Round 15 trades

[SC fish]

Sticking with my original trades - Beams to JPKennedy and Hannan to Macrae

7 trades left

 

[Bollox]

I'm on carnage watch.
Touching nothing till Saturday Night

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Beams>Cripps

2 trades remaining lord help me.

#prayforsteves

#prayforjm

#kegsformod

 

[Gene Simmons]

How do these 2 trades sound?
McInnes -> Witherden
Nank -> Greene

?

 

[srobbo]

Beech will be dropped this week & doubtful he plays again this year

He's playing

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Some advice needed 10 trades 271k.

B: Laird Lloyd Shaw Rance Tuohy Stewart (Scharenberg Ryan)

M: Danger JSelwood Pendlebury JPK Bont Beams Fyfe SSelwood (Greenwood, Cousins, Hibberd)

Fwd: Macrae Dahlhaus Ryder Franklin JJK Lynch (J Stewart, C Brown)

Ruck: Witts Nank (Cameron)

So Stewart and Beams are going holding Scooter and JJK hoping they will be back next week, Lynch will have to stay.

So I have 1111k to get a mid and a back, unsure which to strength most as i can't afford dusty and docherty combined.
A) Docherty and any mid up to 457k (limited options)
B) Dusty and Gray (any mid up to 477k)
C) Adams and any mid up to 592 (thinking neale or hanners)
D) Hibberd and Dusty
E) Adams and Parker/Wines and bank 100k

Sort of leaning towards C but not sure, would like to try and keep some cash in reserve to get gawn soon.

 

[stevebbb]

Some advice needed 10 trades 271k.

B: Laird Lloyd Shaw Rance Tuohy Stewart (Scharenberg Ryan)

M: Danger JSelwood Pendlebury JPK Bont Beams Fyfe SSelwood (Greenwood, Cousins, Hibberd)

Fwd: Macrae Dahlhaus Ryder Franklin JJK Lynch (J Stewart, C Brown)

Ruck: Witts Nank (Cameron)

So Stewart and Beams are going holding Scooter and JJK hoping they will be back next week, Lynch will have to stay.

So I have 1111k to get a mid and a back, unsure which to strength most as i can't afford dusty and docherty combined.
A) Docherty and any mid up to 457k (limited options)
B) Dusty and Gray (any mid up to 477k)
C) Adams and any mid up to 592 (thinking neale or hanners)
D) Hibberd and Dusty
E) Adams and Parker/Wines and bank 100k

Sort of leaning towards C but not sure, would like to try and keep some cash in reserve to get gawn soon.

With so many trades left, you can afford to use every cent, don't need to bank some

Go option C. Adams + whoever you can get. Neale a good option

 

[gutsroy]

How do these 2 trades sound?
McInnes -> Witherden
Nank -> Greene

?

Any other areas where you need to upgrade or at full premo?
Without seeing side:
If you have no use for Nank DPP, reckon Greene is solid, should hopefully net you 125+ points ytg, seems ok.
McInnes actually not bad for looping, do you need cash generation / cover from Witherden / to reopen DPP link? Or short on funds and need to one down, one up?
If not, might be inclined to save trade, personally and loop big Fraser.
Bit non-committal, that, but there you have it...

 

[stevebbb]

Sticking with Cal Ward, taking the punt
Definitely has the potential for consistent big scores, hoping the last couple weeks have been a turning point
For $470k, I'd be ecstatic with a 105 avg from here on

 

[arsene wenger1]

Yes I have all three thanks.

Martin it is

 

[Glorin]

Sticking with Cal Ward, taking the punt
Definitely has the potential for consistent big scores, hoping the last couple weeks have been a turning point
For $470k, I'd be ecstatic with a 105 avg from here on

Not sure about Ward. Even when at his best he throws in real stinker games. If you need someone cheap I would look at R Gray. May have some quiet games but will win a few for you too.

 

[Glorin]

So decided to stick to my long term plan.
Out Hannan and Scooter
In Bont and Witherden.
Leaves me with 4 trades and 116k and decent cover on each line.
Only luxury/injury trades from here.

 

[big_bazza]

Still cant decide whether to go Nank > Stefan. I'd like to give Nank one more week to redeem himself but if i wait another week and he goes shit i wont be able to afford to do it next week and bring Gawny in, itd have to be one or the other where as if i do it this week it will leave 220 k which might be fund the Gawn trade.

Do you lads reckon that 220k will be enough to go J.Stewart>Gawn next week?

