Trades Round 8 Trades

[Cactus_]

Number 1 draft pick

Objection, your honour, irrelevant.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

It’s been very widely reported.

Sandra has been all over it.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Really struggling what to do this week. Tried about 20 trades and not happy [emoji20]
Feel I need to get a premo forward in? Zorko? And a rookie.. or I double down and save time next week..

Help appreciated [emoji106]

Chappy to Frederick, Rowe to Marshall/Zorko

 

[Axly]

Chappy to Frederick, Rowe to Marshall/Zorko

Cheers[emoji106]
I'm a little worried about Freds JS. But suppose he will make a fair bit even if only a couple of weeks.

Haha
They're the 2 premo forwards I've been tossing up between.
Would like to see a little more of Marshall. But looking good and another big score and he won't be this cheap again.
Zorko safe pick. Hard one.

 

[Megabattimus]

Thoughts on Jiath? Is it about time to cash him in? Trade down to Freddo this week or trade up to Ridley next week or the week after? What are owners thinking?

I'm thinking of doing him to Ridley next week. Depends on how he scores this week as I'm not against keeping him for a little while longer.

 

[No eye deer]

There's no team loyalty here for SC, I have three Freo players:
Fyfe, Brayshaw & new recruit Frederick

You've got the wrong Frederick mate

Does fishing lose its allure when it gets too easy? JuddgementDay

 

[Cactus_]

Sandra has been all over it.

Don’t. Sully. Her. Name.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Cheers[emoji106]
I'm a little worried about Freds JS. But suppose he will make a fair bit even if only a couple of weeks.

Haha
They're the 2 premo forwards I've been tossing up between.
Would like to see a little more of Marshall. But looking good and another big score and he won't be this cheap again.
Zorko safe pick. Hard one.

Think unless Marshall gets injured again he will be a top 6-8 forward this year easily in my opinion

 

[Cactus_]

Does fishing lose its allure when it gets too easy? JuddgementDay

Nope. Stuff like that never gets old.

 

[JarmanLimpey]

Thoughts on Jiath? Is it about time to cash him in? Trade down to Freddo this week or trade up to Ridley next week or the week after? What are owners thinking?

Personally planning on keeping him through the byes as i think he will come in handy when Laird, Short, Ridley, Lloyd, May and plenty of others are out round 13 and 14. This is unless he has another couple of games like last week. Then i’ll rethink [emoji848]

 

[Glorin]

anyone that has watched them both play this season knows on this rare occasion, CD have it right

Have you watched them both play?

I would argue they are both being underscored.
While Tmitch has less influence on matches this year, his weight of numbers does not match up to his scoring.
Walsh on the other hand is getting good numbers and having more influence than his scores suggest.
This also seems to be happening to a number of players, not just these 2 and the weighting given to work done by some players is far more out of wack than even the serious KOTD efforts of previous years.
Consistency is all we ask for and fair points reward for input.

 

[Duckworthy]

Personally planning on keeping him through the byes as i think he will come in handy when Laird, Short, Ridley, Lloyd, May and plenty of others are out round 13 and 14. This is unless he has another couple of games like last week. Then i’ll rethink [emoji848]

You were off to a flying start IIRC. You still up with the leaders?

 

[mochacinolatte]

I honestly don’t agree with this take. One player going up a bit is not enough to cruel a team mate, especially since JOM has not improved to the extent that he’s become SC relevant himself.

Well there is many reason why you can say Titch is down on form and one aspect is improvement of JoM. I am not saying Titch is going to score badly, all I am saying is that his ceiling might be lowered due to the improvement of JoM. It means more supercoach points going around and Titch isn't always the go to player. 108 average from JoM is pretty big improvement. Clearances and Disposal is going up.

 

[SC fish]

Really struggling what to do this week. Tried about 20 trades and not happy [emoji20]
Feel I need to get a premo forward in? Zorko? And a rookie.. or I double down and save time next week..

Help appreciated [emoji106]

Chapman to Frederick. Then probably LDU to best MID or FWD you can afford. Zorko or Bolton if a FWD

 

[Hava Alle]

You are in for a treat

Kents have gotta stop talking about him. The clamps will come.

 

[Axly]

Chapman to Frederick. Then probably LDU to best MID or FWD you can afford. Zorko or Bolton if a FWD

Reckon LDU is [emoji505]?
Was kinda thinking I'd give him one more week (after a week off [emoji849] ) to prove himself.
But yeah, been very dissaopinting [emoji25]

 

[SC fish]

Reckon LDU is [emoji505]?
Was kinda thinking I'd give him one more week (after a week off [emoji849] ) to prove himself.
But yeah, been very dissaopinting [emoji25]

Just had a look and his scores are pretty bad except for round 1. I'd have lost patience by now but you could give him one more week v Collingwood and trade Gulden (or Rowe) out instead

 

[Cactus_]

Well there is many reason why you can say Titch is down on form and one aspect is improvement of JoM. I am not saying Titch is going to score badly, all I am saying is that his ceiling might be lowered due to the improvement of JoM. It means more supercoach points going around and Titch isn't always the go to player. 108 average from JoM is pretty big improvement. Clearances and Disposal is going up.



View attachment 1120163

View attachment 1120165

Some AFL teams have three, four or five SuperCoach primos all scoring enough to be good picks.

Hawks have … Titch currently a sub primo, JOM sub primo … Impey as a forward line primo … Jiath back line primo (?).

Basically the Hawks have zero genuine primos to take point off Titchell. Whatever is going on with him I don’t think it is JOM having a little purple patch.

 

[Axly]

Just had a look and his scores are pretty bad except for round 1. I'd have lost patience by now but you could give him one more week v Collingwood and trade Gulden (or Rowe) out instead

[emoji106]
Holding Cripps alongside him is painful too.
Combo just hasn't worked out...

 

[SC fish]

[emoji106]
Holding Cripps alongside him is painful too.
Combo just hasn't worked out...

Always hard to know when and whether to jump off, or HOLD and hope they come good

 

[Duckworthy]

Kents have gotta stop talking about him. The clamps will come.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Don’t. Sully. Her. Name.

I can't rate that.

It's so my level of posting.

Do better kent!

 

[Kadog]

Settled on…

Chapman>Fredrick
Rowe>Bolton

 

[Max the great]

Based on what scenario was McGrath a bad pick for whoever chose him

Talk me through it - given you seem to be the self proclaimed Oracle of all things SC

Given at the start you have to choose 30 players and have a locked 10million

Given McGrath has dropped 30k or $30,000

Compared to:

Oliver dropped 60k
Dustin dropped 60k
Neale has dropped 140k Jake Lloyd dropped 90k
Boak dropped 35k
Nicnat dropped 60k
Rowan Marshall dropped 30k
Laird dropped 40k
Gaff dropped 55k
Josh Kelly dropped 110k
Tom Mitchell dropped 100k

Please enlighten me how you chose 30 players who all held value and rocketed you to the number 1 ranking

Aren't you talking about bringing him in now? Which would make him a bad pick. If you want to pay a premium for a bloke who will take up a valuable midfield spot and not put up uber premo numbers be my guest.
Also relax a little champo. X

 

[Max the great]

Thoughts on Jiath? Is it about time to cash him in? Trade down to Freddo this week or trade up to Ridley next week or the week after? What are owners thinking?

Hold him until his bye unless he starts pumping out big numbers again. Surely you would have bigget problems than CJ currently?