Ruckman for next week: Bryan or Richards?

[1821ellas]

I think Bryan. He really worked hard around the ground last night late in the game, and put a few tackles late in the game, and also kicked the goal. Richards may be abit better with the tap outs, but Bryan is far better around the ground and can be also used up forward if needed

 

[beez]

Re: Ruckman for next week: Bryant or Richards?

Martin Bryant? He can shoot down the entire Geelong squad

 

[1821ellas]

Opps, typo's lol....kept adding a T by accident lol

 

[ROWDY26]

neither, josh to go it alone and also bring in Iles or Shaw depending on form in the willy game 2moro.

 

[AsianWithAFro]

Bryan for sure. He gives us more mobility and can play up forward if nescarry. I think Richards would be unlucky to miss out as his been good suprisingly compared to his standards.

 

[Coin_Toss]

Guy Richards, he's got the support of the coach.

 

[Dale Didak #134]

I think Bryan. He really worked hard around the ground last night late in the game, and put a few tackles late in the game, and also kicked the goal. Richards may be abit better with the tap outs, but Bryan is far better around the ground and can be also used up forward if needed

Fraser is the around the ground ruckman. Richards is the tap ruckman, plus Richards is in good form, why kick him after 1 game

 

[chop_me]

Bryan is definitely better around the ground, but with fraser coming back, we need a ruckman that is not going to get smashed at contests... i think richards has a better chance of being "competitive".... so let's keep richards

 

[AsianWithAFro]

Bryan is definitely better around the ground, but with fraser coming back, we need a ruckman that is not going to get smashed at contests... i think richards has a better chance of being "competitive".... so let's keep richards

Hmm and Blake will be even

 

[Optimax]

for once wouldnt be disappointed if either played, expect richards mm seems to prefer him

 

[WakeUpPies]

Bryan, if he loses ruck contests he slaps the opposition ruckman, making them useless for a few minutes

 

[jerry springer]

guy smilie for me

 

[CarnthePies]

Bryan, if he loses ruck contests he slaps the opposition ruckman, making them useless for a few minutes

Exactly

Guy needs to get angry. He lacks passion

I picked Bryan

 

[Shellz]

Bryan, if he loses ruck contests he slaps the opposition ruckman, making them useless for a few minutes

God that was hilarious

 

[Stifler's mom]

Bryan, if he loses ruck contests he slaps the opposition ruckman, making them useless for a few minutes

That was gold, should be more of it. Having said that I prefer Richards.

 

[Jabso]

Re: Ruckman for next week: Bryant or Richards?

Martin Bryant? He can shoot down the entire Geelong squad

With Kobe Bryant in the side we'd *allegedly* rape Geelong!

 

[luvlicca]

Re: Ruckman for next week: Bryant or Richards?

I think that Bryan would be the better option, he may not be the best ruckman, but I think he would be better around the ground than Richards with Ottens and Blake.

 

[kemosabe]

Bryan for me.

I think if we can apply physical pressure all over the ground we will break the Cats and release those "KittyJitters"

As much as MM has been talking up Guy, I really don't think he has the confidence required.

I tend to like the "animal" in Bryan more

 

[martinclarke_43]

Is everybody serious they want Byran in the ruck instead of Richards. Richards should play in the ruck because he is playing his best footy in his life and he is winning tap outs. I know Byran is better around the ground but Fraser is better then him around the ground. So Richards and Fraser should play this week.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Richards without a shadow of a doubt.

Geelong have the same dilemma - Blake or King.

 

[1821ellas]

Bryan, if he loses ruck contests he slaps the opposition ruckman, making them useless for a few minutes

lol, quality..... We really need to put pressure on Geelong this week with our tackling and second efforts if we are going to have a chance of winning. Seeing some of Bryans tackes and second efforts late in the game makes me think that he is the best option compare to Richard who is nothing more than a tap ruckman, and not mobile at all and can't put the physical pressure on Geelong that we need... Bryan has the animal in him and can tackle well and put in second efforts and help put pressure on the opposition. He can also pop up and kick a goal or 2 or 3.

 

[SwanBet]

i no hes not very good but guy richards in a better ruckman than chris bryan, chris bryan is better around the ground but thats what we got josh 4, guy richards plays ruck then josh can rome around the ground.