Prediction Top 10 in our B&F

[Bring back Bas]

My top ten would be:

1) Laird
2) Talia
3) Gibbs
4) M.Crouch
5) Seedsman
6) Brown
7) Doedee
8) Greenwood
9) Jenkins
10) Lynch

 

[dogs105]

Doedee for the win

 

[GameofSloanes]

Thread needs a poll

 

[huludicidal]

You should have a bet with Marty too.

Doedee top finish top 3 and Doedee to finish top 10.

Top 3 will be hard but he’s been consistently good, I can’t recall a bad game. Top 10 is a lock though, so it may end up square.

Marty has Sloane, Tex and Hartigan finishing higher

Would literally bet everything in my bank account on Doedee finishing top 10.

 

[Elite Crow]

Thread needs a poll

That’s above my pay grade

 

[Elite Crow]

Would literally bet everything in my bank account on Doedee finishing top 10.

Same here

 

[GreyCrow]

The voting system was the same as last year, with five coaches casting votes on a 4, 3, 2, 1 basis after every game.

Final Leaderboard Top 10
Rory Laird – 222
Matt Crouch – 166
Josh Jenkins – 162
Bryce Gibbs – 149
Hugh Greenwood - 140
Tom Doedee – 139
Luke Brown – 134
Wayne Milera Junior – 134
Rory Atkins – 128
Paul Seedsman - 128

Comparison time

 

[GreyCrow]

The voting system was the same as last year, with five coaches casting votes on a 4, 3, 2, 1 basis after every game.

Final Leaderboard Top 10
Rory Laird – 222
Matt Crouch – 166
Josh Jenkins – 162
Bryce Gibbs – 149
Hugh Greenwood - 140
Tom Doedee – 139
Luke Brown – 134
Wayne Milera Junior – 134
Rory Atkins – 128
Paul Seedsman - 128

Comparison time

Laird
Crouch
Gibbs
Talia
Doedee
Jenkins
Seedsman
Brown

 

[big78sam]

And of course a top 10 finish for atkins will not stop the vitriol from posters in here

 

[Bob Neil]

1. Laird
2. Gibbs
3. Doedee
4. Crouch
5. Seedsman
6. Jenkins
7. Jacobs
8. Milera
9. Brown
10. Greenwood

Not too far off

Picked nine of the top ten - missed Atkins and had Jacobs.

 

[Squiba]

The voting system was the same as last year, with five coaches casting votes on a 4, 3, 2, 1 basis after every game.

Final Leaderboard Top 10
Rory Laird – 222
Matt Crouch – 166
Josh Jenkins – 162
Bryce Gibbs – 149
Hugh Greenwood - 140
Tom Doedee – 139
Luke Brown – 134
Wayne Milera Junior – 134
Rory Atkins – 128
Paul Seedsman - 128

Comparison time

Considering how long Milera was out with injury or shunted forward, that's a very impressive breakout year.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

My prediction

1. Laird - correct, no brainer though! Well deserved Rory.
2. M Crouch - correct
3. Gibbs - 1 position out, 4th
4. Seedsman - 5 positions out, 9th
5. Jenkins - 2 positions out, 3rd
6. Talia - 5 positions out, 11th
7. Doedee - 1 position out, 6th
8. Milera - correct
9. Greenwood - 4 positions out, 5th
10. Douglas - 3 positions out, 13th

3/10 - correct position
8/10 - correct top-10 (missed Brown 7th & Atkins joint 9th)

 

[kulak]

Well played Kane McGoodwin and huludicidal for being the closest.

I took your selected top 10, looked up where those guys actually finished, and gave you one fail point for each position difference. Lowest fail points wins!

For example, I earned 34 fail points:

1. Laird (0)
2. Gibbs (2)
3. Jacobs (9)
4. Jenkins (1)
5. Greenwood (1)
6. Talia (5)
7. Seedsman (3)
8. Crouch (6)
9. Doedee (4)
10. Brown (2)

I overrated how the coaches would rate Jacobs (I said 3rd; they said 12th; 9 fail points). I underrated how the coaches would rate Crouch (I said 8th; they said 2nd; 6 fail points). Etc.

