Roe vs Maxwell

[Dave The Man]

Both where on Collingwood Rookie List and They had to keep 1.

Did the Pies picked the right one?

 

[Leather Poisoning]

There is no way Maxwell should win ANY poll against ANY player.

 

[One-eyed]

me thinks the pies pooped on this one. maxwell wouldn't be getting a game if he wasn't such a good leader and wouldn't be getting a game at most other teams.

 

[Heater39]

There is no way Maxwell should win ANY poll against ANY player.

lol, harsh... but true.

 

[notting18]

Roe hasn't had enough of a good run with injuries to really show what he is capable of consitantly so it is hard to judge. However, as a Brisbane supporter I am very happy with Roe and wouldn't trade him for Maxwell if the opportunity arose.

 

[thebigboy]

There are very few players that Maxwell can effectivly match up on. Must be one hell of a leader.