Analysis The Sack List: who stays, who goes in an AFC cleanout?

[GreyCrow]

12,13,14 all have flags

 

[Odog]

It will be
Hampton
Gibson
Dear
Otten
Kelly (trades)?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Redline]

It will be
Hampton
Gibson
Dear
Otten
Kelly (trades)?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I think six will go off the main list in some form.

I don't think we will trade Kelly unless we get a really good offer. Cheney is next but Mackay or Mcgovern might go. Betts might even retire.

 

[Scorpus]

A bottom 6 club would of been down the bottom of that list and the only reason we have not won a flag since 1998 is because the players of 2005,2006,2012,2017 did not deliver at the pointy end of the year despite all the other issues the club has had over the years.

So every club in the top 7 except Adelaide won a premiership in that period, most won multiple premierships

 

[JimmyTheScoop]

Some coaches at the club already know of their future, whether it be contract extensions or moving on/being moved on.

And........


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JimmyTheScoop]

So every club in the top 7 except Adelaide won a premiership in that period, most won multiple premierships

Gee thanks, now I am depressed.[emoji20]


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JimmyTheScoop]

Probably been suggested already, but can we move campo... anywhere else, Francou in the midfield, I think we also need another additional midfield coach, like Sydney and Hawks do.

I would bring Rutten back, as long as he doesn’t teach players to dive!

Going by that earlier article, Clarke isn’t going anywhere...


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jcpdragonx]

So every club in the top 7 except Adelaide won a premiership in that period, most won multiple premierships

Mentally weak on and off field. Prelim win rate of 20%, 33% at home. Culture

 

[ShadeyP]

So Caro saying the Truck has yet to recommit to Richmond 60/40 he is out the door, could the dream be true? Can we get the Truck back!

As long as he doesn't mind doing one last run to drop off the junk at port wakefield rd .

 

[WetCrow1991]

Top of the list for me are the people responsible for our 3rd quarter fade outs this year. Last week being the worst one.

 

[Mike Smyth]

Mentally weak on and off field. Prelim win rate of 20%, 33% at home. Culture

Who drives the culture of a football club? I would say easily pleased supporter base driving a mentally weak, mediocre, soft club.

 

[Mike Smyth]

A bottom 6 club would of been down the bottom of that list and the only reason we have not won a flag since 1998 is because the players of 2005,2006,2012,2017 did not deliver at the pointy end of the year despite all the other issues the club has had over the years.

Not being able to deliver in those years has 5% to do with the players and 95% to do with the club.

 

[Cleric]

The person who counted up our membership numbers.

 

[Mike Smyth]

Given this years disaster is self inflicted it's only fair that the club refunds the membership fees. When can we expect a cheque?

 

[Rotayjay]

No serious supporter should care how many home and away games we've won since 1999. We have won no premierships and that's the only important measure.

 

[GreyCrow]

Campo's actual results don't warrant his removal.

Midfield was the key growth area that took the club to the GF in 2017, when they were considered to have mid-table personnel. They did this in a season where GWS finished top 4, with their start-up concession talent. No top 10 draft selections for Adelaide.

The numbers tell us Richmond is winning because they can defend one ground.

They can perform one aspect of the sport well at one venue.

So it is structural inequity costing us. Not Scott Camporeale.

No, you are right , his results are not the reason most want him moved on. Some might argue with you over that but most , like myself, think assistants have a use by date.

Sure its harsh and moving on a very good assistant can be counterproductive but as far as I recall Campo has always managed the midfield. Stand to be corrected on that. Imagine all those players hearing the same instructions, the older ones snoozing through etc.

Fresh ideas fresh voices

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Who drives the culture of a football club? I would say easily pleased supporter base driving a mentally weak, mediocre, soft club.

Eh supporters are for the most part no different to other clubs. It’s always been the people in high positions like Chapman

 

[ad victoriam]

No serious supporter should care how many home and away games we've won since 1999. We have won no premierships and that's the only important measure.

Just curious, How did you feel after losing last Sat, and how did you feel winning the week before.

 

[Rotayjay]

Just curious, How did you feel after losing last Sat, and how did you feel winning the week before.

After Brisbane match: I felt frustrated by the way we played - good at times but not good enough to make the eight or play well in finals. Brisbane are not a crap side but the 2017 Crows would have won comfortably. Winning by 5 highlighted just how far we've regressed. I'm on record saying we will get 'completely smoked' if we play like that next week.

After Melbourne match: Disappointed and sad but not surprised.

 

[Scorpus]

Ah shit, we offered Hart a contract

 

[Betts are off]

Mentally weak on and off field. Prelim win rate of 20%, 33% at home. Culture

Thanks Kane

 

[Betts are off]

Given this years disaster is self inflicted it's only fair that the club refunds the membership fees. When can we expect a cheque?

I'm pretty sure the clubs still filthy at themselves for giving a free second shake of chicken salt on the chips at Footy Park in 1996...

 

[FantasticShirt]

Ah shit, we offered Hart a contract

OUT: Ben Hart
IN: Ben Rutten ?

 

[Doctor B]

OUT: Ben Hart
IN: Ben Rutten ?

That would be a great result for us.

 

[Scorpus]

OUT: Ben Hart
IN: Ben Rutten ?

Surely we can hire a coach that's not an ex-Crows player