 

[gutsroy]

Still cant decide whether to go Nank > Stefan. I'd like to give Nank one more week to redeem himself but if i wait another week and he goes shit i wont be able to afford to do it next week and bring Gawny in, itd have to be one or the other where as if i do it this week it will leave 220 k which might be fund the Gawn trade.

Do you lads reckon that 220k will be enough to go J.Stewart>Gawn next week?

Don't hold me to this, back of envelope job, but:

If Big Max goes 124, he'll still shed around 25k and end up 527k-odd. If Stewart pumps out a 60, he'll gain 25k-odd and end up around 290k. (237k needed)
If Big Max goes 110, he'll still shed around 31k and end up 521k-odd. If Stewart pumps out a 70, he'll gain 29k-odd and end up around 294k. (227k needed)
If Big Max goes 100, he'll still shed around 35k and end up 517k-odd. If Stewart pumps out an 80, he'll gain 33k-odd and end up around 298k.(219k needed)

Tight, but a chance. Stewart could go for a larger score at home vs Lions. For each 10-point increment up or down, assume +/- 4.2k-odd respectively.

 

[big_bazza]

Don't hold me to this, back of envelope job, but:

If Big Max goes 124, he'll still shed around 25k and end up 527k-odd. If Stewart pumps out a 60, he'll gain 25k-odd and end up around 290k. (237k needed)
If Big Max goes 110, he'll still shed around 31k and end up 521k-odd. If Stewart pumps out a 70, he'll gain 29k-odd and end up around 294k. (227k needed)
If Big Max goes 100, he'll still shed around 35k and end up 517k-odd. If Stewart pumps out an 80, he'll gain 33k-odd and end up around 298k.(219k needed)

Tight, but a chance. Stewart could go for a larger score at home vs Lions. For each 10-point increment up or down, assume +/- 4.2k-odd respectively.

Thanks heaps mate, it is doable then. ill wait until im pissed later tonight before i make the inevidably wrong call.

 

[Glorin]

Thanks heaps mate, it is doable then. ill wait until im pissed later tonight before i make the inevidably wrong call.

If its any help, I have had Stef since rd 3-4 and am a very happy owner. I think he is a little under appreciated around here and most have been scared off by Smith. He will bomb this week now that I am talking him up!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

He's playing

just amazing .......wouldn't be banking on him playing too many more ...was fortunate that Lynch came down with Viral Meningitis ......Beech will play his role this week, maybe next week, until Lynch returns

 

[The Lemon]

Sticking with my original trades

Swallow - Bont
Stewart - Witherden

9 trades left.

With Beams, Scooter and Cousins on the pine, I am a bees pecker away from a donut.

Hoping to get a better idea about how long scooter will be out for. Otherwise I might need to move him on next week.

 

[Glorin]

Sticking with my original trades

Swallow - Bont
Stewart - Witherden

9 trades left.

With Beams, Scooter and Cousins on the pine, I am a bees pecker away from a donut.

Hoping to get a better idea about how long scooter will be out for. Otherwise I might need to move him on next week.

Why not just trade Scooter instead of Swallow. I would see them as about the same and if neither were going to be onfield then they are only cover.
Stick with the guy thats playing.

 

[The Lemon]

Why not just trade Scooter instead of Swallow. I would see them as about the same and if neither were going to be onfield then they are only cover.
Stick with the guy thats playing.

Swallow is putrid.

I legit hate the guy he is that bad.

Whoever I keep is my M10 for the year. I'll back Selwood in Finals

 

[srobbo]

Sticking fat this week with 7 left.

Was tempted to flick Nank for Billings but know minute I do, I'll lose a ruck & be fisted for cover.

Got quite a few back men back, so keeping the faith atleast for this week.

 

[stevebbb]

Not sure about Ward. Even when at his best he throws in real stinker games. If you need someone cheap I would look at R Gray. May have some quiet games but will win a few for you too.

Yeah Gray is the obvious choice, but I'm stubborn as hell and settled on Ward

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Anyone looking at Mathew White?

 

[Papa Caz]

13 Trades left.

Am I mad for thinking of trading Jelwood to another Mid premo, then bringing Jelwood back in in two weeks when he is around 450k or less? My thinking is that then I'd need only one trade (being Greenwood) to bring him in rather then use two in a couple of weeks to bring in my last mid premo.

Either that or it'll be Roughead and Myers to Greene and Witherden.

You have 13 trades left? Get out, leave I don't want you here with your 13 trades while I struggle with my 6

 

[Papa Caz]

Do people think that shaz and brown will both play or atleast 1 of them??