Remove this Banner Ad

Something is on the nose...and it's Collingwood

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

HTPunter said:
It's the most transparent spin of all time. Even Pies fans who claimed there was no cap issue must surely be awake now. Phillips for 65 is not getting back into the draft or rejuvenating a list...
Click to expand...
the grand master plan to start the trade period with picks 16, 39 and 42, and end with picks 14 and 16 (next pick at 65). all for the low low price of adam treloar, jaiden stevensen, tom phillips and atu bosenavulagi.

they've paid 4 players (3 best 22) and a 3rd round pick to upgrade a single 2nd round pick to a single 1st round one. fmd.
 
How did it get to here?

How was the cap mismanaged so badly that they had to shift 4 players, 3 arguably best 22?

It's baffling.

Scenarios I imagine:

Scenario a)

Players had trigger clauses in contracts for bonuses/extensions that they all met unexpectedly. This would be a failure of risk management

Scenario b)

They deliberately over offered players beyond 2020 thinking that they would offload some by mutual agreement. This is a failure of player management

Scenario c)

They didn't process the payment totals correctly. This would be a complete failure of contract management.

Scenario d)

They over-offered players to stay as a method of narrative management, expecting them to depart anyway. This is also a failure of risk management.

All together it's just insane

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
BrisGirl said:
Reminds me of my primary school, school yard bitches, backstabbing and causing hurt.

That is just so sad to read. I am sorry for any member of any Club when Management do this to their members. Especially to hear the actual words come out of the mouth of the person it actually happened to. To confirm it actually happened....'no one likes you'. Awful stuff

Good luck to Buckley getting any respect from any of his players going forward from this day onwards.
Click to expand...


I have felt so sorry for Adam all through this...it must've been terrible for him to be told he wasn't liked etc...

..I've imagined myself in my job that I loved before I retired. Had my boss, who I had huge respect for, phoned me and said I was to be moved on because I wasn't liked by my work collegues.....well my god, I'd have been devastated and humiliated. I haven't and don't have mental health issues, but that would have really upset me...

Anyone out there who is happy in their job, gets on well with workmates etc just think for a minute how you would feel.

...so those in charge at Collingwood who have put Adam through this, should hang their heads in shame......and then hand in their resignation.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Supercoach Bargain said:
Where were all these people who didn't like him, threw up against lockers and thought he was unstable when he was being signed up for 6 years? They all were OK then?
Click to expand...

It probably did happen but think it would have went down more like this

pys0pP.gif
 
wian said:
Honestly think Eddie needs to go now. Times Up
Click to expand...
If he can get away with blatant racism, joking about Adam Goods playing King Kong, this is not going to end him.

The AFL boys club is one of the most insular protected industries in existence. When criminals like Dane Swan, Leigh Mathews and Wayne Carey are idolised by the AFL and their media colleagues, a racist narcissist like McQuire has nothing to worry about.
 
GWT6 said:
When criminals like Dane Swan, Leigh Mathews and Wayne Carey are idolised by the AFL and their media colleagues, a racist narcissist like McQuire has nothing to worry about.
Click to expand...

Wayne Carey....totally agree. I will not watch anything that man is on or talking about anything. Jesus, the guy glassed a woman!
 
GWT6 said:
If he can get away with blatant racism, joking about Adam Goods playing King Kong, this is not going to end him.

The AFL boys club is one of the most insular protected industries in existence. When criminals like Dane Swan, Leigh Mathews and Wayne Carey are idolised by the AFL and their media colleagues, a racist narcissist like McQuire has nothing to worry about.
Click to expand...
I have to ask - what's the mud on Mathews ?
 
Shadow89 said:
The worst part is, that this is after they stayed dead silent while all of this was floating around. Now that the trainwreck is out there, they look even worse for trying to justify it, given they pretty much ignored it for weeks.

They had a chance to get out of it and get ahead of it by trading up, telling Treloar, Phillips and Stephenson that they f*cked up, they have to move guys or they'll breach cap, and Ned Guy will be fired for not performing his duties as required.

Then come out publicly and say 'we want to retain Adz and Stevo but we can't afford to given the position we're in. As a result we will endeavour to find them new homes, in a way that is both fair to us and the player's and their respective new clubs. We apologize deeply to the members, but this is just a minor hiccup and we'll be back bigger and better next year.'

I came up with that in 60 seconds lol. These idiots had 3 weeks and they come up with 'we wanted to get some talent through the draft'...after they ditched elite talent for cents on the dollar.

Instead, it's now a complete mess, and players are publicly voicing their disdain over how they've been treated. It will only get worse from here - especially after they dragged Treloar's partner into it, and blamed her getting a job interstate for 10 months, for Treloar having to go. Absolute PR nightmare.
Click to expand...
Management admit it was their own fault? Won't happen.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ChesterTreasure said:
I have to ask - what's the mud on Mathews ?
Click to expand...
King hit at least a dozen players when he was getting beaten, always from behind. He'd be in prison if he did it today. It wasn't just the era, he should be remembered as the cowardly thug that he was.

