Opinion The all new 2013 trading & drafting thread

[raman]

There was an inference RFC were to deal with PA regarding white. Would butcher be a reasonable trade?

Sure, you can come over to my place and **** my sister, too.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Halls a medium forward, I'm not sure who you are thinking of.

Hall's 197cm. Not medium.

 

[FishingRick04]

Toy, Troy?

 

[Phhht]

I reckon I'm getting Hall confused but isn't he the aboriginal ruckman at GC? If so I thought he showed promise!

Think you are getting Josh Hall, aaron Hall (medium forward, indigenous) and Tom Nicholls (ruckman, Fijian i think) confused

 

[n4nirvana]

There was an inference RFC were to deal with PA regarding white. Would butcher be a reasonable trade?

RFC doesn't deal with PA

PA deals with White

White is an Unrestricted Free Agent

 

[charcolechaddy]

I know a lot of you dont, but I really think Sam Reid can play. Would have a crack at him for sure with Franklin moving in.

I agree think he would be handy for us.

 

[Bojangles17]

RFC doesn't deal with PA

PA deals with White

White is an Unrestricted Free Agent

Yea I realized he is FA, I think the reporter was a bit misleading, I don't believe they'll be a trade, we should get some fair compo as u guys are putting him on good coin

 

[Janus]

Yea I realized he is FA, I think the reporter was a bit misleading, I don't believe they'll be a trade, we should get some fair compo as u guys are putting him on good coin

Pearce was a top ten player for our club, went to Fremantle on good coin, and we got Pick 29 for him.

Ask yourself if White is worth more than Danyle Pearce. You'll be lucky if you get a third round pick, IMO.

 

[Noobz0r]

Hall's 197cm. Not medium.

Aaron Hall? Geeze, I didn't think he was that tall!

 

[Bojangles17]

Sure, you can come over to my place and **** my sister, too.

Sure thing , what part of snowtown are u in?

 

[Noobz0r]

Aaron Hall is who I was thinking of Ford Fairlane, 186cm.

 

[Bojangles17]

Pearce was a top ten player for our club, went to Fremantle on good coin, and we got Pick 29 for him.

Ask yourself if White is worth more than Danyle Pearce. You'll be lucky if you get a third round pick, IMO.

All depends how much u guys are paying him, takes the debate out of it, 1m over 3 years I believe which is triple what he was on at rfc

 

[Phhht]

Aaron Hall? Geeze, I didn't think he was that tall!

Aaron hall is about 6' 1 or 2.

Josh Hall is about 6' 5 or 6

 

[Powerade 08]

Best Richmond can hope for is end of the 2nd round which is pick 40 or so...

More likely to be 3rd round or no compo at all which happened with a few players last year.

 

[raman]

Sure thing , what part of snowtown are u in?

The old bank building.

 

[Malibu#27]

All depends how much u guys are paying him, takes the debate out of it, 1m over 3 years I believe which is triple what he was on at rfc

Making stuff up I see.

The reports were 250k-300k .... I remember line that was on your board even. Your compensation will be a third round selection, at best you get an end of second round pick as his salary is at the lower end of free agency deals. Pearce is getting well over 400k as is Chaplin.

I Also seriously doubt he was on 110k at Richmond, that's ludicrous. In fact wasn't your board reporting our offers were similar but our term was longer.

 

[Portmanteau]

Pretty stoked that we're getting Aaron Hall. Adds a bit to our backline.

 

[TheFVK]

There was an inference RFC were to deal with PA regarding white. Would butcher be a reasonable trade?

Sure, how about Vickery for Matt Thomas while we're at it

 

[TheFVK]

Yea I realized he is FA, I think the reporter was a bit misleading, I don't believe they'll be a trade, we should get some fair compo as u guys are putting him on good coin

No more coin than you guys are offering him, just extra years. I imagine you might get something like end of 3rd round.

 

[Bojangles17]

Making stuff up I see.

The reports were 250k-300k .... I remember line that was on your board even. Your compensation will be a third round selection, at best you get an end of second round pick as his salary is at the lower end of free agency deals. Pearce is getting well over 400k as is Chaplin.

I Also seriously doubt he was on 110k at Richmond, that's ludicrous. In fact wasn't your board reporting our offers were similar but our term was longer.

No he wasn't on much as he was pretty lucky to still be on the list coming into 2013. He was a big improver and most would like him to stay, we wouldn't offer much though as we need remaining cap for another ruck

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Pretty stoked that we're getting Aaron Hall. Adds a bit to our backline.

Isn't it just a rumour? And isn't it josh hall? Oh I'm confused.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

People do realise that we are not getting Aaron Hall right? it is rumoured that we may be getting Josh Hall who is a rookie at GC

 

[raman]

I am really excited about the prospect of getting Tony Hall.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Josh hall is a 197cm defender who is from Townsville. Has played five games and is 23 years old. Was one of the last guys picked up in the 2012 rookie draft (about pick 92).

Nothing to see here really, would be a project player at best

 

[Amstaff_]

Aaron Hall is who I was thinking of Ford Fairlane, 186cm.

He can come too