Round 18 Trades

[Biggie]

Me too. What are you gonna do Big Man? Any trades left?

I have one trade left so looks like I will be forced to keep Chappy on the bench, play Valenti and pray to the supercoach gods that Chappy comes back in 1-2 weeks instead of 3-4.

I think I'll let him go JM.

He is in my mids so I think without doing the math I'll be able to nab a mid whi tearing it up in the last 3 games then also upgrade Morton to a forward who had a great start to the year but has underperfomed as has his team in the past 3 weeks.

Will only leave KReuzer left on field.

WIll do the maths tonight and that will leave me with no trades for 4 weeks.

 

[Josh_williams]

Trading Chad out which will let me get any midfielder I want. Who should i get? I already have Ablett, Bartell, Mitchell and Kornes..

Leaning towards Hodge, Black or Judd?

any thoughts?

cheers

 

[Judd_Magic]

I think I'll let him go JM.

He is in my mids so I think without doing the math I'll be able to nab a mid whi tearing it up in the last 3 games then also upgrade Morton to a forward who had a great start to the year but has underperfomed as has his team in the past 3 weeks.

Will only leave KReuzer left on field.

WIll do the maths tonight and that will leave me with no trades for 4 weeks.

I have Chappy in my forward line so hard choice for me knowing what to do with him. They aren't heaps of good froward line options left either. I have all the good ones and Riewoldt is too expensive now.

So wish I had of kept medhurst now instead of trading in Chappy for him, just too injury prone. Wont be touching him next year.

And I still have C.Cornes on the bench in my backline. I would prefer to trade him out for Birchall, Welsh, Ladson or Mcleoad to be honest.

If it meant Chappy just missing 1-2 I could live with that but if any more it means that he will possibly miss my first finals match and second one too.

What to do, what to do if you were me??????

 

[pup23]

Need to trade C.Cornes ive got 391k to spend any thoughts on who to get?

current backline is: Mattner, Shaw, Bock, Birchall, S.Fisher, Bradshaw, Wilkes (Cornes, Proud on bench)

 

[Headless]

I have 3 trades left, I want to go Cornes >>> Pratt.

Will win easily this week, but if Pratt scores 110 or more I won't have enough cash to get him.

Do I get him this week or hold on?

 

[swansfan51]

To be honest I'm just waiting for everyone to run out of trades, get another injury, and then complain about their bad luck. This is my first year of SC but it happens in DT every year.

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

After a little advice please. I have got $438,200 in bank. Only holes in my team are 6 + 7th forwards.
I have Tippet $235,800, Hill $302,700 and Bradley (bench) $250,100 up for trade. Want to trade 2 of the above for ROK and possibly Franklin.
Who out of Tippet, Hill and Bradley would you keep on your bench as cover?

 

[Biggie]

To be honest I'm just waiting for everyone to run out of trades, get another injury, and then complain about their bad luck. This is my first year of SC but it happens in DT every year.

We're a bit more grown up than that in here I feel.

 

[benny1712]

Trading Chad out which will let me get any midfielder I want. Who should i get? I already have Ablett, Bartell, Mitchell and Kornes..

Leaning towards Hodge, Black or Judd?

any thoughts?

cheers

All good picks but i'd lean towards Hodge or Judd because Brisbane have a tough last 4 games.

I have Chappy in my forward line so hard choice for me knowing what to do with him. They aren't heaps of good froward line options left either. I have all the good ones and Riewoldt is too expensive now.

So wish I had of kept medhurst now instead of trading in Chappy for him, just too injury prone. Wont be touching him next year.

And I still have C.Cornes on the bench in my backline. I would prefer to trade him out for Birchall, Welsh, Ladson or Mcleoad to be honest.

If it meant Chappy just missing 1-2 I could live with that but if any more it means that he will possibly miss my first finals match and second one too.

What to do, what to do if you were me??????

If you'd rather upgrade Cornes then do it

Need to trade C.Cornes ive got 391k to spend any thoughts on who to get?

current backline is: Mattner, Shaw, Bock, Birchall, S.Fisher, Bradshaw, Wilkes (Cornes, Proud on bench)

You could go for some risk in McLeod or Kennelly (pro: can score big, con: injury clouds)
Not a lot on offer for 391k

I have 3 trades left, I want to go Cornes >>> Pratt.