BigFooty leaderboard:
Kane McGoodwin - 23
huludicidal - 23
Scorpus - 24
doppelganger47 - 25
Bob Neil - 25
Elite Crow - 26
James_37 - 26
jackster83 - 26
John Who - 27
Coopers - 28
The Sloane Ranger - 30
kulak - 33
Bring back Bas - 33
Golumless - 34

 

[kulak]

Results page:
http://www.afc.com.au/news/2018-08-31/club-champion-round-by-round

Round 1 v Essendon
Laird – 14
Crouch – 11
Doedee – 9
Brown – 8
Mackay – 7
Seedsman – 7
Gibbs – 6
Jacobs – 6
Sloane – 6
Jenkins – 5
Kelly – 5
Douglas – 4
Talia – 4
Betts – 2
Fogarty – 2
Atkins – 1
Hartigan – 1
Murphy – 1

Round 2 v Richmond
Laird – 19
Jenkins – 16
Doedee – 14
Greenwood – 14
Ellis-Yolmen – 13
Sloane – 12
Jacobs – 11
Talia – 11
Walker – 11
Gibbs – 10
Seedsman – 10
Brown – 9
Hartigan – 9
Kelly – 9
Mackay – 7
Milera – 7
Betts – 6
Fogarty – 6
Murphy – 6
McGovern – 5
Atkins – 3

Round 3 v St Kilda
Gibbs – 15
Seedsman – 13
Betts – 12
Laird – 12
Brown – 10
Jacobs – 10
Hartigan – 8
Mackay – 8
Atkins – 7
Doedee – 7
Douglas – 7
Talia – 7
Murphy – 6
Kelly – 5
Milera – 5
McGovern – 4
Jenkins – 3
Sloane – 3
Walker – 3
Greenwood – 2
Lynch – 2
Ellis-Yolmen – 1

Round 4 v Collingwood
Laird – 7
Seedsman – 7
Brown – 6
Gibbs – 6
Hartigan – 6
Mackay – 6
Atkins – 5
McGovern – 5
Ellis-Yolmen – 4
Greenwood – 4
Milera – 3
Talia – 3
Doedee – 1
Douglas – 1

Round 5 v Sydney
Atkins – 16
Seedsman – 16
Walker – 15
Talia – 14
Doedee – 13
Jenkins – 13
Lynch – 13
Greenwood – 12
Brown – 11
Douglas – 10
Milera – 10
Ellis-Yolmen – 9
Jacobs – 9
McGovern – 9
Laird – 8
Knight – 7
Gallucci – 5
Gibbs – 5
Otten – 5
Poholke – 5
Kelly – 4

Round 6 v Gold Coast
Milera – 16
Douglas – 15
Talia – 15
Lynch – 14
Ellis-Yolmen – 11
Atkins – 10
Brown - 10
Laird – 10
Seedsman – 10
Crouch – 9
Doedee – 9
Gallucci – 9
Gibbs – 8
Mackay – 7
Greenwood – 6
Jenkins – 6
Knight – 6
Jacobs – 5
McGovern – 5
Otten – 4
Poholke – 4
Walker – 2

Round 7 v Carlton
McGovern – 17
Douglas – 16
Greenwood – 13
Laird – 12
Ellis-Yolmen – 11
Seedsman – 9
Crouch – 8
Jenkins – 7
Mackay – 7
Brown – 6
Jacobs – 6
Talia – 6
Gibbs – 5
Kelly – 5
Atkins – 4
Gallucci – 4
Lynch – 4
Otten – 4
Betts – 3
Doedee – 3
Fogarty – 2

Round 8 v Port
Atkins – 13
Laird – 13
Betts – 9
Brown – 9
Greenwood – 8
Talia – 8
Lynch – 7
Otten – 7
Crouch – 6
Doedee – 6
Seedsman – 6
Douglas – 5
Ellis-Yolmen – 5
Jenkins – 5
Mackay – 4
McGovern – 4
Gibbs – 3
Walker – 3
Jacobs – 2
Kelly – 2

Round 9 v Bulldogs
Betts – 16
Ellis-Yolmen – 14
Greenwood – 14
Laird – 13
Seedsman – 13
Gibbs – 12
Lynch – 10
Douglas – 9
Mackay – 9
Doedee – 8
Jacobs – 8
Jenkins – 8
Otten – 8
Poholke – 8
Talia – 8
Gallucci – 7
Hartigan – 7
Kelly – 7
Murphy – 7
Fogarty – 6
Gibson – 5
Atkins – 3