People only talk about the Bruns one like it was a one-off. He made a career out of it.

And Dane Swan - one of the shittest blokes of all time. Bashed a cleaner at Fed Square for fun leaving him permanently disabled, and has refused to pay the compo that the court ordered him to pay. Google it if you don't believe it. But the media are going "how good a bloke is Swannie!!"
 
RUNVS said:
The way Collingwood used Treloar's mental health battle in this was rather disgusting too. They tried to make it seem like they were doing him a favour trying to ship him offl and that clearly Treloar did not know what was in his own best interest, when in reality everything Collingwood did was purely for Collingwood. Not once did Buckley actually consider Treloar's mental health, and I suspect Buckley really does not care about Treloar's battle with depression.
Click to expand...
I agree. To weaponise mental health issues to achieve a means is really quite deplorable
 
GWT6 said:
Really - How's Melbounre gone since he came on board?
Click to expand...
Off field, pretty solid.

On field, inconsistent but if Pert has done anything to hamper the performance or culture of our FD and playing group it's news to me.
 
RandB said:
Off field, pretty solid.

On field, inconsistent but if Pert has done anything to hamper the performance or culture of our FD and playing group it's news to me.
Click to expand...
He's done absolutely nothing off-field. He inherited the financial position from Peter Jackson that has got them through Covid. There is no future plan at all that he has put forward regarding a football home, and he has largely kept the exact same people in place. There is no vision no inspiration, no plan.

The team on-feild has been an unmitigated disaster since Jackson left. It may not be his fault, but he can hardly be praised for sitting idle at his desk for two years.

And he signed the second worst coach in the history of the AFL to an extension when it was clear that he was well out of his depth.

Pert has been a disaster for Melbourne.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

GWT6 said:
King hit at least a dozen players when he was getting beaten, always from behind. He'd be in prison if he did it today. It wasn't just the era, he should be remembered as the cowardly thug that he was.

People only talk about the Bruns one like it was a one-off. He made a career out of it.

And Dane Swan - one of the shittest blokes of all time. Bashed a cleaner at Fed Square for fun leaving him permanently disabled, and has refused to pay the compo that the court ordered him to pay. Google it if you don't believe it. But the media are going "how good a bloke is Swannie!!"
Click to expand...
Yeah I know about the swan thing - typical bikie wanna be.
Seems to be a protected species because he tweets something funny every now and then. Usually something re-hashed by the way !!!
I reckon he would have more dirt on Eddie than anyone which is why he appears untouchable.
 
GWT6 said:
He's done absolutely nothing off-field. He inherited the financial position from Peter Jackson that has got them through Covid. There is no future plan at all that he has put forward regarding a football home, and he has largely kept the exact same people in place. There is no vision no inspiration, no plan.

The team has been an unmitigated disaster since Jackson let. It may not be his fault, but he can hardly be praised for sitting idle at his desk for two years.
Click to expand...
We made finals in Pert's first year. Just missed out in his 3rd. Hardly an unmitigated disaster.

You asked a question and got an answer you couldn't argue against. What's the point in even asking if you're just going to put it all down to Jackson? Dumb.

From an FD POV we've added and retained Burgess, a world class fitness trainer and Yze (well regarded) added to our coaching team. But hey that's "nothing". Goodwin is under the pump in 2021 but he at least deserved a proper chance.

We also pissed off the stupid Darwin games as well. Another home game at the MCG.

Clearly you dont like him and that's fine.
 
GWT6 said:
He's done absolutely nothing off-field. He inherited the financial position from Peter Jackson that has got them through Covid. There is no future plan at all that he has put forward regarding a football home, and he has largely kept the exact same people in place. There is no vision no inspiration, no plan.

The team on-feild has been an unmitigated disaster since Jackson left. It may not be his fault, but he can hardly be praised for sitting idle at his desk for two years.

And he signed the second worst coach in the history of the AFL to an extension when it was clear that he was well out of his depth.

Pert has been a disaster for Melbourne.
Click to expand...
Third worst coach. Neeld and Drum take the chocolates.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Something is on the nose...and it's Collingwood

Similar threads

Cleric
Free Agents are a far bigger issue than academies and F/S, yet people dont complain about it.
Replies
22
Views
1K
juss
juss
LordLucifer
Opinion Time For A Complete Revamp Of The Draft - It's A Mess
Replies
24
Views
1K
geelong_crazy26
G
HugeJohnson
The AFL need to do something about ruck contests.
Replies
13
Views
949
kickazz
kickazz
Football Tragic
Why doesn't the AFL finally put the NRL back into its place?!
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
376
Views
17K
Gough
Gough
B
What is it with Geelong and BOO ?
Replies
11
Views
759
JackFlash
JackFlash
Art Vandelay_
Opinion 2025 Finals series - Is it the reward for patience?
2 3
Replies
62
Views
2K
Sttew
Sttew
GoEaglesGoSGIO
The "its not the coaches fault" thread
Replies
14
Views
834
Dirty Bird
Dirty Bird

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top