The problem for me is that Carlton has been assembling good lists on paper for a lot of years and just not delivering. They have had a lot of high draft picks and have done ever since they were penalised for salary cap breaches and collapsed into a basket case. The talent at the club has been undoubted for a number of years, but the revolving door of coaches amid unrealistic expectations has cruelled them. Whether Teague holds the job is questionable given the expectations being thrown around the media for them to "pop" this year.I think, as Carlton showed last night they have assembled a pretty handy list now. SPS is coming into his powers and Martin looks to have finally found his mojo. Cripps is as good as Fyfe/Martin/Bont Weitering is looking elite, Fisher and others are very classy. Even Levi is handy now. They are on the up.
I don't dispute the thesis of your post but I think Carlton are very underrated on this board. Their last quarter last night they were easily handling Richmond at times, just inconsistent.
As far as last night's comeback against Richmond, I am sure if it was us in Carlton's position we would have recognised that Richmond put the cue in the rack in the second quarter and just did enough from there on. Every time they were challenged they would throw Cochin and Martin in the middle and score a couple of quick goals. If I was a Carlton supporter I would not be taking a lot of heart from last nigh - not to say they won't improve, but I have my doubts.