Round 10 v Melbourne
Crouch – 5
Douglas – 5
Atkins – 4
Talia – 4
Jenkins – 3
Gibson – 2
Doedee – 1
Gibbs – 1
Laird – 1
Mackay – 1
Milera – 1

Round 11 v GWS
Douglas – 12
Gibbs – 12
Crouch – 9
Laird – 9
Brown – 7
Gibson – 7
Jacobs – 6
Fogarty – 5
Greenwood – 5
Jenkins – 5
Seedsman – 5
Talia – 5
Mackay – 4
Betts – 3
Ellis-Yolmen – 3
Hartigan – 1
Kelly – 1
Lynch – 1
Milera – 1

Round 12 v Fremantle
Betts – 11
Doedee – 8
Douglas – 7
Gibbs – 7
Talia – 7
Brown – 6
Poholke – 6
Seedsman – 6
Gibson – 5
Jenkins – 5
Hartigan – 4
Milera – 4
Walker – 4
Crouch – 3
Kelly – 3
Mackay – 1

Round 13 v Hawthorn
Kelly – 6
Talia – 6
Hartigan – 5
Otten – 5
Cheney – 4
Crouch – 4
Gibbs – 4
Jacobs – 4
Gallucci – 3
Milera – 2
Doedee – 2
Douglas – 2
Betts – 1
Gibson – 1
Jenkins – 1
Mackay – 1

Round 15 v West Coast
Walker – 17
Jacobs – 15
Laird – 15
Crouch – 14
Doedee – 11
Douglas – 10
Gibbs – 10
Jenkins – 9
Talia – 9
Cheney – 8
Greenwood – 8
Brown – 7
Gallucci – 7
Hampton – 7
Hartigan – 7
Sloane – 7
Milera – 6
Seedsman – 6
Mackay – 5
Poholke – 5
Kelly – 4
Fogarty – 3

Round 16 v Richmond
Doedee – 13
Crouch – 12
Laird – 9
Sloane – 9
Jacobs – 6
Jenkins – 6
Cheney – 5
Greenwood – 5
Milera – 5
Talia - 5
Gibbs – 3
Kelly – 3
Walker – 3
Brown – 2
Lynch – 2
Douglas - 1
Hartigan – 1

Round 17 v Geelong
Laird – 15
Milera – 15
Sloane – 15
Lynch – 14
Atkins – 12
Murphy – 11
Betts – 9
Doedee -9
Brown – 8
Crouch – 8
Jenkins – 8
Knight – 8
Gallucci – 7
Jacobs – 7
Keath – 6
Cheney – 5
Kelly – 5
Seedsman – 5
Gibbs – 2
Walker – 2
Greenwood – 1
Hartigan – 1

Round 18 v Brisbane
Greenwood – 17
Crouch – 15
Laird – 15
Keath – 13
Lynch – 13
Knight - 10
Jenkins – 9
Atkins – 8
Milera – 8
Kelly – 7
Brown – 6
Cheney – 6
Betts – 5
Gallucci – 5
Jacobs – 5
Talia – 5
Sloane – 4
Murphy – 3
Doedee – 2
Gibbs – 2
Seedsman – 2

Round 19 v Melbourne
Crouch – 14
Milera – 11
Greenwood – 10
Betts – 9
Gibbs – 8
Atkins – 7
Lynch – 7
Keath – 6
Brown – 5
Cheney – 5
Jenkins – 5
Laird – 5
Murphy – 4
Sloane – 4
Talia – 4
Walker – 4
Gallucci – 2
Knight – 2
Kelly – 1

Round 20 v Port
Jenkins – 16
Crouch – 15
Sloane – 13
Atkins – 12
Gibbs – 11
Milera – 10
Doedee – 8
Lynch – 7
Ellis-Yolmen – 6
Gallucci – 6
Greenwood – 6
Betts – 5
Brown – 5
Keath – 5
Walker – 5
Jacobs – 4
Laird – 4
Mackay – 4
Knight – 3
Smith – 3
Talia – 3
Murphy – 1

