Robert Harvey V Nathan Buckley

[Snickers]

Robert Harvey for me!

 

[Joffaboy]

Yup.

 

[what the!]

Do you even have to ask?


HARVEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[viccles]

Yep not one Brownlow but two so Harvs for me

 

[The Fireman]

Skills aside and voting just on the calibre and demeanor of the 2, Banger gets the nod.

 

[EssendonPride]

Harves

 

[LoneStar]

One Brownlow plus the least deserved Norm Smith ever vs pair of Brownlows. Harvey for me

 

[topdon]

Harvey

2 Brownlows to show for it. At his peak, Harvey was untouchable. Well, you might lay a hand on him, but good luck tackling the bugger. Ran all day. A workhorse who will ulimately fail to have a premiership medallion hanging around his neck.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

1 Brownlow
1 Norm Smith
6 B + F Awards
Countless number of awards.

Buckley is much better than Harvey.

 

[Johnson#26]

Buckley.

 

[matts_girl]

Without a doubt Robert Harvey.

 

[Total Package]

Another Saints backslapping poll

 

[Snickers]

Another Saints backslapping poll

No it's not....... its a serouis question!

 

[Pedro]

Two great champions who I'd have in my side any day. Pretty hard to split for me. Harvey at his best is untouchable. He is amazing in the way he eludes tackles. Buckley is the far better kick imo. Both have amazing endurance and are great players. I'll take Bucks out of bias, but Harvey would be welcome any day of the week in my side.

 

[raskolnikov]

At their peak Harvey - right now Buckley

 

[Total Package]

No it's not....... its a serouis question!

hahaha yeah right. Its a backslapping thread. You put the poll up knowing that most people are going to vote for Robert Harvey. You wouldnt have put this poll up if you knew that Buckley would win the poll.

Why is it a serious question anyway? Why the comparison? Why not ask who is better out of Robert Harvey and Wayne Carey?

 

[davey_magik]

Two of the best midfielders of the past 15 years. Brownlows do not count for everything, and although Banger is a champ I'd take Bucks for his better kicking and versatility.

Originally posted by LoneStar
One Brownlow plus the least deserved Norm Smith ever vs pair of Brownlows. Harvey for me

That is ridiculous. Buckley damn near won that game for them. It is a stick topic when others say Voss deserved it but it was extremely close and fair from the least deserved Norm Smith ever.

 

[Snickers]

hahaha yeah right. Its a backslapping thread. You put the poll up knowing that most people are going to vote for Robert Harvey. You wouldnt have put this poll up if you knew that Buckley would win the poll.

Why is it a serious question anyway? Why the comparison? Why not ask who is better out of Robert Harvey and Wayne Carey?

I didnt know who was going to vote for who......... i thought it was going to be a good comparsion. And the reason i didnt do Harvey and Carey was because they played in differnt positions **** head.

 

[Silvagnis]

As much as it hurts me to say it Buckley is the complete package whilst harvey's kicking needs work and doesn't kick enough goals for a champion.

 

[Snickers]

As much as it hurts me to say it Buckley is the complete package whilst harvey's kicking needs work and doesn't kick enough goals for a champion.

Harvey has other qualities that other people have never had before in the history of the game.

HE WILL ALWAYS BE A CHAMPION!

 

[Jimmy]

harvs

 

[don4eva]

Harvey is the man

 

[Total Package]

I didnt know who was going to vote for who......... i thought it was going to be a good comparsion. And the reason i didnt do Harvey and Carey was because they played in differnt positions **** head.

Harvey has other qualities that other people have never had before in the history of the game.

HE WILL ALWAYS BE A CHAMPION!

Yeah... sounds like you were really struggling as to who you were going to vote for

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Bucks' consistency, durabilty and professionalism gets him the nod from me.

Although, Harvey at his absolute best is untouchable.

 

[Silvagnis]

Harvey has other qualities that other people have never had before in the history of the game.

Lucky it's not Harvey v Bradley it would be overwhelming in Bradley's favour.He's a better player than both bucks and banger and twice drank from a premiership cup.