Should Geelong trade to get a key forward?

[Mattster]

Originally posted by BigCat1

Jonathon Brown
Nathan Brown
Nathan Thompson
Whitnall
Kositchki
Croad
Lucas

J. Brown - Would brisbane really give him away? Only plus i suppose was he did play Juniors in Geelong didn't he?

N.Brown - Too small. Not a key position player

N.Thompson - Inconsistent. Can kick 4 goals a game sometimes.

Whitnall - Too fat But he can take a mark and kick a goal.

Koschitzke - Already has had injury problems, but still young. I would definitely consider him in a trade.

Croad - Not a key forward

Lucas - There was talk about us getting him a while ago. But he's now a few years older and i don't see him being what we need.

 

[Malarkey05]

Originally posted by Mattster
Lucas - There was talk about us getting him a while ago. But he's now a few years older and i don't see him being what we need.

Lucus turns 26 at the end of the year, so there is still a few good years left in him. I think Lucus and Jon Brown would be the only two you would consider (maybe Croad if he was cheap). I don't see us getting anyone on the first choice list

 

[ScouseCat]

Originally posted by phatandphreaky
Bit hard to kick goals when you're constantly on the defensive side of the ball.

And when the umpire pays a ridiculous decision against Kingsley in the goalsquare for an illegal sheppard... something we see every single week!!