Round 21 v GWS
Sloane – 14
Smith – 12
Laird – 10
Crouch – 9
Keath – 9
Jenkins – 7
Lynch – 7
Brown – 6
Mackay – 6
Doedee – 5
Milera – 5
Gibbs – 4
Murphy – 3
Gallucci – 2
Betts – 1
Cheney – 1
Jacobs – 1

Round 22 v North Melbourne
Crouch – 16
Laird – 15
Otten – 15
Sloane – 15
Atkins – 11
Greenwood – 11
Doedee – 10
Milera – 10
Jenkins – 8
Gallucci – 7
Gibbs – 7
Seedsman – 7
Jacobs – 6
Brown – 5
Douglas – 5
Kelly – 5
Mackay – 5
Cheney – 4
Lynch – 3
McGovern – 3
Betts - 1
Knight – 1

Round 23 v Carlton
Jenkins – 17
Laird – 16
Gallucci – 15
Milera – 15
Atkins – 12
Betts – 9
Brown – 8
Crouch – 8
Gibbs – 8
Keath – 8
Otten – 8
Ellis-Yolmen – 7
Jacobs – 6
Kelly – 6
Lynch – 6
Mackay – 6
McGovern – 6
Seedsman – 6
Douglas – 5
Himmelberg – 5
Knight – 5
Greenwood - 4

Final Leaderboard – Top 10
Laird – 222
Crouch – 166
Jenkins – 162
Gibbs – 149
Greenwood - 140
Doedee – 139
Brown – 134
Milera – 134
Atkins – 128
Seedsman - 128

 

[kulak]

Round by round progress of the eventual top 10.

Crouch with a bullet! Milera too. Meanwhile Seedsman started great then disappeared after round 12.

 

[kulak]

Votes per game!

Notable:

• Keath 4th on votes per game. Clearly rated by the coaches. Hartigan probably now depth unless he can unseat Brown as a mid size defender.
• Jenkins 6th on votes per game. Sounds nice, but would have been his usual 10th-ish if our good players like Sloane, Tex, Lynch, BCrouch had been fit and firing. Still a good year by his standards.
• Gibbs 12th on votes per game (despite being 4th overall). Below Richard Douglas on votes per game. Would have been even worse if our good players had been fit. Clearly the coaches were not impressed.
• MGov 27th on votes per game lol.

Results:

1. Laird - 10.8 votes per game (20 games)
2. Crouch - 9.2 votes per game (18 games)
3. Sloane - 8.5 votes per game (12 games)
4. Keath - 7.8 votes per game (6 games)
5. Smith - 7.5 votes per game (2 games)
6. Jenkins - 7.4 votes per game (22 games)
7. Otten - 7 votes per game (8 games)
8. Doedee - 6.9 votes per game (20 games)
9. Milera - 6.9 votes per game (19 games)
10. Talia - 6.7 votes per game (18 games)
11. Douglas - 6.6 votes per game (17 games)
12. Gibbs - 6.5 votes per game (22 games)
13. Lynch - 6.5 votes per game (17 games)
14. Brown - 6.4 votes per game (20 games)
15. Greenwood - 6.2 votes per game (22 games)
16. Atkins - 6.2 votes per game (20 games)
17. Seedsman - 6.1 votes per game (20 games)
18. Betts - 5.7 votes per game (18 games)
19. Jacobs - 5.3 votes per game (22 games)
20. Ellis-Yolmen - 5.3 votes per game (15 games)
21. Knight - 5.3 votes per game (8 games)
22. Himmelberg - 5 votes per game (1 games)
23. Gallucci - 4.9 votes per game (16 games)
24. Walker - 4.9 votes per game (14 games)
25. Mackay - 4.8 votes per game (17 games)
26. Cheney - 4.8 votes per game (8 games)
27. McGovern - 4.4 votes per game (12 games)
28. Kelly - 4.1 votes per game (19 games)
29. Gibson - 4 votes per game (5 games)
30. Murphy - 3.8 votes per game (11 games)
31. Hartigan - 3.4 votes per game (13 games)
32. Poholke - 3.1 votes per game (9 games)
33. Fogarty - 2.4 votes per game (10 games)
34. Hampton - 2.3 votes per game (3 games)

A big well done to DMac for coming 25th on votes per game. Holding back the flood right there.