Slobbos top 50

[RonnieRaven]

Correct me if I am wrong but didn’t Cripps win the Brownlow in 2022

Brayshaw is 24 and won the MVP BNF double @ 22 In 2022 and was runner up in 2023 just entering prime age 24-29 yet can’t get a look in for the top 50

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Correct me if I am wrong but didn’t Cripps win the Brownlow in 2022

Brownlow is not an accurate measure of the best player, or midfielder in the league. He was not a top 50 player last year and is almost 30, why would he be top 25

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Tom Green lucky to make top 50, Taylor is very good but is he this good.. not sure I agree.

Green just about a top 10 midfielder in the game, if not top 5. Will take the afl media a year or two to jump on because he’s at GWS.

Taylor every bit as good as our Weitering who we rate at that level.

I think it’s a very fair list with a few blunders, more than likely it’s click bait.

 

[RonnieRaven]

You're right, bit low. Coaches voted him #1 last year.

The Rag that slobbo works for ranked serong at number 1 in 2023 but couldn’t crack the 30?

 

[Doc1763]

Keidan Coleman making it simply on the back of a good grand final is a joke.

De Goey 7th best player in the league? What a ****

he hardly touched it after half time

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Hopefully we can win a game or two with the lack of talent we have on our list. Might have to start the rebuild from scratch

 

[Liam Boy]

Sam Walsh is already having an interrupted pre-season, it may have already derailed a chunk of his 2024.

Dare I say it - Larkey should be higher? What he's done at north is simply remarkable. Based on pre-season reports I'd have Rowell a bit higher too, he's finally added outside possession to his game.

Probably expecting, reasonably, that the goalkicking spread will be a bit wider at North this year with less reliance on Souv to kick all the goals. Which you'd hope for with fitness improving and the gameplan starting to cohere.

As far as LDU being on the list, it's really not that farfetched. If he gets a full season without injury he's a smokey for the brownlow, had a pair of perfect 3s before he got injured last year, when he's on he gets 30-40 touches, about half of which are the most outrageous dash out of traffic you've ever seen, umpires notice it.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Brayshaw is 24 and won the MVP BNF double @ 22 In 2022 and was runner up in 2023 just entering prime age 24-29 yet can’t get a look in for the top 50

No arguments from me on the Brayshaw omission

 

[james Dean]

Isn't it a prediction at the start of the year?

I actually like it when predictions make some calls.

And LDU will be better than Cripps this season put your house on it.

Mate, Cripps is a Brownlow medallist, multiple AA and multiple B&F coming off a year where he made the AA squad and captained his team to a Prelim.

LDU is not even fit to gargle his balls.

 

[Doc1763]

Mate, Cripps is a Brownlow medallist, multiple AA and multiple B&F coming off a year where he made the AA squad and captained his team to a Prelim.

LDU is not even fit to gargle his balls.

If I was recruiting for the future, I'd take LDU. If I was recruiting for this season, I'd take Cripps in a heartbeat.

 

[BennyGan]

Brayshaw, May, Dunkley, Hawkins, Libba, Warner I’d all have in before a couple of these guys.

 

[danster168]

Isn't it a prediction at the start of the year?

I actually like it when predictions make some calls.

And LDU will be better than Cripps this season put your house on it.

he's already better.

From a dees perspective, Newcombe over Viney? yeah, no. Viney made the AA squad last year and is in career best form. Will only get better with less Oliver influence this year.

 

[Cleavy]

where's Robbo's top 50 bevvies and snacks list?

 

[carlton_99]

Anyone else shocked Robbo can name 50 players...?

