as i said in the phantom draft thread Marsh is a much better selection than McCarthy or Freeman at our pick, was a touch surprised with the time he ran, when you watch him in the WAFL you just think he's running away from average KPD's, but that is proper quick. he's a risky selection but wow if we were to land White, Flynn and Marsh in one offseason.... if they ever play in the same 22 we would be one of quickest teams in the comp. would be another gutsy pick. i do like him he has potential to be the best in the draft, also could be delisted just as easily.
Also Ben Brown suits us much more than Thorp in my view.
That article is a joke. Anyway!
Im not sure id go McCarthy as he seems to be the second best of a bad bunch of talls this year. Its another midfielders draft. So best available!
agree 100%, i have the slight feeling he sort of defaulted into first round picks because it's so hard to compare mid's to forwards. most people think a KPF is sure to be a requirement for someone in the first round so he is just put there for that reason... only a feeling though not as dominant as you would want from a first round KPF. he is outperformed by next years crop nearly already.