on this forum went to school?

:diamond::club::spade:

 

[The Coach]

OMG I cannot actually believe the arrogance of Carlton supporters to put this thread up. To think a VFL side could compete with an AFL team is a joke and shows your stupidity!

I bolded this comment because I love the fact that a BROWNLOW medalist a guy who was runner up and has kicked 800 goals and two young guns are 'possible' exceptions. You have got to be kidding yourself.

I don't mind the blues and was good mates with Murph at school, but I think a few Carlton supporters need to take a look and see that they have had 1 good year for the last 7. Plus you got bundled out in the first final, lost your captain for the first 3 games and now have no forward line.

Im not at all suggesting that Richmond are going to come through and dominate by any means. However I love the fact that you put in every crap Richmond player possible and don't include guys like Cotchin in your team.

I think you need to realise that rnd 1 this year will have no where near as much build up, but will probably be much closer. Carlton have no forward line now and a terrible back line. Your midfield is very good but come rnd 1 no Judd will make a big difference.

While Richmond have alot of work to do our midfield of: Cousins, Deledio, Cotchin, Foley, Tambling, Collins and Jackson is decent. Add to this Martin who will we pick up in the draft and Carlton really don't have much over us.

Seriously take a rain check...cannot see Carlton making the 8 next year purely for the fact that they will not be able to replace 90 goals.

Never before have we had such a compliment from a Richmond supporter - you really believe we do not have a single idiot barracking for us because you do know that posts are made by individuals

 

[Silvagnis]

Plus you got bundled out in the first final, lost your captain for the first 3 games and now have no forward line.

Carlton have no forward line now and a terrible back line. Your midfield is very good but come rnd 1 no Judd will make a big difference.

While Richmond have alot of work to do our midfield of: Cousins, Deledio, Cotchin, Foley, Tambling, Collins and Jackson is decent. Add to this Martin who will we pick up in the draft and Carlton really don't have much over us.

I guess you won't mind me quoting a Richmond supporter if we have no forwards, Martin and Judd for just the first three rounds.

HF: reiwoldt post cousins/newman

FF: morton gourdis nahas.

Our terrible backline won't be able to stop that A grade forwardline.

Dustin Martin is another top three pick who will be developed to the best of Richmond's ability.

 

[Cotchin2010]

FFS how many people on this forum are friends or 'went to school' with Marc Murphy??

Well I went to Whitefriars college and graduated in 2005...Andy Otten was also two years below me and Stephen Gilham 3 or 4 ahead lol

 

[blue gunslinger]

Well I went to Whitefriars college and graduated in 2005...Andy Otten was also two years below me and Stephen Gilham 3 or 4 ahead lol

so why are you our local garbo?

 

[Cotchin2010]

I guess you won't mind me quoting a Richmond supporter if we have no forwards, Martin and Judd for just the first three rounds.

Our terrible backline won't be able to stop that A grade forwardline.

Dustin Martin is another top three pick who will be developed to the best of Richmond's ability.

Ha ha well i don't know why people quote David Gourdis at FF. The kid hasn't played a game is 197cm and a freak athlete who plays VFL 2's! His as good as setanta...

Morton kicked 4 in a side that lost by 80 points and Riewoldt kicked 30 or 40...a hell of alot better than Carlton's forward line now with no Fev! Plus Vickery will become the big target down there...

As for Richmond's development...I think a new coaching staff will make a difference! Plus it's not so much our development, more us recruiting sh*T trucks like JON! I think Cotchin, Post and Vickery are developing pretty well and no one could stuff Martin up he is a gun!

 

[blue gunslinger]

Ha ha well i don't know why people quote David Gourdis at FF. The kid hasn't played a game is 197cm and a freak athlete who plays VFL 2's! His as good as setanta...

Morton kicked 4 in a side that lost by 80 points and Riewoldt kicked 30 or 40...a hell of alot better than Carlton's forward line now with no Fev! Plus Vickery will become the big target down there...

As for Richmond's development...I think a new coaching staff will make a difference! Plus it's not so much our development, more us recruiting sh*T trucks like JON! I think Cotchin, Post and Vickery are developing pretty well and no one could stuff Martin up he is a gun!

well it has not done much the last dozen times!

 

[Blue Dimension]

Do you guys not have the slightest sense of humour? You can't tell me you didn't giggle...just a tiny bit