Will win easily this week, but if Pratt scores 110 or more I won't have enough cash to get him.

Do I get him this week or hold on?

Might as well get him, Cornes isn't going to be doing anything on your bench

After a little advice please. I have got $438,200 in bank. Only holes in my team are 6 + 7th forwards.
I have Tippet $235,800, Hill $302,700 and Bradley (bench) $250,100 up for trade. Want to trade 2 of the above for ROK and possibly Franklin.
Who out of Tippet, Hill and Bradley would you keep on your bench as cover?

Tippett, while inconsistent, will play out the rest of the season so if you need cover you'll get 20 more points

 

[Satan]

problems

backs

neagle gone I believe, King will he be back, Proud, who knows

need to trade 1 out to avoid a zero again, lost my last game by 29 pts playing with a zero

mids
ablett on the bench with Scott selwood, or wellingham as my 6th mid

fwds

Chappy at least 2 weeks

Pav??

have porps, Jetta to cover

Unless there are more changes only want fix up backs this week

have 4 trades , 195,800, 3rd on % , playing bottom side, could finish between 2 and 6th

As neagle is gone and I trade him just to make 7 backs playing have upto 385600 to spend and as previously stated on these boards, quality backs this year are rare. Can go from a birchall , staker to a brad moran or joshua head.


if king plays ??, then I might downgrade wellingham to Dazell in the mids

 

[shiny_on_top]

Think i might wait to next week and go
Goodes > Cooney
Palmer > Thompson
Will Cooney and Thompson score big scores in the final 4 weeks???

 

[dopeh]

I've decided to take a huge risk in the hope of placing higher in the overall rankings, as that my main goal.

I'm going to trade out Ablett, but who for, tossing up between Bartel, Harvey or Hodge.

They extra cash this nets me allows me to upgrade Cornes but cant decide between Milburn or Bowden.

Any ideas/suggestions/criticism?

 

[fugu]

Nice to see someone's got the balls to do it. I'd go Bartel, looks like he's coming home with a wet sail.

 

[Faz 2000]

Barring major selection shocks, Nicoski is turning into a gun defender for me this evening.

Who do I want to be on board out of?

Gilbee for $521k
Fisher for $492k
Pratt for $493k

Anyone else in that bracket? Seems to me Fisher is the most consistent of the 3, but won't have the massive games of Gilbee.

 

[alternatevista]

I want to trade out Houli for a gun midfielder. Have the cash for Ablett but want to make the trade sooner rather than later as I'm trying for a top10 overall finish in AdelaideNow.

My current mids are Cooney, Bartel, Cross, NDS, Hodge and Cotchin. So Cotchin will go to the bench and new recruit will start.

Shortlist is Kirk, Harvey, Power, Judd, Black, Goodwin and Corey.
Was thinking Corey due to Cats form and good run home, alternatively I could wait a week for Ablett and hope he returns to his best. Lions have been a bit ropey of past so would probably go for Judd over them too.

 

[alternatevista]

I've decided to take a huge risk in the hope of placing higher in the overall rankings, as that my main goal.

I'm going to trade out Ablett, but who for, tossing up between Bartel, Harvey or Hodge.

They extra cash this nets me allows me to upgrade Cornes but cant decide between Milburn or Bowden.

Any ideas/suggestions/criticism?

Bartel has a good run home but needs 30+ possies for a good score. Hodge is more like Goodes and can post 100 from just 20 possies. Saying that it doesn't look like Bartel is going to be struggling for the pill any time soon so either would be a great pickup. For the record I have both.

 

[Faz 2000]

Shortlist is Kirk, Harvey, Power, Judd, Black, Goodwin and Corey.
Was thinking Corey due to Cats form and good run home, alternatively I could wait a week for Ablett and hope he returns to his best. Lions have been a bit ropey of past so would probably go for Judd over them too.

I was looking at those sorta guys too... but Corey seems to be able to post sub-100 scores with 35+ touches. Not sure he's the greatest SuperCoach player. Harvey and Judd are guys who can put up very big numbers, with their goal-kicking nous.

