So who's in the gun

[TheTimberMerchant#14]

if any1 saw that article about sando in the herald sun when he was about to pay his 200th, he had a list of ten things that he was going to set out to do, and one of them was to see the soccer world cup in germany next year. seeing as though this will be staged around june-july, i cant see bomber letting him have half the year off, so it may be curtains for sando this year

 

[Vaughan Pitt]

Buckland will be promoted to the senior list, Spencer will make his debut for sure next season. Anyone who suggests Spencer for delisting is a few sequins short of Elton John - a mobile, big-marking defender (that's Spencer, not Elton John, though Elton has also spent considerable time in the back half).

 

[bsg7]

What are your thoughts on the 3 rookie's currently in their first year (sheringham, batchelor and garth) will they stay or get another year????

 

[thehoff]

What are your thoughts on the 3 rookie's currently in their first year (sheringham, batchelor and garth) will they stay or get another year????

Garth has talent to burn. I think if he stays injury free and puts a couple of handy games together in the coming week he may even be elevated to the senior list next year.

When all the Nathan Ablett was going around, I went to watch the Geelong VFL side playing Sandringham in a practice game at Sandringham and fell in love with Brooksy, he kicked 5 goals in a half, 6 for the game, hardly spilled a ball, great vision and finishing off skills. I am very confident he will be around the club for a few years yet.

You just cant help but be impressed by Garth hands. He takes numerous was grabs each week and when I have seen him play they are contested marks. I rate him very highly. Class act. I am also impressed my the other 2 rookies. Mini Ling (Batchelor) gets a fair bit of the pill and uses it wisely and Sherringham is a tough in and under player who is almost the twin brother of 'beamer' on the footy field. I think he is the perfect player to fill the void (if any) beamer has left.

What do the rest of you guys think? My judgements are based on the 4-5 VFL games of have seen. Please advise me if i am worng in any way. I want too know more about these kids, espicially Garth.

 

[WestCat]

What are your thoughts on the 3 rookie's currently in their first year (sheringham, batchelor and garth) will they stay or get another year????

I would think they'd be retained unless there is something better in the draft as all 3 are first year rookies. From all accounts, Garth shows the most promise as a marking forward, but I haven't seen any of them and can't make an accurate appraisal.