 

[Langford]

1. Bontempelli
2. Butters
3. Nick Daicos
4. Toby Greene
5. Petracca
6. Charlie Curnow
7. De Goey
8. Jeremy Cameron
9. Lachie Neale
10. Sam Taylor
11. James Sicily
12. Errol Gulden
13. Tom Green
14. Sam Walsh
15. Rozee
16. Noah Anderson
17. Charlie Cameron
18. Davies-Uniake
19. Tom Stewart
20. Max Gawn
21. Harris Andrews
22. Darcy Moore
23. Patrick Cripps
24. Jordan Dawson
25. Josh Kelly
26. Lachie Whitfield
27. Touk Miller
28. Jai Newcombe
29. Nick Larkey
30. Tex Walker
31. Oscar Allen
32. Stephen Coniglio
33. Zach Merrett
34. Caleb Serong
35. Jack Sinclair
36. Jacob Weitering
37. Keidean Coleman
38. Shai Bolton
39. Nick Blakey
40. Hugh McCluggage
41. Rowan Marshall
42. Dusty
43. Clayton Oliver
44. Luke Jackson
45. Jack Viney
46. Matt Rowell
47. Josh Daicos
48. Brayden Mainard
49. Ugle-Hagen
50. Will Day..

This list is now just click bait, gone are the days when Mike Sheahan would put it out and it meant something, but this is quite comical.. LDU Infront of Cripps, cmon... Andrew Brayshaw doesn't even make the list wtf.. 3 Giants in the top 13 and 6 overall.

Rowan Marshall - big risk given his inability to stay fit.
Clayton Oliver - a bit low.
Mainard - wtf
Will Day - maybe next year
Coleman - he plays so lose, but he is classy.
McCluggage - one of the more overrated footballers imo. Of course he is good, but.
A lot of defenders on the list.


All in all for a predication list it is not that bad. Who the F really knows.

 

[Langford]

Yeah. I love Jordy but he's not 7th... definitely top 50, but not top 10.

Finals beast, though.

Yeah.. he is a big game player (makes it hard to assess).

 

[Chadwiko]

If I was recruiting for the future, I'd take LDU. If I was recruiting for this season, I'd take Cripps in a heartbeat.

I'm a NMFC fan and I think this is fair.

If you told me LDU ends up having a better season than Cripps this year though, I also wouldn't be surprised in the slightest.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I know people aren't expecting much of the dogs this year but where the hell is Tim English? Easily a top 50 player imo. Bevo is just as mad as a hatter which diminishes his influence

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

he's already better.

From a dees perspective, Newcombe over Viney? yeah, no. Viney made the AA squad last year and is in career best form. Will only get better with less Oliver influence this year.

You realise Newcombe did as well?

 

[danster168]

You realise Newcombe did as well?

lol, did he? that surprises me. But good point

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

Brownlow is not an accurate measure of the best player, or midfielder in the league. He was not a top 50 player last year and is almost 30, why would he be top 25

Some just get marked higher than others though, don’t they.

 

[daicosdemis]

Meh. Sam Walsh won the Gary Ayres without even playing in the grand final. Tom Green had an outstanding series.

JDG is a top 50 player in the comp. Top 7 he is not.

Lol, you have a problem with JDG who kicked ass in the finals yet no problem with Charlie at 6 ? Ok mate

 

[daicosdemis]

Meh. Sam Walsh won the Gary Ayres without even playing in the grand final. Tom Green had an outstanding series.

JDG is a top 50 player in the comp. Top 7 he is not.

Lol, you have a problem with JDG who kicked ass in the finals yet no problem with Charlie at 6 ? Ok mate

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Lol, you have a problem with JDG who kicked ass in the finals yet no problem with Charlie at 6 ? Ok mate

I don’t have a problem with anything.

 

[Atomboy]

Rowan Marshall - big risk given his inability to stay fit.
Clayton Oliver - a bit low.
Mainard - wtf
Will Day - maybe next year
Coleman - he plays so lose, but he is classy.
McCluggage - one of the more overrated footballers imo. Of course he is good, but.
A lot of defenders on the list.


All in all for a predication list it is not that bad. Who the F really knows.

Marshall has missed 7 games in the last four seasons ?. Seems pretty fit to me.