 

[Biggie]

Barring major selection shocks, Nicoski is turning into a gun defender for me this evening.

Who do I want to be on board out of?

Gilbee for $521k
Fisher for $492k
Pratt for $493k

Anyone else in that bracket? Seems to me Fisher is the most consistent of the 3, but won't have the massive games of Gilbee.

Gilbee.

 

[Biggie]

I've decided to take a huge risk in the hope of placing higher in the overall rankings, as that my main goal.

I'm going to trade out Ablett, but who for, tossing up between Bartel, Harvey or Hodge.

They extra cash this nets me allows me to upgrade Cornes but cant decide between Milburn or Bowden.

Any ideas/suggestions/criticism?

Harvey & Milburn.

 

[swansfan51]

I've decided to take a huge risk in the hope of placing higher in the overall rankings, as that my main goal.

I'm going to trade out Ablett, but who for, tossing up between Bartel, Harvey or Hodge.

They extra cash this nets me allows me to upgrade Cornes but cant decide between Milburn or Bowden.

Any ideas/suggestions/criticism?

Bartel and Bowden.

Barring major selection shocks, Nicoski is turning into a gun defender for me this evening.

Who do I want to be on board out of?

Gilbee for $521k
Fisher for $492k
Pratt for $493k

Anyone else in that bracket? Seems to me Fisher is the most consistent of the 3, but won't have the massive games of Gilbee.

Gilbee, followed by daylight, followed by Fisher.

I want to trade out Houli for a gun midfielder. Have the cash for Ablett but want to make the trade sooner rather than later as I'm trying for a top10 overall finish in AdelaideNow.

My current mids are Cooney, Bartel, Cross, NDS, Hodge and Cotchin. So Cotchin will go to the bench and new recruit will start.

Shortlist is Kirk, Harvey, Power, Judd, Black, Goodwin and Corey.
Was thinking Corey due to Cats form and good run home, alternatively I could wait a week for Ablett and hope he returns to his best. Lions have been a bit ropey of past so would probably go for Judd over them too.

I would go with Kirk or Judd, not considering price or anything else. Kirk wins hard contested ball and is not a cheap showpony, and Judd is allegedly returning to his best now.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Any reason not to buy Cooney? Seems like the best value gun midfielder, though his recent form is a little concerning.

 

[Lotch]

Yeah have 6 trades.
Does anyone see a problem with:

Armitage -> Dalziell
Chappy -> RoK

Also can any WC fans tell me the players likely to be dropped off extended bench.

 

[Kanga.18]

I'm going for League wins, and therefore prepared to use 2 of my remianing 4 trades this week to fix up my 7th defenders spot.

I plan on trading out bench players Urquhart and Nathan Brown (Collingwood), in order to get a decent back in either:

Bock or Ladson

and a cheap 9th defender in:

Josh Head, Callan Ward or Eric mckenzie


Prices and averages of these 5 possible purchases are near enough to the same ( but I am probably leaning towards getting Ladson and mckenzie), but just wondered what others thought of these 5 - and in particular what WCE and Freo suppoerters think of the two young guys playing out the year??

 

[swansfan51]

Yeah have 6 trades.
Does anyone see a problem with:

Armitage -> Dalziell
Chappy -> RoK

Sound fine to me

I'm going for League wins, and therefore prepared to use 2 of my remianing 4 trades this week to fix up my 7th defenders spot.

I plan on trading out bench players Urquhart and Nathan Brown (Collingwood), in order to get a decent back in either:

Bock or Ladson

and a cheap 9th defender in:

Josh Head, Callan Ward or Eric mckenzie

Prices and averages of these 5 possible purchases are near enough to the same ( but I am probably leaning towards getting Ladson and mckenzie), but just wondered what others thought of these 5 - and in particular what WCE and Freo suppoerters think of the two young guys playing out the year??

Josh Head isn't young, but his career so far has been affected a lot by injuries etc and he can't take a trick. He has improved every game so far after a pretty uninspiring debut. MacKenzie is highly rated by a lot of Coast supporters and looks like he has a role to play in their defence. I would steer clear of Ward.

Any reason not to buy Cooney?

Nope.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Let me rephrase that. Given his recent form, is it worth taking the risk on Cooney when I can afford Boomer?